So this story has a base beginning and several alternate ways this can go, I have added each in a new chapter so please give me some feedback on which story you like the best, if anyone is interested in taking the idea prompt let me know! I will probably add new chapters/prompts as well so let me know if you are interested in a specific one
DISCLAIMER: I DO NOT OWN SUPERNATURAL, AVENGERS, HARRY POTTER, OR FAIRYTAIL
"Please Father… I just couldn't love them more than I love you… They are flawed; they will destroy the paradise you have built." Lucifer sat in front of his Father on his knees, held in place by Michael and Raphael as Gabriel hovered behind their Father nervously.
Ethereal body broken and bleeding Lucifer wept.
Once glorious white wings were shredded by Michael's sword and stained with his own gold Ichor, patches of feathers missing, slices littering his skin and arms broken grotesquely, he was surely a sight to see next to his pristine family, for even as much as he hated the humans he couldn't fight his brothers.
"You were the brightest of all my children… my morning star… but… you have failed me in this." God spoke to his son sadly; it brought him great sadness to see his beautiful son this way.
"You must face your wrongs and give penance my son. Your deeds be punished and when complete… I will welcome you home." Lucifer looked to his father with shame and unconditional love; "I will do as you say Father so that I may return to you one day."
Michael made a protesting noise but was quickly silenced by a reprimanding look from their father.
"I will place you in the mortal life cycle until you learn to love them as I do Lucifer. You may not take a mortal life willingly or your punishment will be severe, I will take your essence and lock you in a cage within your creation Hell. Only when you accept and love the mortals into your heart as I do will you be able to return home and regain your full power."
"Full power, Father?" Gabriel asked playfully, relaxed now that he knew his favorite brother would be able to return to him.
"Many of the universe's I have in mind are dangerous, I am placing you in the life cycle, however, only life and Death are able to tell which race you will become with each life. Your soul will most likely be born many times my son, for your hatred is overwhelming even now. Go now, to your punishment, but remember my love and the love of your Family. One day you will come home."
With that Lucifer felt his father's grace touch his mutilated essence, gentle waves of the power surrounded him in a cocoon until the power and Lucifer, was gone from heaven.