Leo's 16
Don's 14 (turning 15 on April 16)
Raph's 14 (turning 15 on June 18)
Mikey's 13 (turning 14 on March 13))

On January 14, Leo's sixteenth birthday, he was fast asleep, when he felt something land on his chest. Snapping open his eyes, he looked up and saw his mate, Mikey, who was grinning like a Cheshire cat. "Morning, Leo," Mikey said. "Time to get up."
"Ugh. Get off of me. You weigh a ton!"
"Don't be so grumpy, Leo. That's Raph's job," Mikey said, not moving.
"What time is it?"
"One a.m. I'm horny, Leo," Mikey said huskily, running his fingers down Leo's plastron and making his shell feel extremely tight. "Come on, Leo. Let's play."

Mikey nipped at Leo's neck playfully, leaving little bite marks and making the older turtle groan. "You like this, huh, Leo?" he asked.
"No, wait. We have to use a condom. I told you that I'm not ready to have babies."
"Ugh. How to ruin the mood."
"No condom, no sex. You know the rules."

Mikey scowled, got out the condom from a dresser and said, "Happy, Leo?"
"Yes. Now continue."

Mikey kissed his way down Leo's body towards his throbbing groin. He spread Leo's legs apart with his knees and rubbed at the soft cartilage between Leo's legs, until the leader dropped down with a loud churr. Then Mikey stuck two fingers into Leo, prepping him. "Wow. That feels so amazing," Leo said.
Mikey pressed a quick kiss to Leo's lips and said, "This will be even better."

When Mikey was sure that Leo was ready, he rubbed his own slit until he dropped down with a deep rumble. Then he stroked himself until he was fully erect, put on the condom, lined himself up with Leo's entrance and thrust inside. Slowly at first and then building up to a steady rhythm that soon had both of them churring and seeing stars. Letting out a deep rumble, Leo said, "This is fucking fantastic. Thank you, Mikey. I love you."
"Love you too, Leo, and I always will."
"Do you think Raph and Donnie will find love like we have?"
"I don't know," Mikey said, as he thrust harder into Leo. "I hope so. It would be nice if they did, so Raph can stop gawking at you! I hate it when he does."
"I'm going to come!" Leo yelled, and with a final churr, he came, spraying himself, Mikey and the bed sheets. Mikey came a minute later with a loud growl and flopped down beside Leo on the bed, panting heavily.

"Hey, Leo," Raph's gruff voice said from outside the door. "I can't sleep. Nightmare. Can I come sleep with ya? Please, bro."
"Ugh. That's the fifth time this week, Leo," Mikey whispered. "You have to tell him no, Leo, otherwise he'll never stop and it's just a ploy anyway. He wants you."

"He's my baby brother, Mikey," Leo whispered back. "And he needs me. I'll go. You know I love you, so don't be jealous."
"Of Raph? Give me a break. I'm not. No one could be attracted to that temperamental, stubborn, hotheaded jerk. I know you're not."
"Uh huh. I'm not. Why would I be when I have the most amazing guy I could ever want? I love you, Mikey."

"Leo?" Raph said again. "Can I?"
"Tell you what, Raph. You wait in the kitchen and I'll be there now, okay?"
"Promise," Raph said in a broken voice that tore at Leo's heartstrings.
"Yes."

Leo waited until Raph's heavy footsteps had receded. Then, as he wiped himself with a cloth and sprayed cologne to mask the heavy smell of sex, he said, "Mikey, I love you. I'll tell Raph we're together if it makes you happy."
"Yeah. He needs to know his place, Leo, and Donnie would be perfect for him. I hate the way Donnie moons over you too."

Leo went into the kitchen and found his temperamental brother at the table. "Hey, Raph," he said, sitting down. "You want some hot chocolate?"
"No, thanks. Leo, what do ya think 'bout me?"
"You're brave, passionate, loyal..." Raph's face fell. "Not good answers?"
"No. I was kinda hopin' for somethin' else."

Shit, Leo thought. He does have the hots for me and while I feel the same way, I have to tell him there's no chance of us happening, because I'm with Mikey. Aloud, Leo said, "Listen Raph…"
"Look, Leo, I've loved ya ever since I was eight. I knew then that we were meant ta be together, when you carried me home after I sprained my ankle. I don't mean love as a brother," Raph said, his cheeks flushed. "More than that," he added shyly and grabbed Leo's hand. "We have so much in common. Yeah, I know we fight…"
"Raph…"
"Let me finish before I lose my nerve. We fight, yeah, but it ain't because I hate ya. I could never hate ya. I pick fights ta get yer attention. I know that sounds crazy, but, I'm crazy for ya and I think 'bout ya all the time. Donnie said ya can have babies. I'd like that with ya, Leo. I don't mean now, but in the future. Someday. We…"
"Raphael…"
"I ain't done. Yer sexy, smart, funny, caring, ya make me wanna be a better turtle, and I couldn't live without ya. I wanna be yer mate for life."

Raph sucked in a deep breath, leaned close and pressed his lips against Leo's, who out of loyalty to Mikey felt obligated to pull away, but he was unable to. Raph's lips against his felt so good and right. The emerald skinned and golden eyed turtle tugged on Leo's bandana tails to deepen the kiss and Leo found himself eagerly kissing his brother back; his lifelong dream being realized. To kiss the hothead. He'd always had a strong desire for Raph, but had thought his brother would never feel the same way, so when Mikey had asked him out, he agreed.

Leo and Raph kissed passionately, tongues exploring, until the desire for air was too great. Panting breathlessly, Raph said, "That was my first kiss, Leo. Thank ya. I never thought I'd have one and it was everythin' I thought it would be. Passionate, sweet and with ya. Hell, I love ya. After the party, ya think we can go somewhere? Just the two of us and get ta…"
"Raph…"
"Look, we don't have ta have sex. Just talk, see how things go. Please. I got somethin' for ya, but I only wanna show ya away from the others, so they won't laugh, okay? We can meet up and I'll show ya."
"Raph, can I speak now?"
"Sure."
"I realized I was in love with you when I was ten and you were very sick that winter. We all thought you were going to die and the thought of that hurt something fierce. I NEVER felt that way about anyone else before. I never left your side and when you woke up, I was so grateful."
"So ya love me too?" Raph said happily, his eyes shining.
"Yes, I always have…"
"Oh, hell, Leo. Ya just made me the happiest turtle alive," Raph said, and kissed Leo gently on his lips.

"Raph, I'm," Leo began, and was cut off by Raph kissing him again. They made out for a few minutes and then Leo broke apart and said, "The nightmares. Was it an act of yours to make me be with you?"
"No. I get them all the time and I did have one tonight, but I also needed ta tell ya how I felt. Been tryin' ta for months. I wouldn't lie ta ya, Leo, because I respect ya so much. Will ya come back ta bed with me and hold me? We don't gotta have sex. That can come later. Yer my mate now, right?"
"Huh?"
"I mean, we kissed and stuff, confessed that we love each other. That means we're mates and we can have a bonding ceremony and shit and babies in the future."

I have to be honest, Leo thought. I love Raph, but I'm bound to Mikey and I can't just dump him after he's been so good to me, can I?

"Raph, stop," Leo said.
"I say somethin' wrong?" Raph asked, his golden eyes clouding.
"No. Look, I love you, but we can't be together."
"Why not? Is it somethin' I've done?"
"No, you're incredible, and if things were different, I'd be with you…"
"I don't understand. Why?"

"Because he's fucking me," Mikey said, entering the kitchen and baring his teeth at Raph. "So get any fucking ideas of him out of your head, Raphael. He doesn't love you and NEVER will."