Ally Gilbert is Elena's older sister who left Mystic Falls 3 years ago and hasn't seen her family since. She's finally returning home with two secrets. What happens when she comes home and gets caught up in the supernatural drama that she's known about since she was 15? What happens when Ally catches the eye of a certain original hybrid and doesn't know what to do?

I do not own any of the characters besides my OC's all rights go to the show...

Ally is portrayed by Margot Robbie.


I'm finally heading home after three and half years. I left home when I was 17 and now I've come back to where my family lives in Mystic Falls. The reason why I left was because I found out I was a witch and I got pregnant. I didn't want anyone to know so I left and moved to Georgia and have lived there ever since. Nobody but my parents, Aunt and Uncle knew why, but unfortunately they are all dead.

My parents Miranda and Grayson Gilbert died in a car crash over a year ago. I tried to make it back for their funeral but Amy, my three year old daughter, got appendicitis so I couldn't. I have regretted it since but I've always kept in contact with my siblings so when I got the call that my aunt and uncle passed away I knew I had to come home. I know they are going to be mad but I did it to keep everyone I loved safe including my daughter.

I found out about all the supernatural when I was 15. I stumbled across my families old journals in my parents bedroom and it had everything about the supernatural in them. I was confused at first because and didn't think that it was possible but my parent's found me reading them and explained it to me.

Growing up I always felt different. I would have these weird dreams and could feel the elements calling me, but when I turned 16 I finally found out why. I'm a witch. Shortly after my birthday my powers came into effect and it scared me. So with the permission from my parents using the excuse of being pregnant, I left town and found other witches who kindly took me in and taught me how to use my magic and quite quickly I got good at it, but when Amy was born I decided to distance myself from my magic to protect my daughter so she could have a normal life.

The thing that is different about me from other witches is that my magic doesn't come from ancestors or family lines it comes from the elements and that's how I channel my magic. I'm more powerful than your average witch and that's why it's easy for me to stay away from it, as I can raise Amy in a normal life away from any supernatural.


I turn into my street and slowly pull the car off to the left and put it into park. I look outside the window at the two story house. I'm officially home and now that I'm here my nerves have set in. I'm finally telling my siblings the truth, I just hope they can forgive me.

I slowly get out of the car and unbuckle Amy out of her car seat. She looks up at me and I smile down at her. "You ready baby girl?" I ask as she clutches her favourite wolf.

"Yes momma." She replies softly.

I move some of her blonde hair out of her face. "You know it's okay to be shy, you're meeting your aunt and uncle today but just remember whatever happens you will always be my number 1." I remind her placing her down on the concrete and flattening her dress.

We walk up the concrete path to the front door. I knock on the door and wait. Moments later the door opens ajar and a familiar head answers it. "Ally?" Elena gasps shocked and confused.

"Hi Lena." I greet quietly hiding Amy behind me.

Elena opens the door wider and looks behind me and sees Amy peeking from behind me. Elena first looks shocked and does a double take. "Ally who is this?" she questions.

I smile and look down at Amy then back to my little sister. "Elena I want you to meet my daughter, Amy."

"You have a daughter." She gasps in shock.

I nod. "Amy I want you to meet your Aunt, Elena."

Amy confidently steps forward and hugs Elena's legs. Elena in shock slowly crouches down and hugs her back with teens in her eyes. "It's nice to meet you Amy."

"Mumma told me so much bout you." Amy greets.

Elena glances up at me and I send her a small smile. "Well what are we waiting for come inside." Elena invites after a moment with her niece.


Once inside I set Amy up in the lounge room with my IPad and I ask Elena to come with me to the kitchen. As we get inside her face drops. "You had a kid." She addresses harshly.

"I can explain everything." I reply.

She nods and crosses her arms. "Go on."

I take a breath. "About three years ago I found out I was pregnant and I didn't know what to do. I told mom and dad and they were disappointed obviously, but after a while they got over it and wanted to support me. They suggested that I leave and raise the child away from Mystic Falls for a while away from the lifestyle." I explain telling the half truth.

"Lifestyle?"

"The supernatural."

She gasps. "You know?"

"I've known since I was 15." I confirm. "Dad explained it to me when I found some of the old family journals and when I found out I was pregnant I didn't want any chance of her getting caught up in it, so I left without telling anyone."

"You could have told me."

"I was 16 Elena, you wouldn't of understood. I would have been judged as soon as I left the house. I just couldn't risk it."

She nods slowly. "Why now, why didn't you come to mom and dad's funeral?" she asks a little louder.

"I was going to, but Amy got sick and was in hospital for a week I couldn't leave her."

"Was she okay?" she asks concerned.

"At first we didn't know what was wrong but she had appendicitis."

"I'm glad she's okay, she's beautiful."

"Shes the best thing that's ever happened to me."

"She has your eyes. Who's her farther?"

"Josh Fell."

She looks at me shocked. "Does he know?"

"No and I want it to stay that way, he was an idiot and I don't want her around him."

"Why are you back now?" Elena questions.

"I heard about Aunt Jenna and Uncle John and I missed our parents funeral, so I wasn't going to miss Jenna's. And I know it's not going to be easy living with me and a three year old but I am home to help you because that's what family does." I respond.

She takes a minute to take in my words "I missed you so much." She expresses.

"I missed you to little sister." I smile and we hug.

"Mumma." I hear Amy's voice yell out.

"Yes."

"I'm hungry."

I laugh. "Well lets get you something to eat, how about the grill Elena, want to come with us?" I invite.

She nods. "That sounds like a great idea, Jeremy is working there too." Elena agrees.

I smile. "How's he doing?"

"He's doing good, but I worry about him."

"Well no need to worry now, I'm home and we are here to stay." I tell her.

She smiles. "Well what are we waiting for lets go." Elena exclaims and we leave.


We arrive at The Grill which is the local hangout for everyone in town. When Elena, Amy and I walk through the doors we find a table near a window and Amy excitedly sits against the window. We wait a moment and the waiter who I instantly recognise, Matt Donavon, walks over approaches us. "Hey Elena what can I get for you?" he asks Elena and doesn't notice me until he looks up and locks eyes with me. "Ally?"

I nod smiling. "Hi Matt." I greet.

"Omg, you're back." He exclaims and hugs me and finally notices the blonde girl sitting down looking at us with curiosity.

"And whos this cutie?" Matt asks.

"Uh this is Amy, my daughter." I introduce.

He looks shocked but quickly covers it up. "Wow, uh that's great."

"It's a long story." Elena mouths to Matt.

He nods and smiles at Amy. "So Amy I'm Matt, your Mum andAunt's friends." Matt introduces himself to Amy.

Amy looks to me and I give her an encouraging smile. "Matt." She greeets shyly.

"Can we get nuggets and chips with a Fanta?" I order.

He nods smiling. "What about you two?" Matt asks Elena and me.

"I'll get the cheeseburger and fries with a coke. Elena?"

"The same." Elena orders.

Matt writes it down and walks away. "So where's Jeremy?" I ask her.

"He's probably out the back."

"How are you handling everything you must have a million questions about everything?"

"I do, I'm still processing everything."

"We can talk tonight once this one is asleep." I suggest.


Mintues later our meals come and we eat and Amy is stuffing her face hungrily. "You really were hungry weren't you baby girl?" I ask with a smirk.

She smiles and takes another bite of her burger. Elena then looks behind me and I turn around I see Jeremy come out from the back. He walks straight for our table and looks at me eerily. "Ally?" he questions.

"Hey Jer." I whisper quietly standing up.

"You're back?"

"I'm back Jer."

"Is it true you have a baby?" he asks and looks to my daughter who is playing with my phone.

"It's true, I can explain everything but not here please?" I beg.

He looks to Amy who notices Jeremy she smiles shyly and goes back to the phone. "She looks just like you.".

I smile. "She's basically me at three."

"She's three?" he questions loudly.

"Yeah."

He calms down and takes a breath. "You have some explaining to do."

"I know I do. I will when we get back home.

"Fine." He finishes and walks off.


After our meal Elena leaves Amy and I and we head back home. I unpack everything and she looks tired. "You tired munchkin?" I ask her.

She yawns and nods. I laugh and pick her up and she clings onto me like a koala. "Me tired."

"Let's get you to bed munchkin." I suggest and carry her upstairs to her room where I lay her onto her bed. I lay her underneath the covers and kiss her forehead and leave her to sleep. I shut her door leaving it slightly ajar and walk to my room.


Once I'm in my sweats I walk downstairs to find Elena and Jeremy walking inside. "Amy asleep?" Elena asks.

"Yes, she's out like a light, she's exhausted from traveling all day." I explain. "Can we all talk now?" I ask changing the subject. They both nod and I exhale. "Where do you want me to start?" I ask them.

"Elena filled me in briefly but start when you found out about the supernatural." Jeremy begins and I nod.

"I was 15 and I was going through the attic when I came across these old family journals, there were many of them. I started reading them and I was intrigued. At first I was confused as they had our family name in them and had stuff about monsters of the night, werewolves, witches but it didn't make sense." I begin. "Dad found me reading them and I asked him what this was about and he told me everything."

"You know about vampires, witches and werewolves?" Elena questions.

"Yes, I know about them but I've never met any but I wear vervain and don't let strangers in the house. I know werewolves are only dangerous on full moons and witches are well witches." I explain.

"Do you know about the Lockwoods?" Jer asks.

"Yes but we were never in danger because they didn't trigger the curse."

"Tyler did." Elena mentions.

"Omg, how?" I ask shocked.

"He killed someone on accident." Jeremy answers.

"That's all it takes."

"Does Amy wear vervain?" Elena asks changing the topic back to vampires.

I nod. "In her necklace, she never takes it off accept for when she baths." I tell them.

"About Amy why didn't you tell us?" Jeremy asks hurt.

"I was ashamed. I would have been seen as the 16 year old who got knocked up and didn't finish school." I answer.

"We wouldn't of seen you that way." Elena argues.

I shake my head disagreeing. "You don't know that, you saw the look that Matt gave me at the grill, but it doesn't matter anyway, I've done fine these past few years. Amy is the best thing that's ever happened to me and she's kept me going, everything I do is for her."

"How did you survive by yourself?"

"Mom and dad helped to start off with and I got a job well several actually. I lived with flatmates so it wasn't as expensive, I'm doing ok."

"We thought you left because you couldn't live with us." Jeremy mentions.

"Jeremy don't think that, look I don't regret moving because I've grown up majorly, I had a baby god sake, I had to. If I wanted the best for Amy I needed to be somewhere that I could start over." I continue.

"We understand." They finally say.

"I know it's going to take a lot to get back to what we once were but with us together we can get through anything and I will help anyway I can. If you have any trouble with vampire business I will help but now that I've been honest with you, you have be honest with me, what and who has been invited in here?" I ask them concerned.


They both go into detail of what has happened since mom and dad died up right up to Elena and the sacrifice where she died and came back. "I can't believe I left you guys." I gasp with tears of shame.

"It would of happened anyway Ally, I was doomed from birth." Elena responds.

"You're not doomed." I scold. "Is this Klaus business over?"

"He's left town with Stefan."

"And this Damon guy is he safe to be around? Especially my daughter?"

"Yes, no one will hurt Ally." Elena assures.

"Good, well it's been a long day for all of us, lets just go one day at a time and if someone is in trouble we help each other out." I suggest.

"I think we can manage that." Jeremy agrees.


I hope you enjoyed this first chapter the next chapters follow the show more but with a twist.

Please read review and fav follow. I would love the feedback.

Anna xx