This is just an idea that I had seeing as I ship Quick and Faberry hardcore. I'm planning on making this a short fan fic (Maybe 5 chapters plus epilogue) I haven't quite decided on the length yet. I may end up deciding based on the reception this story gets. I hope you all enjoy this story
Quinn and Puck had been dating now for over two months and Quinn's belly had kept growing as the days passed. She had thought this was a bad idea at first but Puck had shown her over the past two months that we wasn't completely a bad guy. He was actually a gentleman, opening doors for her, rubbing her feet every night and even getting up at all hours of the night to get whatever Quinn had craved from bacon to out of season watermelon.
The sex between them was really good, Quinn had even began to enjoy having sex even though she still had that voice in the back of her mind that said it was against God's will but her hormones won over that voice each time. There were many nights where Quinn couldn't keep her hands off of Puck, not that he didn't enjoy that. Lately though, Quinn had been thinking of ways to spice up what they had. They had really tried anything there was to try when it came to sex, other than one thing that Quinn had secretly wanted for awhile, a threesome.
That night, Puck flopped down on the couch next to her ready as ever to rub her feet just like every night since she had moved into his house. Quinn sat with her hand on her stomach feeling the baby kicking and moving around wildly.
"Is she being crazy again?" he asked as Quinn nodded with a smile as she felt their daughter kick hard hearing her father's voice.
"Yeah, she's kicking like crazy tonight" she said with a smile as Puck put his hand on her rounded stomach feeling his daughter pretty much having a party in his girlfriend.
"Baby girl, calm down, it's night time" he said with a smile as he leaned down and kissed her stomach before sitting back up to rub her feet.
The two of them were home alone, Puck's mom Deborah was at work and Puck's sister Sarah was spending the night at her friend's house. It was Friday night, which was strange for Puck to be home but since they had started dating, he kept his going out to one night a week, if that. He would spend most of his nights at home with Quinn or at work.
"I wanted to ask you something" she said as Puck began to rub her feet and sip from the beer.
"Okay, Q, what's up?" he asked as he looked to Quinn as she nervously looked down and mumbled
"I…I want to have a threesome" she said nervously as Puck almost spit his beer across the room.
"What?" he asked shocked that she had even thought about it as Quinn nodded this time a bit more confident.
"I want to have a threesome" she said confidently as Puck smirked and went back to rubbing her feet again.
"I knew you were a freak under it all. I like it Fabray. Who do you want a threesome with? I really don't want another dude" he said taking another sip of beer as Quinn thought for a second.
She knew Santana would do it but she really didn't want to do it with her, Brittany would get distracted with her belly there, she really had no idea who else would do it that they knew. She had always known though that it would be another woman no matter what. She wanted Puck to be the only man inside her at this point in time.
"I don't know who" she said with a shrug as Puck thought for a second and got an idea.
"I know someone who would" he said with a smirk knowing that this would be good.
"Who is it?" Quinn asked groaning when his fingers hit a sore spot on the bottom of her foot.
"It's a surprise but its good babe, you'll love it" he said as he smirked as he got the mental image and it was hot to say the least.
Later that night, while Quinn was in the shower, he found the girl's number and smirked to himself.
"Well if it isn't my Jewish American Princess, how are you Berry?" he said being completely nice, a little more nice than usual.
"I'm doing just fine Noah; I am working on my vocal scales at the moment. How are you and Quinn this fine Friday evening?" she asked as Puck shook his head hoping she wasn't this annoying during sex.
"I have a favor to ask Berry" he said simply as he licked his lip and rose his eyebrows at the same time.
"Does Quinn need anything? Remember I told you both that I would do anything to help if either one of you ever needed anything. Is she craving anything? I can make cookies if she wants something sweet and bring them over" she said listing off the many ideas as Puck smirked, she would totally say yes. She was practically in love with Quinn and of course everyone else was blind to see it.
"Well you see Rachel, Quinn being heavily pregnant has needs, needs that I can't take care of alone" he said smirking as Rachel was silent on the other end for a few minutes.
"Noah, what are you talking about?" she said confused about what he was even talking about.
"Quinn asked me today to have a threesome and I thought you would be a great third for our little party" he said as Rachel was silent on the phone.
"Are you trying to get me killed? Quinn hates me" Rachel said completely shocked but happy she was behind the phone because she was blushing just thinking about it.
"She wouldn't kill you, plus you're pretty hot when you aren't in those animal sweaters" he said as Rachel sighed not knowing what to say.
"Can't you ask Santana or Brittany? They seem to really like women that way" she asked annoyed as Puck shook his head knowing she couldn't see it.
"Quinn doesn't want them to; I think she's afraid that we'll kick her out of the bed or something. She needs someone who is careful of her condition and very discrete. I don't care if people find out about me in a threesome but Quinn… she cares. Something about morals or some junk like that" he said as Rachel sighed.
"I would be lying if I said I wasn't aroused by the idea of consensual sexual contact with both of you and plus if it helps Quinn get some relief, I'll do it Puckerman" she said as Puck sat in shock, she had actually said yes. He looked up and saw Quinn walking out of the bathroom in just a towel and gave her the thumbs up with a goofy grin.
"When do you want to do it babe?" he asked as Quinn shrugged knowing that he was talking to the mystery woman on the phone.
"Anytime is fine with me" she said as Puck turned back to the phone trying to keep himself from sounding giddy about the situation.
"Can you come over now?" he asked as Quinn's eyes became wide. Puck was the only guy she knew that could have a threesome together in the time it took her to shower.
"I can be over in half an hour, I'll tell my dads' that I'm spending the night at Kurt's house" she said as Puck said his goodbyes and smiled to Quinn.
"She's coming over in half an hour" he said as Quinn looked at him with the look of nervousness and disbelief before snapping out of it.
"Puck! I need to shave then!" she said frantic that another woman would be coming over and her legs were hairy.
"I'll help you, come on" he said walking with her in the bathroom to shave Quinn.
The half hour past quickly as he shaved Quinn's legs and bikini area for her since she couldn't really reach them around her swollen belly. It took every ounce of restraint he had not to just have sex with her right then and there. The doorbell rang and Puck took a deep breath looking at Quinn sitting on his bed in his shirt and a pair of panties.
"Ready?" he asked Quinn as he kissed her and smiled. All Quinn could do was nod as he went downstairs and opened the door seeing Rachel Berry standing there in jeans and a t-shirt.
"Hello Noah" she said walking in and Puck smiled hugging her loosely impressed that she was in jeans and a t-shirt and not her usual animal sweaters or plaid.
"Q is upstairs waiting, now let me do the talking" he said as Rachel followed him upstairs and he opened the door slowly.
"Alright babe, she's here. I need you to promise me to keep an open mind" he said as Quinn's eyes narrowed. It was never good when he asked her to keep an open mind.
"Please tell me you didn't get Becky" she said as Puck shook his head in disgust.
"No, oh no, not her. I just… I don't want you to freak out about who I got. It's a good thing" he said as he opened the door and Rachel walked in looking down not even able to look Quinn in the eyes.
"Hello Quinn" she said her voice low as Quinn's eyes got wide with surprise.
"This has to be a joke; Rachel Berry wants to have a threesome with us?" Quinn said not really believing that this was real.
"Yes, if it helps with the relief of the tension and it makes you feel good, then I would be honored to help" Rachel explained as Quinn took a deep breath and actually entertained the idea of Rachel and her together.
"Okay, ground rules, Puckerman, you do not penetrate Rachel without both of our permission and a condom. Our daughter does not need a sister or brother right now. Both of you need to be careful, if something hurts me you both have to stop" Quinn said as Rachel nodded looking at her understanding that they had to make sure that Quinn was comfortable the whole time.
"I would rather you not kiss me on the mouth Puckerman unless Quinn is okay with it. I do not want to ruin your relationship between you two" Rachel said as Puck nodded.
"Alright, it's all agreed then, let's begin" he said clapping his hands together as the girls looked at each other nervously.
