I was thinking about doing this one after Secrets and Surprises, but I just had to write it now! It's been stuck in my head for weeks. I really hope you guys like it.

Chapter 1

"A ball?" asked Sabrina, incredulously.

"Yes, Sabrina, we have to go to the ball. It's for investigating!" said Granny Relda.

Mayor Heart was holding the annual Heart Ball for Valentine's Day. Granny Relda thought it would be perfect for spying on the Scarlet Hand. Since you have to have a partner, Sabrina and Puck were going. They weren't bothered that they were going together, because they were going out. (Finally! A/N note) What they were bothered about was dancing.

"I am not dancing!" said Sabrina.

"Me neither!" said Puck.

"It's okay, you don't have to dance," said Granny Relda.

"But I still don't want to go!" said Sabrina and Puck.

"If you don't go I'll take away your dessert privileges!" said Granny Relda. That got them to stop.

"Do I have to wear a dress?" said Sabrina, hoping the answer would be no.

"Yes, you do," said Granny Relda.

"Why?" Sabrina pouted. She hated dresses. She owned only one, that she vowed never to wear.

"Sabrina it's a ball. You have to," said Granny Relda.

Sabrina muttered "stupid ball".

"I don't see why you're complaining," said Daphne, "I wish I could go."

Daphne had begged Granny Relda to go, but only partners could go. She didn't understand why Sabrina was being so reluctant.

"Ugh, fine!" said Sabrina. She hated giving in, but she didn't like arguments to go on and on.

"Good," said Granny Relda, "now look at your dress."

Daphne went and got a royal blue spaghetti strap dress. It was sparkly and nice. It was also totally not Sabrina.

"Why do I have to do this?" she muttered under her breath. Puck had heard her and snickered. She punched his arm.

"And here, Puck, is your tuxedo," said Granny Relda. She pulled out a black suit. Puck put on and outraged face and Sabrina smirked.

"Why do I have to wear that?" said Puck.

Granny Relda sighed. "Puck, as I have explained earlier, this is a ball. You can't wear casual clothes there. You have to be fancy."

Puck pouted, but Granny wouldn't take another argument. She told them to go upstairs and change. Daphne told Sabrina that she was going to do her makeup. Sabrina looked furious.

A little while later, Puck came in the kitchen. He was wearing his tux, and had apparently put on cologne.

"You look very handsome, Puck," said Granny Relda. Puck gave her a sarcastic look.

Then, Sabrina walked in. She looked beautiful in her dress. She had put on mascara and lipstick and blush. Her hair had been curled and she had put on perfume. She wasn't very happy though.

"You look beautiful, Sabrina!" said Granny Relda.

Sabrina just frowned at her. "When do we leave?"

"In just a few minutes, I have to take pictures!" said Granny Relda. Daphne ran to get the camera.

"No!" said Sabrina, and reluctantly put a smile on her face for a picture. Puck refused to smile until Sabrina made him.

"Aww, you two look so cute together!" said Daphne. Sabrina glared at her.

"Let's just go," Sabrina said, grabbing Puck. Granny reminded them to come home by eleven, and Sabrina reassured her that they definitely would.

"I can't believe they're making us do this," said Sabrina, on their way there.

"I know," said Puck, "this is going to be so boring."

"If only this wasn't for only partners, then Daphne would go. She wouldn't mind at all," said Sabrina.

Puck nodded, and stared at her. She looked so beautiful. Her dress brought out her eyes.

"Hey, Sabrina?" said Puck. She looked up at him.

"You look beautiful," he said with a wink.

Sabrina blushed. "Well, you don't look so bad yourself, fairy boy." She actually hated wearing the dress. It was way too fancy.

When they got there, Sabrina went to get them some punch, and Puck went to the bathroom. Sabrina started chatting with Briar Rose and Snow White.

"Hello Sabrina, I didn't think you would come tonight," said Snow White.

"Yeah, Granny made me," she said.

"Oh, I don't think I've ever seen you in a dress before," said Briar Rose.

"Yeah, hopefully, this is the last time," said Sabrina.

"Are you hear with Puck?" asked Snow White.

"Yes," said Sabrina, "he's taking a while, I'm going to go find him." She left to find the bathroom.

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

Puck had a hard time finding the bathroom. He finally had to ask a huge bear, and they said it was upstairs. He had looked everywhere, but couldn't find one. He saw a woman with black hair there.

"Excuse me?" said Puck. The woman turned around and smiled.

"Yes?" she said.

"Do you know where the bathroom is?" asked Puck.

She gestured him to follow her. When they were in front of a room, she grabbed him and kissed him passionately.

"Hey! What are you-"he was muffled. Then he heard a gasp. He looked up and saw Sabrina.

"Puck?" she said.

"Sabrina, it's not what it looks like. I-"said Puck. But Sabrina had punched him in the gut. It had knocked the wind out of him.

"Sabrina!" he shouted. But she was running away. He followed her, but he couldn't find her. He saw her leaving and ran to the door. He got out his wings and flew after her. He found her running down the street. He went to her and grabbed her waist.

"Sabrina, listen to me!" Puck said.

"Let go of me, idiot!" she said. He was stung by her words, and let her go. She ran down the street.

"Sabrina!" he screamed. She didn't answer. Puck broke down. What had he done? He loved Sabrina and he had lost her.

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Puck got home a while later. He saw Daphne and Granny Relda in the kitchen looking disappointed at him.

"Why did you do that, Puck?" said Daphne, furious, "why did you cheat on Sabrina?"

"I didn't cheat on her," he said.

"Then why were you kissing another girl?" asked Daphne.

"The girl came to me, and Sabrina saw her on me. I swear!" said Puck, as truthfully as he could.

Daphne looked at him and realized he was telling the truth.

"Okay Puck, I believe you," she said, "but I don't know about Sabrina. She trusted you, Puck. She doesn't trust too many people. You betrayed her, and I don't think she'll ever even try to find out the truth."

Puck buried his face in his hands. "What have I done? I lost her."

Daphne came over to him and comforted him. "Puck, it's okay. I'll try to talk to her."

"Thanks, marshmallow," he said and hugged her. Then, they both left there rooms to go to sleep.

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

Daphne came into her bedroom and saw Sabrina on the bed, just sitting there. She wasn't crying. Either because she had already cried or she was too shocked to cry.

"Sabrina, I talked to Puck," said Daphne. Sabrina looked at her.

"Let me guess," said Sabrina, "he told you that the girl kissed him?"

"Yes, he did, Sabrina. And I know he was telling the truth. Just believe him," said Daphne.

"I don't know, Daphne," said Sabrina.

"Well, think about it, okay?" said Daphne. Sabrina nodded, and laid down.

Sabrina was devastated. She had loved Puck, and he betrayed her. She would never trust him again. But what if Daphne was right? What if he really wasn't betraying her? Sabrina knew that could be true, but she didn't want to take her chances.

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

The next few days had hurt Puck. He had tried several times to talk to Sabrina, but she refused to say a word to him. He didn't know what to do. He just wished she would just forget everything.

Then, Puck's eyes lit up. If Sabrina forgot everything, then she would love him again. He snuck downstairs for Uncle Jake's spell book.

Did you guys like it? Please, I really want reviews. I might not update for a while though.