The morning after Halloween. Always a mess. Sam, Cas,and Dean had some tricks still up their sleeves and they saw this trick the night before while watching Jimmy Kimmel, so they decided to try it out for themselves on their unsuspecting little sister, Carter. They sat at the kitchen table, rubbed chocolate on their faces and waited for Carter. Dean got out the video camera to film Carter's reaction. Carter came into the walking into the kitchen, where Sam let out a groan.
"Morning everyone. What's wrong, Sam? And why do y'all have chocolate on your faces?" asked Carter
"I think I ate too much." groaned Sam, rubbing his distended stomach gently.
Cas and Dean nodded in agreement.
"Too much of what?" asked Carter.
"Candy." groaned Cas
"Your candy." groaned Dean.
Carter started to laugh.
"That's not possible." she said, through her laughter. "I hid all it so none of you could get it."
"Well Carter, we found it and pigged out while you were asleep." said Dean as he puts up the "Scouts honor" hand.
Carter's smile turned into a frown.
"You guys seriously ate all my candy?" she asked on the verge of tears.
"Yep." said Cas. "It was delicious."
Carter began to cry. She pounded the wall.
"Why the hell did you eat all my candy?!" she bellowed
"Well Carter, as you know, I'm pregnant and I got a craving for candy and Cas and Dean wanted in." said Sam.
"But I was gonna share that with all of you and then give the rest to the families aren't doing so well." sobbed Carter
Carter was on the verge of hyperventilating and ran upstairs to her room and locked the door to her closet. The boys got up the steps and knock on her closet door.
"Carter?" asked Dean
"Leave me alone!" she bellowed.
"Carter, we're sorry we ate all your candy." said Sam.
"Come out so we can talk." said Cas
"No!" she cried.
They were starting to feel really bad. She was a very sensitive girl.
"Carter, sweetheart come out here. We didn't eat any of your candy." said Sam.
The closet door opened.
"You didn't?" Carter sniffled
"No." Sam said. "We didn't touch your candy."
"Then why did you lie?" asked Carter, balling up her fists
"Well because it's Halloween and we wanted to trick you."
"Well, that isn't very nice."
"We saw it on Jimmy Kimmel and it seemed like a pretty funny thing to do at the time, but now I guess it's not."
Carter went up to the camera and said. "I hate you, Jimmy Kimmel!"
"And that ladies and gentlemen was three brothers pranking their younger sister. Join us tomorrow for more of parents saying they ate their children's candy." Said Jimmy on the tv