Lunarpaw always knew that Ashfeather never wanted to go to The Shining Hollow. THe medicine cat appretience however, never wanted to know why somehow. Soon the truth would be finded out. But she decided now to remember the moments of the past.

Flashback 1

"Ashfeather, when will we go to the Shining Hollow? I'm traning for 3 moons ,and we havent been to this place yet."- Lunarpaw asked her mentor Ashfeather, when she was sorting herbs.

"Lunarpaw! We will go to the Shining Hollow soon. You have to wait."- Ashfeather replied, wanting to change the topic.

"Why?- Lunarpaw wanted to ask just why the werent going to the Shining Hollow when they should. However, she never said this out loud.

Flashback 2

"How's your traning dear? Are doing well?"- SIlverheart asked her kit one day, and she liked her on the cheek

"Silverheart, I'm fine. I know a lot of herbs now. Ashfeather is a good mentor."- Lunarpaw replied embarsed at her kin's affection.

"Did you see the Shining Hollow? I want to know, how was your trip there." - the silver she-cat replied asking at the same time.

"...No... I havent seen the Shining Hollow yet."- the apprietience replied shocked. Silverheart looked shocked in disbelief.

There was silence beetween the she-cats. The rest of the mermory, was a blur however ,and that was the part of the mermory, that was remebered.

And that was it. Lunarpaw looked at the moon sad, whishing she could knew why. And Starclan accpeted her wish.

2 moons later.

"Ashfeather! I'm ba... Wait! Ashfeather why you do have those scars on your pelt?"- Lunarpaw asked, dropping the herbs she had in her jaws shocked.

"It's not your buissness, Lunarpaw."- Ashfeather replied coldly, lashing her tail around.

Lunarpaw was shocked. Tons of questions were in her mind.

"Why?" Why she was so mean? WHat had happened? Is she hiding something? What happened to my mentor?- These quetions trobuled Lunarpaw's mind who was shocked that Ashfeather shoved her off. The poor apprietience was hurt by her mentor, by Ashfeather's words.