Description:
Instead of Kurt being asked to spy on the Warblers, Santana is asked to spy on the Show Stoppers, one of the rival show choirs at sectionals from Madison Academy, an all-girls private school/boarding school that Brittany S. Pierce attends.
Blaine has always attended McKinley, and Brittany has never met any of the New Directions.
Introduction
Santana strolled into the choir room at lunch and smiled weakly at Puck as she took a seat next to him, as she had done each day since joining glee club. As the other students filed in to take their seats, Santana became lost in thought as she did during most lunch time rehearsals, showing her lack of interest in any activity that Mr Schue had planned for that day. Her gaze landed on Puck who was sat beside her scrunching pieces of paper into balls to place inside a straw that he was rolling between his teeth. Santana rolled her eyes.
Santana's POV
I'm not dating Puck, I never have been and I never will be. When Quinn and I joined glee club to spy for Sue, Quinn decided that we needed a way of keeping up appearances, and she thought that the best way to do this was to associate with the 'right' kind of people. Even though Puck is in glee club too, he's still always been feared by many of the students at McKinley because of his 'bad boy' attitude and the fact that he's still on the football team. Don't get me wrong, not many people would choose to cross me anyway because I don't give off the friendliest vibe, but Quinn was determined to keep up our reputation as the most important people at McKinley.
Although Santana was often with Puck in public, it was only for appearances, as she had no genuine interest in him. Due to Quinn and Santana's popularity at McKinley, most students assumed that Santana had slept with a lot of people, but the truth was she hadn't. In fact, Santana was a virgin.
Santana's POV
No one knows that I'm a virgin. Not even Quinn. At the end of our Freshman year, Quinn so graciously informed me that during my Sophomore year I HAD to lose my virginity to keep up our reputation, and I had no intention of doing that. So, I spun her some bullshit story that I had slept with a guy I met in Europe over the summer and she bought it. She had no reason not to.
Since then, Santana had fooled around with Puck to give him the impression that she was interested in him and kept him under the pretence that they would eventually have sex. But Santana knew that it would never happen. At the time she thought that she knew the reason for her not being interested in any of the boys at McKinley: She had always been independent and sometimes cruel to prevent people from getting too close to her and leaving like her father had done, at least... that was what her therapist always told her. That may have been part of the reason, but a string of events that began that day would make Santana realise that this was not the primary explanation for it at all.