I am a die hard Finchel fan but recently I've started to really like PuckleBerry as well and I've been wanting to write Glee for ages now. This just randomly came to me even though I was actually initially trying to write something for Finn/Rachel, lol. Hope you like.
Noah 'Puck' Puckerman had stayed late for football practice that afternoon and had just finished showering and getting changed. Coming out of the changing rooms, he began walking through the hallway of McKinley High school that would lead to the doors outside of the school's parking lot when he heard a sobbing coming from the choir room that glee club used to rehearse.
Curiously, the badass Jew stopped outside of the door and looked inside and was startled to recognise Rachel Berry (A fellow hot Jew) sat by herself at the piano, letting out some quite loud sobs. Rolling his eyes, Puck wondered what over dramatic antics Rachel was participating in at the moment. He opened the door and walked inside.
"Berry, what's going on?" he asked, remembering his vow to be a nicer person this year no matter how crazy or annoying he thought Rachel could be.
"Puck" Rachel looked up, her large brown doe eyes filled with tears and Puck found that he couldn't tear his eyes away from her. Her eyes were really were the prettiest things he had ever seen and normally he was too badass to even think something like that. Normally his thoughts centred around things like legs and breasts and asses but never eyes or any mushy crap like that but Rachel's eyes were hard to tear his own eyes from.
"Going to tell me what's going on Berry? Or just leave me standing around here like an idiot because I have better things I could be doing, you know?" he pointed out, momentarily forgetting his vow to be nicer to the less cool people like Berry even though she was a fellow gorgeous Jew like himself and he should be nice to her just for that fact alone.
"It's Finn" Rachel sniffed."He broke up with me because I told him about the kiss"
"What?" Puck found himself exclaiming with surprise. Why the hell would Rachel be crazy enough to tell her boyfriend that she kissed another guy? Had she completely lost her mind? "He broke up with me for being honest. He promised he wouldn't break up with me" Rachel sobbed and Puck glared at her, forgetting completely about his nice guy act.
"Berry, Finn and I have only just started getting our friendship back on track since the last time I screwed around with one of his girlfriends. Why did you have to go and open that big, oversized mouth of yours and screw it up for me?" Puck was annoyed at her; Rachel could see that clearly from the expression on his face.
It made her feel even worst about everything that had gone down. She shouldn't have kissed him in the first place; if she hadn't let her anger get the better of her than neither one of them would be in Finn's bad graces right now.
"I'm sorry but I couldn't allow our relationship to go on and hide something like this from Finn" Puck felt irrationally annoyed by her answer. Why the hell did she have to grow a conscience and be all honest and that crap when Finn had been lying her about doing the dirty with Santana the entire time they had been together? Why did she feel the need to do that?
"Berry, you are the craziest chick I've ever known" Puck told her, calming down slightly and sitting beside her on the piano bench."Finn lied to you about Santana. Why the hell did you feel the need to be honest about a meaningless short kiss? What Hudson didn't know wouldn't have hurt him. It's not like we made out or anything" Puck pointed out to her but it didn't seem to comfort Rachel out at all, she still wore that sad kicked puppy expression that melted Puck's cool, bad ass heart just a little bit. And if anyone ever knew he thought that then he would hunt them down and end them. Puck was a bad ass no matter how much Berry's annoyingly sad doe eyes affected him.
"I couldn't lie to him or pretend it never happened; I didn't want to be a hypocrite and have our entire relationship based on a lie" Rachel replied and Puck let out a snort which led to Berry glaring at him."At least remember your manners Noah Puckerman" she added. At least she wasn't distraught enough to let go of the lectures, Puck thought with slight irritation.
"Wake up, Berry and face the facts. Your relationship was based on a lie. Hell, you and Finn started out because he cheated on Quinn with you so if anyone is the hypocrite it's him" Puck retorted.
"That may be so but I still couldn't lie to him" Rachel admitted."I don't think he is ever going to forgive me, Puck"
"You should have known that when you decided to put the moves on me" Puck smirked and Rachel looked at him offended so he added "Don't worry, I don't blame you for wanting some of the Puckster, all the chicks in McKinley do"
"For your information, Puck, I kissed you because your the only member of glee that is available and not currently in a relationship and I also knew you would not mind me kissing you as you seem to have enjoyed our kisses quite a bit when we briefly dated the previous school year" Rachel reminded him, her sobs drying up now much to Puck's relief.
He may have a weakness for Rachel's damn doe eyes but it didn't mean it made him anymore comfortable with comforting a crying chick. He usually avoided that sort of crap and it was one of the reasons why he did not do relationships that much. Too much crying and emotions involved for his liking. All Puck wanted was to get his needs seen to and that was it end of story except with Rachel for some reason he always felt like forgetting his own damn rules. She made him feel things that he did not want to feel especially since he had gone through that crap with Quinn and he couldn't handle going through that kind of hurt again.
Plus there was the fact Berry was constantly pinning and obsessing over Finn though what the reason was that attracted to her him was beyond Puck. Sure he was captain of the football team but beyond that he was pretty average looks wise and he had the charm and grace of a clumsy ass polar bear. Even Berry could do a bit better than that oaf and not to mention the fact that from what Puck could see, Hudson was embarrassed to even admit he was with Rachel half the time and could barely put with the amount of slushies that got thrown at him for it and the gossiping. Sometimes he even seemed embarrassed of Rachel's, larger than life, over bearing, self-centred, diva attitude even though that was who Rachel was.
Sometimes Puck felt like calling out his former best friend for it but he kept his lips shut as it was none of his business anyway and he was too busy having his own life and getting laid as often as possible by as many girls as he could.
"Look Berry, I'm calling your bluff here. I think that you chose to kiss me for a reason" Puck told her smugly."You knew it would hurt Finn and he'd break up with you but you chose me anyway. You know you could have always gone to someone outside of Glee club and I'm pretty sure they'd be more than happy to make out with a hot Jew like yourself but you still picked me"
"Maybe that is true but I do not have any romantic feelings for you Noah, no matter what our unfortunate mistake of a kiss has lead you to believe. I didn't mean to lead you on", Rachel replied in her usual dignified manner that was just another one of her irritating quirks but still for some reason Puck found himself into her anyway.
"So you wouldn't mind if I kissed you again then?" Puck smirked and Rachel shifted away from him, looking nervous.
"Noah, Finn is your best friend and I still harbour some hope, no matter what has occurred between us, that Finn will restart a relationship with me in the future. I also do not believe that a kiss between us would be such a good-"but Rachel was cut off mid-dialogue when Puck slammed his lips against her own.
Rachel let out a moan and Puck felt inwardly smug. He knew he was right, Rachel was attracted to him and felt something for him no matter what she said or believed. She was soon kissing him right back and Puck felt himself begin to get slightly breathless quickly. This kiss was the best damn thing he had ever felt from anyone and that was saying something since he had kissed most of the Cheerio's and then some. Eventually, they needed to come up for air and Puck pulled away from her with a smug expression. Rachel looked stunned.
"I knew you couldn't resist the awesomeness that is me, Berry" Puck declared knowingly."I'll be around if you change your mind about not having romantic feelings for me"
With that said, he got up from the bench that he had sat on with her and gave her a wink before leaving her alone, stunned in the choir room.