“Because….”

“You’ve never experienced it?”
“No…”

“Or maybe because your heart has been broken” he glanced at Remus

“Love doesn’t exist” Carlie repeated quietly

“Yes it does” Sirius said standing up

“Well then” Carlie replied standing up to match Sirius “Prove me wrong”

He smiled “Maybe I will”

“Er is this a private conversation or can anyone join”

Carlie get's sick of all the broken hearts around Hogwarts and blows up at Sirius. 
“But before I do that I have something to ask you?” She said poking him in the chest “What gives you the right to go around breaking girl’s hearts and expecting us to forgive you just because the girl was a slut anyways!”

“What?!”