"We're over!" Finn cried, storming down the hallway furiously.
"WAIT! The hook up didn't mean anything I swear! I'm over Jesse!" Rachel said convincingly, but Finn kept walking. He didn't breakup with her just because she cheated, also he had feelings for Santana. The way she flipped her hair and batted her long eyelashes to her beautiful brown eyes, snapping at someone with attitude. He decided to take a risk and ask Santana out the next day. She's not dating anyone, so how could she say no? Finn thought.
Rachel stood in the middle of the hallway sobbing, hating herself for what she did.
"Hey, Berry...oh, are you okay?" Santana said, walking up to her.
"No! Finn just broke up with me! I can't believe I cheated." Rachel sobbed.
"Sorry, but it's your own fault for cheating." Santana stated, patting her shoulder before walking away.
"Okay, glee club dismissed!" Mr Schue announced as everyone got up and started to leave.
"Wait, Santana!" Finn yelled, running up to her.
"What?" Santana asked and turned around with an impatient look on her face.
"I...I was just wondering if you'd wanna go out sometime?"
"Haha, good one." Santana said.
"I wasn't kidding, please?" Finn begged.
"Um let me think about that? No. I don't want to be your Berry rebound." Santana snapped and walked away.
"But you wouldn't be!" Finn shouted back, sighing. He would have to do a big jester to get Santana. What should I do? He thought.
Then it hit him! He jumped up in the air like an idiot and walked out the door.
The next day in glee club Mr Schue announced: "Finn said he'd like to sing something for us, so take it away Finn!"
"Thanks, Mr. Schue. So I'm going to be singing a song for a certain someone." Finn said and winked at Santana who rolled her eyes but half smiled a bit.
He nodded to the piano player who started playing the intro. He took a deep breath and sang staring and Santana with a longing face (the lyrics he sing are in bold)~
I've seen her face, I've heard her name
I've lost my place and she's to blame
And I can't stand it when I'm staring in her eyes
And she's not looking back, it's not a big surprise
I've heard music, I've heard noise
I wish that she could hear her voice
The way that I do when I go to sleep at night
And dream my life away but she's gone when I awake
Sani, Sani...
Why can't you see
What you're doing to me?
The way her hair falls from her eyes
Makes me wonder if she'll
Ever see through my disguise
And I'm under her spell
Everything is falling
And I don't know where to land
Everyone knows who she is
But she don't know who I am
Sani, Sani...
Why can't you see
What you're doing to me?
I see you singing on that stage
You look just like an angel
And all I do is pray
That maybe, someday you'll hear my song
And understand that all along
There's something more that I'm trying to say
When I say
Sani, Sani...
Why can't you see
What you're doing to me?
What you're doing to me...
When he finished, he noticed his eyes were glassy, so he blinked quickly before anyone noticed. Everyone clapped slowly looking at Santana, except for Rachel who got up and left. Finn smiled at Santana, who was looking down awkwardly. Finn's smile faded and he sat down.
When glee club finished, Finn rushed up to Santana.
"So...did you like it?" Finn asked.
"Yeah...I don't like love songs much." Santana said looking away.
"But-but girls love them!" Finn thought aloud.
"Are you saying I'm not a girl?" Santana challenged him, glaring at him.
"What? No!"
"Well that's what it sounded like. Sorry, you won't be getting much of this any time soon." Santana snapped and caught up to Mercedes and Tina.
Finn sighed and face palmed himself before leaving disappointedly.