Author's Note: Hello, all! I hope you enjoy my fanfiction! (For those who don't know, Annalise is a OC that my sister and I created. She's Winn's girlfriend)
Disclaimer: Nothing is mineā¦. except Annalise and the plot bunnies that gave their lives for this story. Naw, just kidding, they're just all tired out.
"It's Annalise! Open the door, my hands are full!" Annalise called through the door into Kara's apartment.
Kara smiled at the sound of her female (other than Alex, of course) best friend. "How long it takes me open the door depends on what kind of food you have."
"Karaaaaa..." Annalise moaned. "Fine, I have ice cream. It's cold, and heavy, and if you don't open the door this second I will sit down right here and eat all of it before it melts."
"Ok, ok, I'm coming." Kara laughed. She opened the door and took 2 of the 4 ice cream containers out of Annalise's hands, checking the flavors before setting them down on the counter next to the place where she had been chopping potatoes up to make hash browns.
"I get the coffee for James, the cookies and cream for Alex and I-"
"Me." Annalise corrected.
"Sorry. Alex and me, the mint chocolate chip for the general public, but who's the chocolate brownie for?"
"Winn. It's his favorite." Annalise responded, starting to load the cold dessert into the freezer.
"Right." Kara nodded, and finished up with her potatoes just as the someone else nocked on the door.
"I've got it!" Annalise volunteered, racing over to the door. "Alex! Max!"
"Max? What is he doing here?" Kara scoffed, looking up.
"Hello to you, too, Mrs. Danvers." Max smirked, passing his bag of Tie food to Annalise. "Alex invited me."
"Why did you have to go and do that Alex?" Kara groaned, glaring at Max.
Thankfully, the argument was headed off by a muffled voice saying, "Thank's for slamming the door in my face!"
"Sorry, Winn!" Annalise peeped, opening up to reveal her friend. "Come on in."
"Thank you." Winn grinned and stepped in, handing Annalise the multiple bags of potato chips that were in his arms. "James is late."
"He's coming." Kara said. The next second there was another nock at the door. "See?" James was let in with his bottle of wine, much appreciated, and they all settled down in seats- Annalise, Winn, Max and Alex on the couches, and James and Kara in chairs.
"I'm not hungry yet, lets play a game." Kara suggested.
Winn groaned. "Fine, but we better have dinner before my stomach eats my small intestine."
"That's gross." Alex commented dryly, and Max snorted.
"With Winn, things like that are possible." Annalise responded, and Winn gave her a playful push in the shoulder. "Shaddup." Annalise giggled.
"How about 'Truth or Dare'?" Alex suggested.
"Ooh! Fun!" Kara exclaimed. The majority of the group (meaning everyone except Max, which made Alex glare at him) agreed.
"Go ahead, Alex. It was your idea." James said, and Alex rubbed her hands together mischievously. "Maybe that was a bad idea..." James said worriedly, making Kara laugh.
"I won't be too mean, I promise." Alex told him. "Ok. Winn. Truth or Dare?"
"Uh... dare."
Alex grinned evilly, and Winn's eyes grew twice in size. Annalise giggled. "I dare you to kiss Annalise."
Annalise stopped laughing, and everyone in room froze. Winn's face went from red to pale then back to red. "I- uh, I- wha-"
"Do it, Winn." Kara prompted. "You know you want to."
Winn turned and pressed his lips to Annalise's for a quick kiss. They pulled apart and looked away, though Annalise had a huge smile on her face and a dreamy look in her eyes.
There was a awkward silence, broken only by Kara's squeak of surprised laughter. After that Max started chuckling, then James, and before long the whole room was in stitches without knowing quite why.
After they had calmed down some, Alex turned to Winn. "Your turn."
"Alright. James, Truth or Dare?"
"Truth." James said warily.
"Oh, your no fun. Let's see... Why did you and Lucy break up in the first place? I've always wanted to know."
James gaped at him, and though Kara tried not to, she looked intrigued. "Um... well... you know most of the story. She thought I was too obsessed with Superman, and I didn't pay enough attention to her, so when I left it just didn't work out. I also think we just weren't meant to be."
Annalise nodded sympathetically. "That's tough."
"Now I get to go." James said, hurriedly changing the subject. "Max, Truth or Dare."
"Oh, what the heck- Dare."
"Kiss Alex." Alex's jaw dropped, Kara looked furious, Winn nudged Annalise, who in turn gave him an excited glance. Max, on his part, grinned. He turned to Alex, placed one hand behind her head, and gave her a long, romantic kiss.
Kara mimed throwing up, though Annalise thought it was sweet. When they finally pulled apart Alex looked a bit faint. "Wow..."
"I've wanted to do that for much too long." Max muttered. "My turn!" As Alex kept staring blankly at a wall, Max turned back to Winn. "Winn, Truth or Dare?"
"Me again?" Winn complained. "Fine; Truth."
"What was the worst moment of your life?" Max asked.
"That's a cruel question." Alex reprimanded.
"It's ok. It was probably seeing my dad dragged off to prison for murder when I was 11. He turned just before getting into the car and gave me this smile... if that's even what you could call it. That's when I knew he was really gone."
The room was silent. Annalise bit her lip and squeezed Winn's hand, laying a head on his shoulder. Alex sighed.
"Well, on that note, Annalise; Truth or Dare?"
"Truth." Annalise said.
"Lets see... Do you want to go on a date with me Sunday?"
"A... uh... a date, huh?" Annalise looked a little flustered. "Uh, sure! Definitely."
Winn grinned. James didn't really think it was a very interesting question for the rest of them, but decided not to comment.
Annalise then face Kara. "Ok. Kara; Truth or Dare?"
"Dare."
"I dare you to kiss your choice of person in this room, and not your sister." Annalise exchanged significant glances with Winn. They both knew if she forced Kara to kiss James, there was the possibility that nothing would come out of it. Now, if Kara had a choice, James the thick would probably get that Kara wanted to go out with him.
Kara blushed, glanced at Alex, who tilted her head at James. They seemed to have silent conversation with just their eyes and expressions, something only sisters can do. Kara jutted out her chin a little and blinked: 'I can't kiss James!'
Alex, in turn slid her eyes around the room and grinned: 'Who else are you going to kiss then?'
Kara wrinkled her nose: 'You have a point.' Then she sighed: 'Fine.' Turning quickly, she got out of her chair and planted her lips on a surprised James.
Annalise bit her knuckle in excitement. Alex smirked in triumph as Kara pulled away, blushed, and sat back down. James goggled at her, and she blushed harder.
"Uh... wait, Alex, you haven't gone, right?"
"Nope."
"Ok then! Alex, Truth or Dare?"
Alex considered. "Truth."
"What's something I don't already know... hmmm... Oh! Who was your first boyfriend?"
Everyone sat back to hear the story as Alex thought back. "Let's see. His name was Rick. Don't you remember Kara? I met him at school."
"Oh, him." Kara wrinkled her nose.
"Do you just have a problem with every boy Alex's is interested it?" Max smirked.
Alex rolled her eyes and intervened before a full blown war could start. "Anyways, his name was Rick, and I started dating him before Kara came to Earth. We would go with a group of our friends most of the time, he wasn't very romantic- I mean, he was only a high school boy. It was nothing very interesting."
Winn nodded. "At least you had a boyfriend."
"Winn, you wanted a boyfriend?" Kara teased.
"Oh, shush." Winn shook his head, and Kara stuck out her tongue at him. "What I mean is, I didn't have a girlfriend until collage- unless you count Margo..."
"Who was Margo?" Annalise asked, interested.
"She was... Margo." Winn shook his head as he remembered. "She was really weird. Like really weird. Kind of like... Luna Lovegood weird."
Everyone except James laughed. He looked confused. "Who's Luna Lovegood?"
"You don't know who Luna Lovegood is?!" Annalise shrieked. "Please don't tell me you've never read Harry Potter."
"I'm not really into those kind of books." James defended. Annalise glared at him and sat back on the couch.
Trying to break the ice that had suddenly formed in the room, Kara said brightly, "Who wants Tie food?"
After a yummy dinner and quite a few glasses of wine, it was time for everyone to be getting home. Kara came to the door and said the all off, giving James an extra kiss on the cheek. They all decided to try and have a night like this once a month. It was good to all get together and hang out every once and awhile.
Author's Note: I hope that was enjoyable. There will be more soon!
