****My First Story! Criticism is encouraged! Thank and please enjoy!*****

**I do not own Vampire Diaries**

"Damon, all I've wanted in the past few months is you. I've wanted you to love me, to make love to me, to be mine. But I can't shake the guilt I feel about Stefan. And I've come to realize, it's not guilt."

Elena hesitated and Damon smiled encouragingly. His eyes told her to keep going.

"I don't want to hurt you Damon, or Stefan. But I need you to know that I'm in love with both of you and I don't want to do this to either of you. I can't make a decision between you two and it's not fair. Maybe I should just go. I'm sorry for all the pain I've caused you both."

Elena knew Stefan was in the house, and with his Vampire hearing he was always within earshot. She needed him to know this as well. She dropped her head and began to cry. She told herself she would replay her memories of both brothers in her mind when she got home and then let both of them go completely.

Damon touched Elena's arm. She couldn't even look at him. He slid his hands up to her shoulders and started to pull the straps of her top down her arms. She froze, not able to meet his eyes.

"Tell me to stop."

Her breath caught and she looked down trying to focus on something besides his white-hot touch.

"Elena," Damon warned, "If you don't tell me to stop, I won't."

Elena stood quietly, feeling every nerve in her body light up, and her legs start to tremble.

Damon placed his hands on her shirt hem, and began pulling upward. Elena lifted her arms up and let Damon finish the motion. He ran his hands up her back and unhooked her bra clasps. He pushed the straps down her shoulders and let it fall to the floor. She breathed heavy as her exposed nipples hardened in their freedom. Damon ran his hands up her sides, around to her chest and sharply pinched her nipples. She let out a stifled whimper and breathed deep, shoving her breasts into Damon's hands. He massaged them, as he stuck his tongue in her ear.

"Damon," Elena whispered, hesitant to ask what she was thinking.

"Tell me what you want," he whispered, nibbling lightly on her ear.

"I want you both," she said slowly, holding Damon's hands on her chest so as not to let her go.

"Oh Elena. You think we don't know that? Stefan is warming up in the other room as we speak. We both love you Elena. We want to give you everything you want. You don't have to choose."

Damon pinched her nipples again.

"But right at this moment, all we want to do is make you feel so good, and make you cum so hard, you won't remember your own name. The only thing you'll know is that you belong to the Salvatore brothers."

Then, with vampire speed, Damon yanked the remainder of Elena's clothing off and hiked one of her legs up from behind. He then reached around and slapped her pussy and she cried out in pure pleasure.

"I know you like it when I spread your legs and tap your little wet cunt," he slapped her pussy again and then shoved a finger in her wet core. Elena bent her knees, trying to get him deeper, grabbing his forearms to steady herself.

"Fuck, Damon, please. You're going to make me cum before Stefan even gets to touch me."

"I don't think you realize what we have planned for you tonight. Now Elena. Get on your knees. Wrap your sweet little lips around my hard cock and suck. I want to watch you blow me."

He spun her around, winked at her and she eagerly got down on her knees. He had already freed himself from his clothing and his member was standing at attention. Elena eagerly took him in her mouth, and he grabbed her chin, tilting her face up.

"Good girl Elena. You like that don't you," he said, as he stuck his thumb in her mouth, "Oh shit, your mouth is so wet, I can't wait to feel your pussy. Or maybe I'll start from the other side. You're just begging to be fucked in the ass."

Elena blushes and couldn't help but smile. How these two Salvatore brothers always knew exactly what to do to her blew her mind every single time.

"You are so good. I think you've wetted me enough that I'll slip right into your ass perfectly. Stay on your knees and turn around."

She did as she was told and waited. She felt Damon sit behind her, then pulled her over him so she was straddling him, facing away. He propped himself up against the wall and steadied her over him. He then slapped her ass and she squealed. He grabbed her hips and pulled her gently down, slowly sliding in and out of her ass, stretching her out. She sat back, and Damon let her ride slowly, getting used to the feeling.

It didn't take long for Elena to lose all inhibition as she slammed down on Damon's hard length, whining and screaming in delight at every pump. Elena got on to her feet so she could pump faster, reaching on to her toes as she rode harder. She closed her eyes and threw her head back. Damon was grunting behind her.

"Fuck yes Elena, don't stop. Oh shit, don't stop. I know you like this, you love getting fucked in the ass don't you baby. Let's hear you moan."

"Oh my fucking god Stefan," she said, barely catching that she called out the wrong brother's name.

"I'm here Elena."

She heard Stefan's voice, every word dripping in sex, and she opened her eyes to see him fall onto his knees in front of her.

"Jesus Elena, you're going to kill us both," he said as he crawled slowly to her opening, looking as though all he needed was this. "Look at you, riding wildly. Can I touch you?"

She smirked a little, loving how sweet Stefan could still be, even when seeing her riding his brother's cock. She nodded, still feeling completely out of control as Damon thrust up into her over and over. She closed her eyes again and threw her head back.

"Elena, your hot wet pussy is dripping all over the floor, and no one is paying attention to it all. Let me help you," Stefan said, as she felt his gentle fingers graze her clit.

All of sudden, Stefan shoved two fingers into her and grabbed her chin. Elena moaned loudly and opened her eyes to look straight into Stefan's beautiful face.

"Oh fuck, look at you enjoying both of us touching you in all the right places. Yes, Elena. Feel this." Stefan curled his fingers upward and stroked her g-spot every time he thrust his fingers into her. He fingered her faster and faster. She threaded her fingers in his hair and bit her lip, trying not to lose it entirely.

Elena looked into Stefan's face, and all she could see was pure need. He smiled then took his other hand and rubbed the very tip of one of her nipples, never breaking eye contact. Damon reached around and did the same to her other nipple, and Elena screamed as she came hard. She heard both boys encouraging her to come undone and she thrashed and writhed on Damon's dick and Stefan's hand. It was the longest orgasm she'd ever experienced and she felt both brothers rubbing and soothing her through it. They didn't let up until Elena grabbed both of their hands to let them know she'd finally finished.

Her legs felt weak and she fell forward onto her knees, into Stefan. Her world was blurred and she tried to focus again. She steadied herself and blinked to see clearly. Stefan was staring at her. His gaze lit her on fire again and she knew she wanted more. She needed more. She grabbed Stefan's shirt at the hem and began yanking at it.

"I was hoping you'd want more you sexy little thing," Stefan said, as he assisted in pulling his top over his head, and removing the remainder of his clothing. Elena dug her fingers into his abs, feeling every ridge in his stomach. She felt herself wanting to drool over his hotness, and she reached behind her to grab Damon's hand, to ensure him that she wanted them both. Badly. Still.

Stefan grabbed Elena's face and kissed her deeply, and passionately. When he let go, there was more then just love in his eyes. There was pure hunger. He buried his face in her neck and planted wet kisses on her shoulders and chest, down her arms and stomach. Damon had begun the same process behind her, kissing her back, suckling her shoulder blade. Elena spread her knees apart, hoping soon that one of them would touch her where she needed it most, as she felt that familiar burn in her lower stomach. She groaned with every kiss.

She turned to the side and was able to grab both brothers' cocks, rubbing them up and down. Stefan let out a strangled cry and Damon drew in a sharp breath. She felt a little guilty, as this was the first contact Stefan was receiving. She pumped them both then abruptly stopped.

"Oh god, Elena, please. I need you. We need you so badly. Please, please let me fuck you," Stefan asked quietly, as he dropped his hands to the floor, trying to catch his breath. Elena smiled, and then climbed onto the bed.

"You know, boys, I am a lady. I prefer this big, soft bed to the cold hard floor. I don't mind a good floor fucking, but I think it's my turn to make the decisions for a little while."

Both brothers crawled up onto the bed, and Elena caught Damon's beautiful blue eyes. He was so intense with his look. She shivered thinking about what he has just done to her body and what he will continue to do for the rest of the night. She purred and reached out to pull Damon in for a deep kiss. She released him, then grabbed Stefan and pulled him over her. She hitched her leg over his shoulder and silently requests he enter her.

"All I've wanted for so long is to have you underneath me, naked and writhing. I'm so glad you've agreed to let us both love you."

Elena smiled, than gasped as Stefan pushed into her, roughly but not enough to hurt her.

"And I'm so glad you've agreed to let us fuck you senseless as well," Stefan said between thrusts. He pushed her leg out further and drove deeper into her. She grabbed his shoulders as he pumped faster.

"Oh god Stefan, ah, oh my god, yes fuck me, oh god," she moaned looking up at him. He could hardly contain his animalistic grunts as he watched the woman he loved lose control underneath him. He pounded harder into her, feeling pleased with himself for making her want him this badly. He wanted her just as much.

"Look how sexy you are. Do you feel how hard my cock is for you? I always thought I should be gentle with you, but now that you've agreed to the roughness, I can't get enough of your wet opening, dripping and waiting for my every thrust. I'm going to make you say my name over and over tonight."

Stefan's mouth dropped open as he felt every wave of sensation wash over him.

"Stefan please, your words are driving me mad," Elena squealed. She'd never heard him talk like this before. She loved it. She wanted more.

Stefan then pulled them both up and lay on his back, forcing Elena on top.

"Ride me, ride my dick hard. I want to watch your tits bounce up and down as you slam down onto my dick." Stefan tapped her bundle of nerves gently with his finger as she rode him, and she cried out. "You like that?" He rubbed it lightly then tapped it again, a little harder.

"Tell me how much." She whimpered and let out a strangled reply.

"Don't fucking stop. Oh god, I love it. I love it Stefan. I love you."

Stefan smiled and continued to talk dirty to her as she bounced on him. She felt wetness on her jaw, and reached up to put her hand in Damon's hair as he darted his tongue in and out of her ear. He shoved his fingers in her mouth and she sucked hard on them, getting herself even more riled up, loving that even a simple finger sucking could get Damon breathing hard.

Damon then trailed his wet fingers down her body and began rubbing her breasts tenderly.

"Oh god, oh my god, ughn ughn, yes don't stop," Elena moaned, slamming down harder every time.

"Feel, Elena," Damon whispered, "feel every nerve in you vibrating. Feel how wet you are around Stefan. Feel my hands wrapping around to your hard nipples, and the sensations you experience when every hot spot on your body is being tended to. Now Elena, scream for me," Damon said as he pinched her nipples hard and she did, saying both of their names as she came on Stefan's hard length.

"Oh god, oh fuck don't let me go, don't stop," Elena said quietly as Stefan drove up into her and Damon rubbed her body. She saw stars and her head spun as she enjoyed all the pleasure her body had to offer her.

Elena finally came back down, feeling anxious to tend to both her male suitors that had just made her world explode. She tried to steady herself, and Damon caught her as she fell back.

"You… you… you guys I can't… I need… I'm," Elena trailed off, trying to get her words right.

"Hush," Stefan said lovingly as Damon cradled her in his arms, "there is no need to speak. Not when I can do this instead."

Stefan then placed his hands on her knees and pulled them apart. She tried to object.

"Stefan, you've done so much for me already, I need to return the favor. You can't tend to me all night."

"Oh, we beg to differ my sweet Elena," Damon said, and he laid her back against his chest, as Stefan continued to open her legs. Elena stopped fighting as Stefan's lips connected with her wet core, and she writhed against his mouth.

Stefan lapped at her, darting his tongue in and out of her, rubbing her nerves with one finger, slipping another into her. Her eyes rolled back in her head as Damon whispered how good she looked, splayed out on the bed, humping Stefan's face. Elena's hips bucked up at the sound of Damon's voice, and the sensation of Stefan's fingers and tongue. She felt Damon's length harden against her as he watched her. She opened her eyes and the site of Stefan getting her off in his mouth made her cum hard, right then and there.

"Stefan, Stefan, oh god, ah yes," Elena let out a gurgled grunt as she watched Stefan lap up her juices.

Elena blinked, and suddenly she was against the wall. No wait, not the wall. Her back was pressing against Stefan, who was against the wall. She felt his hands close around each of hers and raise them above her head, around his neck.

"I think we've had enough of the bed. We thought you wouldn't mind us finishing against the wall" Damon said as he walked toward her. He grabbed her hips and easily lifted her up, as she wrapped her legs around him. She looked into his eyes as he settled her onto his length and pushed her back into Stefan.

Stefan slipped into her ass and she moaned as the two brothers lifted her, and she turned to put one arm around each of them. They then brought her back down onto both of their cocks at the same time. Elena cried out, not believing the sensations she was feeling. She noticed they both were quiet, and she looked up to see Damon watching his shaft slide in and out of her. She knew how turned on he was by the sight. She turned to look at Stefan, as he bit his lip and grunted low, trying to make himself last longer. She decided it was her turn to talk to them the way they'd talked to her all night.

"Oh yes, Stefan fuck my ass hard, give it to me. Damon, pound into me harder, I want you both to fill me as much as you possibly can. How are you both so big? Please, give it to me. Make me cum all over both of you. I've never felt anything like this before."

Stefan raked his nails down her back and growled low as he drove hard into her. Damon grabbed Elena's hips and continued to drill her.

Stefan came first, with the most beautiful sound of satisfaction Elena had ever heard. His head fell onto her shoulder blade as he ground his hips into her a few more times. He let out a euphoric sigh.

Damon finished next, whispering that he loved her over and over as he came down from his high. He put his hand on her cheek and kissed her softly.

With this loving gesture, Elena realized she loved both sides of both of her men. Damon was rough and dirty, but when it came down to it, he really was in love with her and could show her more then he could ever tell her. Stefan was always good to her, kind and gentle and she always knew he loved her. But deep down he had a fire inside him, only for her, that he had been waiting to release. And she loved it.

Damon held on to her tight, and Stefan reinforced his grasp. Elena relaxed against them both.

"I love you both, so very much. And thank you for everything. Please tell me this won't be the last time we do this."

Stefan and Damon laughed together. Elena took her time to kiss each brother sweetly and deeply.

****My First Story! Please be gentle with criticism, but criticism is encouraged! Thank and please enjoy!*****

**I do not own Vampire Diaries**