Hey lovely people! I've recently been thinking about how cool it would have been for Sam and Dean to have a baby sister… but then she would have possibly thrown off the whole plotline of the show. So, in this fanfic I have tried my best to do the storyline justice, but I also added a sister to the Winchester family (Katie), and I had to change their birthdays slightly around to make everything realistic. So please read, review and ENJOY!
-warehouseluver13
P.S. I don't own Supernatural, because it belongs to The CW! The only character I claim here is Katie, because I made her up.
Winchester Siblings
In:
Pilot
January 24, 1979 (26) Dean
December 2, 1983 (22) Sam
May 8, 1985 (20) Katie
Lawrence, Kansas November 1985...
"Come on Sammy and Dean, time to say good night to your sister," said Mary Winchester.
The young Winchester brothers raced over to their baby sister's crib, and waited patiently for their mom to come in and help them say good night to the new addition to the family, six month old Katie Mary Winchester.
The brothers clung to the side of the crib and bent over to kiss Katie on her forehead.
"Good night Kat," said Dean.
"Good night Katie," remarked Sam.
"Good night love," said their mother.
Katie gurgled in response.
"Hey Sam and Dean," said their father, John Winchester, as he walked into the nursery.
"Daddy!" Sam and Dean both yelled, as they raced towards their father to hug him.
"Hey you guys!" John replied to his sons, accepting their hugs.
"What do you think? You think Katie is ready to toss around a football with us yet?" Their father joked.
"No Daddy," they said in unison, laughing.
"You got them?" Mary asked softly.
"Yeah, I got them," John reassured his wife.
On that note, Mary headed back to their bedroom.
"Sweet dreams Katie," said John, looking over the crib at his precious baby girl.
She looked over in their general direction and cooed. John turned off the lights in Katie's nursery, tucked Sam and Dean into their beds in the room they had to share before heading downstairs to unwind.
Suddenly, in Katie's nursery, the pink clock on the wall stopped ticking, and the lights in the room began to flicker. Katie's cries over the baby monitor woke up Mary, who was trying to fall asleep in her own bed.
"John?" She asked, turning on the lamp, located on her nightstand.
She noticed her husband wasn't back from tucking in Sam and Dean yet, so Mary got up to go check on Katie in the nursery.
She walked into the nursery, only to notice a figure standing over Katie's crib. She figured it was John.
"John, is she hungry?"
"Shh!" said the mysterious figure.
"Okay," Mary replied, still thinking it was John standing over the crib.
She walked out of the nursery and noticed a light flickering on the wall. After tapping it a few times, the flickering stopped. At the top of the stairs, she heard voices coming from the television set below. Mary walked down the stairs to investigate. To her shock, she saw that her husband had fallen asleep in front of the TV set. Only one thing crossed her mind at the moment; who the hell was standing over Katie's crib? She raced back up the stairs and into the nursery to find out for herself.
"Katie? Katie!" She yelled as she entered the nursery.
At that moment downstairs, John Winchester awoke to the screams of his wife. He climbed the stairs as fast as he could to find out what happened.
"Mary? Mary! Mary!" He screamed, as he sprinted into the nursery.
"Mary?" He said upon entry of the nursery.
As he scanned the room at first, he only saw his daughter safely cooing in her crib.
"Hey Kats," said John.
Katie looked up at him.
"Okay,"
As he went to tuck the sheets around Katie, something dripped on his hand from above. He looked up, and took in the horrendous sight of his wife pinned to the ceiling of the nursery. He fell back in horror, not believing his very eyes.
"No! Mary!" He yelled.
Mary, who was ghostly pale, just stared back at him, silently pleading for help- yet seconds later, fire erupted all around her engulfing the ceiling in unbelievably bright fast moving flames. John watched helplessly as his wife burned alive, still pinned to the ceiling. It was Katie's cries that made him stand up and grab her from the crib, making him realize he also needed to get Sam and Dean to safety as well.
"Daddy!" His sons cried, obviously they had been woken up by their father's screams.
"Take your sister outside as fast as you can! And make sure Sammy stays in front of you! Don't look back! Now Dean! Sammy! Go!" He ordered.
Dean nodded his head as his father pressed Katie into his small arms.
"Let's go Sammy!" Dean yelled over the sound of the fire, already putting Sam in front of him.
John watched making sure his children climbed down the stairs and raced out the front door onto the front lawn before going back into the burning nursery in a last effort to save his wife. However, the flames were starting to grow too intense, and John knew that nothing else could be done to save her. So, he switched his focus onto saving his children that were waiting for him out on the front lawn.
Out on the front lawn, Sam and Dean looked back at their burning house. Katie began to cry.
"It is okay, Kat," said Dean, as he began to rock his baby sister.
John Winchester came barreling down the stairs. He dashed out the front door and scooped up Sam and Dean, who was still tightly holding onto Katie. He managed to get his children far enough away from their house before it blew up.
By time the firemen got to their house, it was burnt to a crisp. Nothing was left; the Winchesters' personal effects, and most importantly, their memories were gone.
John Winchester sat on top of the hood of one of the police cars, cradling Katie in his arms, with Sam and Dean on both sides of him.
John Winchester knew only one thing that fateful night: the murderer of his wife was definitely not human; whoever or whatever it was, he was going to hunt it down and kill it just the way it killed his wife.
I know the story is rough around the edges, and I'll probably run into trouble if I ever get around to writing the apocalypse and leviathans but what did you think? Amazing? Awesome? Terrible? Please leave a review to let me know to post the next chapter. Also, I have no beta, so all the mistakes you saw are probably mine.
-warehouseluver13
