Ok so slight update before I begin this one-shot.
If Glee Were Different it Would Go Like This: I havent been updating this story at all because I'm working on some rewrites, I want to take it in a slightly different direction and add more detail so for now I'm not updating that one.
You're an Idiot, But I'll help you: I'll be uploading new chapters for this story really soon, I'm just deciding on a few plot ideas before I do.
Now about this story, I got the idea for it while doing a Puckleberry RP with a friend of mine, it's just a one-shot for now but if you guys think it should be turned into a multi chapter story let me know in the reviews :) Love Me Like You Do by Ellie Goulding will be sung by Rachel at some point in this story, its a good song. (The movie its from is not my cup of tea, I only like the song)
Sentences written this way are flashbacks.
Now on with the story.
Rachel wrapped her arms around herself sadly while she stood around the piano with the rest of the glee members. She had just turned down the opportunity to sing a solo offering the song to Mercedes and Tina instead. Puck stood behind her protectively looking at the people in the room practically daring them to say something negative to her about what happened between her and Finn just moments ago. He didn't touch her or speak to her in a comforting manner, but he stood close by to keep her safe from the harsh words he knew the people in the room were capable of.
A few days ago Santana had harshly told Rachel about how she took Finn's virginity and about how Finn was lying to her about it. Rachel was devastated and everybody had assumed she made out with Puck that night to get back at Finn. That wasn't the case at all.
Two days ago.
Puck walked up behind Rachel while she sadly watched as Santana flirted with Finn and smirked at Rachel before walking to cheerios practice. Puck rolled his eyes at Santana before touching Rachel's arm. "Hey, are you ok?" He asked gently when he saw the unshed tears in Rachel's eyes. He frowned and checked to see if Finn was watching before leading Rachel outside to his truck so they could talk.
The other gleeks didn't know this but Puck and Rachel had actually been close friends before sophomore year when Puck turned into a douchbag. After they dated last year their friendship started up once more.
Now Puck could Read Rachel like a book and he knew she needed to talk to someone, he was happy to do that for her. "Talk to me baby."
Rachel smiled a little at the nickname, Noah Puckerman was known for charming girls often calling them "Babe" or "Sexy" but she was the only one he ever called baby. She sat down beside him closing the door before she sighed sadly.
"Finn lied to me Noah...I told him that I hadn't really slept with Jesse. I thought that he'd never slept with Santana either because last year that's what he told me. I thought that we'd be each others firsts..." Tears started to slide down her cheeks as she spoke. "Now I found out that he's been lying to me, that he slept with the one person who tries to make my life a living hell everyday of my life and he never defends me!"
She was starting to get hysterical and Puck tried to calm her down by hugging her. She sniffled against his chest. "You always stick up for me Noah, when nobody else does. I just wish Finn were like that..."
Puck chuckled softly while he rubbed her back. "I've known Finn a long time Rach, he's always been kind of dense when it comes to girls. But honestly...I don't think he's the right guy for you Rachel.."
She pulled away from him and frowned, confusion splashing her features. "I love him Noah, of course he's the right guy for me. Why would you say something like that?" She started to reach for the door before he stopped her.
"What if there's someone better out there for you?" He asked desperately not wanting her to go. "Someone...like me?" He felt like such a wuss but he wasn't afraid to be this way around her.
He eyes widened when she realized what he was implying. "Noah I..."
He shook his head. "It's ok Rach. it was a stupid thing to say I'm-" He was cut off when she crashed her lips against his in what had to be the most intense kiss he'd ever experienced thus far.
After thirty minutes he found himself on his back against the seat of his truck grabbing Rachels ass and pressing himself against her while they made out. His shirt had long since come off and he didn't want to let her go but he couldn't do this while she was still with Finn. "Rach wait..."
"What's wrong? Did I bite you again?" She frowned and he chuckled while brushing some of her hair out of her face.
"Baby you can bite me anytime, its just that I can't do this to Finn again. I want you. you don't even know how much I do. But I can't do it like this, that was the old me."
Rachel nodded and moved so he could sit up. "I have to tell Finn..."
Finn had broken up with her after she told him she'd made out with Puck before sectionals, She was devastated of course but she confided in Puck later when they were alone how relieved she was.
Rachel huddled close to one of the large trees on the lot to attempt to avoid the snow while she dialed Puck's number. He answered the phone laughing. "Hey baby! Hold on one second." He paused his game and told Sam he'd be right back before taking his headset off. "Ok I'm back, what's up Princess?"
Rachel shivered and pulled her coat closer around her. "Noah could you come and pick me up? I'm at the Christmas tree lot right outside of town." Puck stood up and got dressed after putting his phone on speaker.
"Baby what are you doing on a Christmas tree lot? We're Jewish." He teased, causing her to laugh despite how miserable she felt.
"I'll explain everything when you get here, and please hurry I don't want to contract frostbite." Puck left his house and stayed on the phone with her until he got there. She climbed into his car thankful for the heater and that he brought her a blanket. "So, you wanna tell me why you're out here in the cold alone at night? With no car at that?" She could tell he was worried about her which was the lat thing she wanted when she came out here.
"I felt bad about what happened with Finn, so as an attempt to make it up to him I brought him out here to get a new tree for the choir room. We were both looking on opposite sides of the lot and when I turned the corner I bumped into him. I'm not very sure how or why it happened but he kissed me..." She saw hurt in Puck's eyes for a moment so she quickly continued her story. "I guess he quickly remembered what I did to him because he pulled away, told me we were officially broken up, and just left me there!" she folded her arms angrily. "I didn't even want him to kiss me, I'm so mad Noah!"
Puck pulled her against his side while he drove and rubbed her arm. "Don't worry about it babe, I'll handle it." When she quickly looked up at him with a worried expression on her face he tried to calm her. "There wont be any violence I promise, I just meant I'd talk to him." She relaxed and leaned back against him while she messed with the radio.
Over the course of the holidays Puck and Rachel began a secret relationship, it's not that they wanted to hide it out of embarrassment or anything. Rachel just wanted to wait because she didn't want Finn hitting Puck or Puck going back to juvie. He was still on probation after all and she didn't want to lose him.
Her fathers were out of town for the week on business and a short vacation as well so Puck was spending a lot of time at her house with her, he didn't want her to be alone. He laid with her in her bed one evening content just to hold her, he knew she wasn't ready for sex and he was fine with that. "You know you're beautiful right?" He smiled Lazily while rubbing her back.
Rachel smiled and sighed contently as she nuzzled her head against his chest. "Maybe..." The tiny brunette said softly as she blushed, looking back at him before she pressed a kiss to his jaw lightly. "You're handsome..." She whispered as she rubbed his chest, she loved how broad it was. She always found herself slightly aroused when she saw his nipple ring. She was a little embarrassed about that but he just found it hot.
He smiled and pressed his forehead against hers. "I've got something to tell you babe..." He pulled her closer to his chest and pressed his face against her hair so he could breathe in the smell of her vanilla shampoo.
"What is it?" Rachel asked softly as she looked into his eyes and smiled, stroking his face lovingly. "Did you pass that math test I helped you study for?"
"Well yeah." He chuckled. "But that's not what I wanted to tell you, what I wanted to tell you is...I love you baby. I feel like...like I know for sure you're the only girl I want and when we graduate next year I'm following you to New York." He smiled.
"I love you, too, Noah." Her eyes lit up and she snuggled closer to him. "You know, your mother had a feeling that I would be the one to tie you down." Rachel whispered teasingly as she nuzzled her nose against his and pecked his lips lovingly.
He chuckled and leaned into her kiss. "If your dads still aren't going to be home I could stay with you again tonight. Not to do anything sexual, just to be here with you so you're not alone." He said quickly not wanting her to think that he told her he loved her just to get into her pants.
"Well, we could make dinner together? A filet mignon and pasta with vodka sauce, and a salad, and bread sound good." Rachel said as she sat up and got off the bed, flattening her skirt. "What do you think? I'm hungry."
He stood up and stretched before wrapping an arm around her. "Sounds good babe, but you'll have to show me what to do for some things." He chuckled and kissed her nose.
Rachel smiled and took his hand, leading him downstairs. "Don't worry. I'll let you stir the sauce. Sound good?" The brunette asked as she went to get everything out to cook.
He chuckled and got the things she needed from the high cabinets that she couldn't reach. "Sure babe whatever you want me to do I'll do." He set the things down on the counter for her and got the pots out next.
Rachel seasoned the filet mignon before she placed it in the oven to cook along with the garlic bread she had made herself (there was a flour fight between the two of them during that part.) before she began to cook the sauce and noodles. "You can make the salad. It's not that hard." She teased before lovingly kissing his cheek.
He cleaned up the last of the flour mess and nodded. He pulled various vegetables out of the fridge before chopping them up and adding cheese, he knew how much she loved cheese. "How's this babe?"
Rachel looked over at him as she mixed a salad dressing together. "Perfect." She smiled as everything finished cooking after a while. "Yay! Dinner's done!" The brunette made their plates and set them down before she sat with him to eat.
He took a bite of his food and closed his eyes savoring the flavor. "Mm... I could get used to this babe, you're an awesome cook." He smirked and kissed her hand before eating more of his food.
"I've learned a lot recently." Rachel said with a smile as she continued to eat her food, moaning softly. "So good. I'm proud of myself." She nodded and drank some of her juice.
He chuckled and did the dishes for her once they were done eating. "Follow me babe." He smiled and pulled her into the living room, putting a slow song on before pulling her against his chest gently.
"Noah... you're such a hopeless romantic." Rachel smiled as she blushed and slow danced with him, sighing contently. "This is nice..." Since they were keeping their relationship a secret for the moment, it made them more intimate behind closed doors.
He kissed the top of her of her head while they gently swayed to the music. "You're the only girl who's ever given me the chance to be." He smiled.
"I'm glad it was me." Rachel whispered as she looked up at him and tilted her head up a bit to kiss him softly, wrapping her arms around his neck.
He wrapped his arms securely around her waist and held her while they kissed. "I love you..." He mumbled against her lips with a slight smile.
"I love you, too..." Rachel whispered as she kissed him deeply, rubbing his arms before she pulled away. "Make love to me, Noah." She said as she looked into his eyes.
His eyes widened in surprise and his eyebrows shot up so high they looked like they might leave his face. "Baby really? Are you sure about this?"
"I'm more than sure." Rachel smiled softly as she rubbed his chest and pressed a few kisses along his jaw and neck lovingly. "Please?"
He didn't need to be asked twice, he scooped her up and carried her to her bedroom. He wanted everything to be just right, he wanted her to be comfortable. "Do you want to undress each other baby?"
Rachel nodded her head and smiled as she spoke softly. "Sure." The brunette began to undress him slowly. She undid the buttons on his shirt and slid it off his shoulders watching it fall to the floor. Next she she slid off the long sleeved white shirt he was wearing underneath. He stood there in a black wife beater and blue jeans. She waited to remove the wife beater and went for his belt instead, she carefully unlatched it and unbuttoned his jeans. She was surprised when she had realized he'd gone commando that day never seeing a naked man before in the flesh. A blush crept on her cheeks.
He chuckled at how cute she was, he gently held her hands together and kissed them. "It's ok, it doesn't bite." He teased motioning to his circumcised cock, it wasn't hard just yet. He removed his wife beater and moved closer to her "Want me to undress you now baby?" He smiled reassuringly.
Rachel giggled cutely as she covered her face before she nodded. "Uh-Huh." The brunette smiled as she lifted her arms up to allow him to undress her.
He removed her gray sweater, sliding it above her head while he gently kissed her neck. He reached down and unzipped her skirt before sliding it off. He rubbed her sides gently and kissed her chest while unhooking her bra. Her breasts were incredible to him but he waited to touch them, he had to get her naked first. He reached down and slid her panties off with a smirk. "I want you to know your body is amazing, I guess it's true what they say about dancers." He smirked.
Rachel smiled and blushed as she laid back on the bed giggling softly."My body isn't like Santana's or Brittany's..." She said with a slight pout as she looked back at him.
"I know, it's way better." He smirked. "You have the perfect shape, your boobs are just the right size and holy crap that ass." He licked his lips. "And don't worry baby, if I get you good and aroused for me before I enter you it won't hurt at all. Might be a little tight though...I am kinda big when I'm hard."
"Okay." Rachel smiled and nodded as she rubbed his shoulders gently, leaning up to kiss him deeply. "What do you do to arouse me?" She asked innocently, tilting her head.
"This..." He placed his lips on the base of her neck sucking slightly and then kissing it gently, he trailed kisses up her collarbone to her shoulder and back down again. He trailed his tongue between her breasts, they were the perfect size. He trailed his tongue around her nipple watching it harden, he used his fingers on her other breast while sucking on the other. He felt her writhe and moan beneath his touch, he used his hands to seek out all the sensitive areas on her body. His cock was painfully hard, he stroked it a few times and pressed it against her clit while kissing her neck.
"Ohh..." Rachel moaned softly as she felt herself become even wetter, fluttering her eyes. "That feels so good..." She bucked her hips a few times as she pulled him closer. "More..."
He moved his cock against her clit until he was completely hard while he kissed her passionately massaging her breasts. "You want me baby?" He panted and used his fingers to check if she was wet enough for him.
"I want you." Rachel whispered as she kissed him softly, spreading her legs wide for him. "Please, Noah...I need you..." The brunette begged as she kissed along his face.
He nodded and gently slid inside of her while rubbing her stomach to help relax her. He slid in slowly while kissing her and backed away to see if she was ok. "How's that feel baby...?" He panted a little bit waiting for her answer.
Rachel moaned softly as she wrapped her legs around his waist, gnawing on her bottom lip gently she looked up at him. "I've never felt this before in my life... feels so good..."
He smiled and touched her cheek before kissing her again. "I'm gonna move now ok?" He rubbed her waist and kissed her again before moving his hips slowly at first so she could get used to his length. Being inside of her was more incredible than he had imagined.
Rachel closed her eyes and let out a soft moan with each thrust as she gripped his arms, panting softly. "So good..." She mewled softly as she rubbed his arms.
He took his time making sure her first time was amazing, he wanted to memorize every part of her body. He wanted to know what she liked and where she was most sensitive. His thrusts were slow and hard, he grunted softly and kept his eyes on her making sure she felt every inch of him. Her headboard hit the wall every time he moved into her and sweat started to accumulate on their bodies.
"Noah... make me come..." Rachel whined out as she fluttered her eyes and kissed along his neck and jaw, panting and moaning. She gripped the back of his Mohawk and pulled him down for an intense kiss. Their tongues clashed and she gripped him tighter.
He pressed his forehead against hers and laced their fingers together wile they kissed. He pounded into her repeatedly and rapidly making sure he was rubbing against her clit.
"Oh, Noah!" Rachel moaned out loudly as she came undone, her juices gushing around his cock as her hips bucked up a few times. Her breasts bouncing and heaving as she bucked against him "Oh..."
He groaned gruffly in her ear, her orgasm triggering his. His body shook and he dug his fists into the sheets by her head while his warm cum shot deep within her. He collapsed against her panting hard still coming. She held him close while he came. "Milk me baby..." He grunted as an aftershock shook through his body. She moaned and held him inside her squeezing out every last drop of cum she could until he was finished.
"That was fun..." Rachel panted out as she looked over at him, smiling softly before she pressed a kiss to his nose. "When can we do it again?" She asked sweetly.
He laughed breathlessly and kissed her cheek. "You are so hot." He smirked and pulled out of her then he pulled her against his chest. "Just let me catch my breath and I'll show you some more positions we can do."
"Okay." Rachel nodded her head as she blushed a little, looking back at him. "Take your time." She added as she snuggled up underneath the covers.
He smiled and kissed her cheek. "I wasn't expecting to make love to you anytime soon." He rubbed her back."How'd it feel? I didn't hurt you did I? I've never made love before..." He blushed slightly and then he felt like an idiot.
"I'm fine. It felt great. You're only use to sleeping with girls. No emotions." Rachel said as she shook her head and moved closer to him.
"Yeah, how do you always seem to know what I'm thinking?" He wrapped his arms around her completely and nuzzled his face into her soft hair.
"I just know you. I'm smart." Rachel said with a giggle as she went to rest her head against his chest, sighing contently. "And you know me."
"Yeah I do, even before we started dating I knew stuff about you. I mean we did grow up together after all, we used to be best friends." He chuckled and rolled over so she was on top of him.
She kissed his forehead and gently flicked his nipple ring with her finger causing him to moan. "So sexy Noah..." She brought her lips down and gently tugged on his nipple ring with her teeth eliciting another moan from him. His cock twitched and slowly started to harden once more, she smirked and sat up on top of him. Puck Lifted her up a little so she could grab his cock. "Put me inside you baby..."
Rachel nodded and slid down onto his cock slowly, he placed his hands on her hips and she immediately started bouncing rapidly. His eyes practically bugged out of his head it felt so intense, he leaned up to kiss her breasts and she grabbed him, keeping him there while she bounced. He groaned loudly as his balls twitched and throbbed ready to blow his cum deep into her. "Noah..." She moaned loudly feeling her orgasm about to hit. They came together for the second time that night collapsing against the pillows sweaty and panting. Puck laughed breathlessly and pulled her against him so he could kiss her softly. "God I love you.."
A few weeks had passed since they'd been back at school, their relationship was still a secret to everyone outside their families. Puck sat in the choir room chatting with Mike and Sam while glancing at Rachel every few minutes. She was sitting near the band whispering something to them, they had slowly started to play a song. As the music started everyone in the room began to quiet down, Rachel's voice slowly filled the air.
You're the light, you're the night
You're the color of my blood
You're the cure, you're the pain
You're the only thing I wanna touch
Never knew that it could mean so much, so much
She sang softly still sitting in her seat not really looking at anyone before she slowly stood up walking to the middle of the room. Puck smiled softly knowing she was singing to him, she was going to reveal their relationship in her own way.
You're the fear, I don't care
Cause I've never been so high
Follow me to the dark
Let me take you past our satellites
You can see the world you brought to life, to life
She faced everyone before she sang the chorus, glancing at Noah but not drawing too much attention to him.
So love me like you do, love me like you do
Love me like you do, love me like you do
Touch me like you do, touch me like you do
What are you waiting for?
Finn watched confused, he didn't want her back but he hoped she was singing to him. Santana scoffed assuming Rachel was attempting to get Finn back and mumbled it to every one and they quietly gossiped about Rachel and Finn. They called her desperate and Puck smirked, if only they knew the truth.
Fading in, fading out
On the edge of paradise
Every inch of your skin is a holy grail I've got to find
Only you can set my heart on fire, on fire
Yeah, I'll let you set the pace
Cause I'm not thinking straight
My head spinning around I can't see clear no more
What are you waiting for?
Puck smirked a little feeling his chest tighten a little bit, his feelings for her were so strong. She was his and he never wanted to let her go, he never wanted to leave her he'd follow her anywhere. He loved her more than anything. Sure he was only seventeen but he didn't care, he was young but he wasn't stupid or naive he knew what he wanted. As she belted out that line he stood up and went to her wrapping her in his arms.
Love me like you do, love me like you do
Love me like you do, love me like you do
Touch me like you do, touch me like you do
What are you waiting for?
She gently pressed her forehead against his and placed a hand on his cheek, looking into his eyes as she sang the rest of the song directly to him. He held her close smiling softly leaning into her touch while she sang.
Yeah, I'll let you set the pace
Cause I'm not thinking straight
My head spinning around I can't see clear no more
What are you waiting for?
It was like it was only the two of them them there, but in the back of his mind he knew the rest of the gleeks were freaking the hell out and he was fine with that.
Love me like you do, love me like you do
Love me like you do, love me like you do
Touch me like you do, touch me like you do
What are you waiting for?
He kissed her gently and then she hugged him waiting for the onslaught of questions, of course Finn was first angrily accusing Puck of stealing Rachel from him. "Dude what the hell?! Its like you get some sick pleasure out of stealing my girlfriends from me or something!" He shouted angrily and stood up, when Santana stood up next Puck moved Rachel behind him shielding her. "Puck is my man Berry, keep your dirty man hands off of him!"
He felt Rachel stiffen behind him and when the other gleeks started to harass her with insults like they did at sectionals Puck snapped. "You idiots need to shut the hell up! Now! Finn, I've known Rachel a helluva lot longer than you have. Before I was a slushy throwing douche bag we were actually best friends. She was my girlfriend first and I didn't steal her from anyone, you ruined that relationship by being a jerk. And Santana I'm not your man, just because I used to bang you every now and then that doesn't mean you have some claim over me. I love Rachel and she loves me end of discussion, if anybody has something to say about it I don't mind going back to juvie." He sneered before leading Rachel back to her seat and slinging an arm over her protectively. Everyone shut up when Mr. Schue walked in to start practice a few minutes later.
Puck was at an away game over night with the rest of the football players two months after he and Rachel revealed they were dating. She had a skype call with him that night and she was getting ready for it when she heard the ring. She smiled and sat down on the bed answering it, she grinned when she saw his face pop up on her laptop screen. "Hey baby! Miss me yet?" He smirked.
"Hm...let me think about it." She teased and he pouted playfully. "Babe come on." he laughed.
"Of course I miss you honey." She blew a kiss at the screen and he pretended to catch it. "I have some news for you Noah.."
He raised an eyebrow as she leaned over to grab something off her night stand, when she held it up to the camera he nearly passed out.
"Is that what I...what I think it is..?"
"Yes.."
"So I'm..."
"Yes you are." She smiled slightly.
"And I actually get to be there the whole time?"
"Through everything, Noah I promise."
"So we're going to keep it?"
"I wouldn't be able to give it up, that would break me Noah."
He nodded still in shock. "So I'm gonna be a...a..."
"Yes Noah you're going to be a daddy, for real this time. To a little Jewish child who will hopefully have your nose." She giggled.
He smiled. "I love the sound of that, and I love your nose babe it's beautiful just like the rest of you."
She blushed and smiled shyly. "I love you...father of my child."
He chuckled. "I love you too mother of my spawn."
She giggled. "Noah!"
Thank you all for reading, like I said at the beginning I'm working on my other two stories don't worry. If you guys want a sequel please review the hell out of this story because I wont know otherwise lol And special thanks to my rp buddy Kristina for inspiring this story.
