This is my newest story. I wasn't going to started a new one but this came to mind. Hope you like it.

Note:My OC, Katie and Kelly are sisters. I don't really care for Kelly actually last name or her real name so, I changed it to Buchanan. This is fiction, so I can do that.

Disclaimer: I don't own the WWE or the wrestlers. This story is fiction.


John Cena walked through the arena broken hearted over his recent relationship. He and Mallory had been dating for a year and he thought everything was just as it should be. But a car accident with her and her cousin changed that. Mallory woke up and had no memory of her relationship with John. She thought she was still dating Ted DiBiase and she told John she loved Ted. John walked into the locker room and saw Randy Orton sitting on the bench.

"Randy, things okay?" John asked sitting down.

"Not really." Randy replied.

"I know the feeling. Mallory still doesn't remember. She thinks she is still dating Ted and he is playing it up. He has always wanted her back and now he has a chance."

"It's all crazy. I miss Katie and she doesn't want to talk to me. God, how stupid was I to sleep with her sister. Then I didn't use protection and she got pregnant. Then Kelly miscarries because of the accident."

"Randy, you made a mistake. I'm sure Katie will eventually realize that and forgive you."

"I doubt it. I'm going to go see how Kelly is doing after the miscarriage." Randy got up and headed to the divas locker room.

John sighed once Randy had left. He thought about the accident and how it changed the lives of a lot of people. Mallory had been driving Kelly to the doctor and a drunk driver ran a red light and hit the car on the driver's side. The impact cause Mallory's memory loss and Kelly to miscarry. Katie hadn't been in the accident as she and Kelly were not on speaking terms.

Randy arrived at the divas locker room and knocked on the door. Maryse opened it and let him in. Kelly was sitting on a bench. He walked over to her.

"Kelly, I'm sorry about the baby."

"I know. I'm sorry too." She began to cry a little. She wanted Randy to feel bad for her so, he would stay with her. She wanted him ever since she first saw him and she hated that he liked Katie and not her. She always thought nothing could come between her and her sister but the moment she saw Randy it changed. She wanted him. "Are you going to leave me now?"

"No. I'm not leaving you." Randy replied. In reality, he wanted to leave now that she wasn't pregnant. He wanted to be with Katie but he felt like he had to be with Kelly to help her heal from the miscarriage.

"Good. I can't do this without you. Katie won't talk to me. I only have Mallory and she is in no position to help me."

"I know. I will help you through this." Randy hugged her. "I have to go and get ready for my match. I will come and see you after."

He quickly left and headed back to the locker room. When he got there, he saw that John was still there. He felt horrible for him because Mallory didn't remember the life they shared. That had to be hard to deal with.

"John, I thought you would be with Mallory."

"I called and Mallory told me to not call her anymore. She was with Ted and that was where she was staying."

"I'm sorry. Hopefully she will get her memory back."

"I don't know. But I'm not giving up."

"Don't. Fight for her. I wish I had tried harder with Katie."

"Randy, Kelly isn't pregnant anymore. Talk to Katie and see if you can work things out."

"She won't talk to me. John, I slept with her sister. That's not something you forgive easily."

"Just give Katie time."

"I know. But I cheated willingly. Katie won't forget that or forgive it. God, why did I cheat with Kelly?"

"I don't know. I can't tell you why."

"I know. I can't even tell me why I cheated."

"I'm sorry." John got up. "I have a match. See you after."

Once John was gone, Randy picked up his phone and called Katie. He hoped she would talk to him. It went right to voicemail.

"Hey, it's Katie. Leave me a message."

"Katie, its Randy but I'm sure the caller id told you that and that is why you haven't picked up. But please call me. I want to talk to you. I want to work this out. Just call me."

He hung up and sighed. He had thought about the night he slept with Kelly a lot. He had been hanging out with some friends and everyone was drinking. He knew Kelly had a lot to drink so, he offered to take her back to her hotel room. Once they got there and he helped her in, she kissed him. He didn't know why he kissed her back. But he did and before he realized it, they were having sex. He knew immediately after it was a mistake. But he didn't tell Katie about it. She found out when Kelly announced she was pregnant and then told everyone Randy was the father. Katie broke up with him and cut him and Kelly out of her life. She blamed them both for what happened.

Katie Buchanan was sitting in her apartment in Tampa. She didn't' want to be near her sister or cousin. After the whole Kelly sleeping with Randy came out, Mallory immediately took Kelly's side. This left Katie alone. Mallory was their cousin and always closer to Katie but she took Kelly's side. But Katie honestly didn't' care. Sisters were supposed to have a bond that was unbreakable and it was sisters' code to not go after a guy one of them was dating. But Kelly broke that and she couldn't and wouldn't forgive her for it. Katie knew the WWE was in Tampa that night but she didn't want to see Randy. He had broken her trust and worse than that, it had been with her sister.

Once RAW was over, Randy headed over to see Katie. He hoped she would see him. John, on the other hand, headed over to see Mallory. He arrived at her apartment and knocked on the door. Mallory answered it wearing only a robe.

"John, what are you doing here?" Mallory asked him.

"I wanted to talk to you."

"I have nothing to say. I love Ted and I'm with him. Now, I need to get back to him." She shut the door and headed to the bedroom.

John sighed once she had. He had hoped she would at least listen to him. But it was obvious that she had no desire to remember him or their life.

Randy arrived at Katie's and knocked on the door.

"What do you want?" Katie asked when she opened it.

"I want to talk. Katie, I'm sorry. I'm sorry that I cheated with Kelly. I can't explain why I did it."

"I'm sorry too. Randy, you told me that you were staying with Kelly to help her through the miscarriage. I get that okay. Don't make this harder by saying you want to be with me when you don't."

"I do want to be with you. I don't want Kelly but I promised her I would stay and help her heal."

"Then do that and leave me alone." She shut the door before he could say anything else. Once she had, she started crying. As much as she wanted them to get back together, she wouldn't be the other woman while he was with her sister.

She had just got her a drink when she heard a knock. She was surprised to see John standing there.

"John, what are you doing here?" She asked opening the door.

"I needed someone to talk to. I can leave if you want."

"No. Please stay. I could actually use someone too." She smiled. She noticed he was already a little drunk. "How much have you had to drink tonight?"

"Not that much." He replied immediately getting something else to drink.

"Do you think drinking is going to solve our problems?" She asked taking a drink of the whiskey he had.

"I don't know. But it might make things more bearable." He sat down in the sofa.

"I guess so." She replied sitting down beside him.

They continued to drink and before long were laughing and talking about everything. It was nice to just be with someone who wasn't really involved with the situations. Both needed the escape from reality but either knew what would come of that night and how it would affect everyone.

Please Review and let me know what you think.