A/N: So I got this idea after hearing Taylor Swift's Haunted, The song is so amazing its not even funny. Nick J obviously loves Glee and out of everybody on Glee he only follows Lea on Twitter, and tweets about her so of course that lit a spark in me and I love Finchel so this is a win win, I've never seen these two worlds collide so I'm gonna try... Finn/Rachel/Nick (I haven't chosen who she should be with yet so… you pick?
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or the Jonas Brothers… Nick and his brothers are not famous
Chapter 1
You and I walk a fragile line I have known it all this time But I never thought I'd live to see it break It's getting dark and its all too quiet And I can't trust anything now And its comin' over you like its all a big mistake
Rachel Berry sat starring at her kitchen wall. She had heard from her best friend that her ex-boyfriend was back in Lima… Not to her surprise Nick Jonas had always had such star potential but she knew that his heart had, and always, loved Lima, Ohio… But he left anyways. He left his hometown, his friends, his family and most importantly he left her with any doubts. But she knew he'd be back. She knew that his heart would forever belong to her.
HoldIng my breathe, won't lose you again
She was so heartbroken when he left. She spent years opening up Nick to trusting her and finally when she had figured him out he told her that he had a destiny to full fill and she would get in the way of it, and they were just high school sweethearts its not like they were planning to get married after high school.
Something's made your eyes go cold
"We're to young to be any thing serious, Rae I love you, I do but this is something I have to do this… For me" His words echoed through her mind.
Stood there and watched you walk away From everything we had
She let him leave, instead of trying to reason with him she got her things told him she'll drop all the stuff he gave her at his parent's house and walked back to her house. Rachel left for New York and had a good run on Broadway because although she was heart broken did not mean she wouldn't make her dreams come true. After winning 3 Tony's and 7 years, she came back to Lima ready to teach the New Direction's Glee Club, after Mr. Shue's heartbreaking retirement.
He will try to take away my pain And he just might make me smile But the whole time I'm wishin he was you instead
She tried her best to date but no one had ever compared to Nick, although she was currently in a relationship with her (ex) boyfriend Finn Hudson. She knew that the only reason they were (sort of) together was because both had found love and lost. After the death of Santana Lopez-Hudson. Finn was so heartbroken and finally was starting to become whole know, and Rachel knew a part of that was because of her. Whenever she was with Finn she felt her self become so alive. It wasn't exactly the same feeling she got with Nick but it was better that feeling nothing at all…
*Knock-Knock*
Rachel got up and walked to the door of her apartment forgetting what she was only wearing an old shirt of Finn's and her undies…
"I was wondering when you'd show up, come on in Nick"
Continue? R&R?