Takes place after Rachel sang 'Total eclipse of the Heart'

Thankyou for the story alerts you guys =)

Rachel was just standing there alone after pouring her heart out in song to 3 boys she once dated, tears streaming down from her eyes. How could she be so stupid. Rachel walked out and headed home. She has to do something. Reaching home she said her hi's to her dads then heading to her room. Rachel decided to take action, she loves Finn but also Jessie and Noah well everyone likes a bad boy.

'What can I do I want all 3' She thought as she unloaded her bag arranging her school books back into alphabetical order. 'How can I chose between them?'

"Rachel?" One of her dads called from downstairs. "Dinners on"

She's going to have to decide later. After dinner she completely forgot about the whole 'figure out which boy to be with'. It was only untill later that night when she went upstairs to go to sleep she saw a picture of Jessie and her pulling freaky faces, on her bed. 'Oh God I forgot!' She picked up the photo and put it with the one she had of Finn and Noah. 'Ahh I can't chose one' She stared at the photo's. How was she supposed to chose between 3 boys she likes? 3 boys she went out with. 3 boys who she wants.

"That Run Joey Run video was a mistake" Rachel muttered to herself. She's racking her brains thinking how she could go about deciding something so important. They all went to her school. "I can't cho- wait a minute. I'll just do a Pro and Con list"

She pulled out a peice of paper from her desk and started writing all the bad and good points of her 3 boys.

'Jessie

Pros: Good looking, Smart, Brilliant singer, Wants the same dream as I do, will stop at nothing to get it, I think im falling for him, He moved schools for me.

Cons: He's kinda arrogant, everyone does not like him, he's not as sweet as Finn hell he's not Finn.

Finn

Pros: His smile, his ability to make my heart flutter every time he sings.

Cons: He breaks my heart some way or another, He can't sing like Jessie can, My dreams will probably mean in the end I'll have to leave him, He cares about his reputation.

Noah

Pros: BAD BOYYY, theres two sides to him Sweet Noah and Bad boy Noah, He serenaded me in Glee, He's Jewish like me, His Body.

Cons: He's a bit tempermental, He slept with Quinn, He got someone pregnant.'

"Right now to decide."

It took Rachel all night to figure out who to go with because even though Jessie has more Pro's doesnt mean that she would go for him. Finally she decided that she cant chose one on facts and figures so 3 would have to pick with her eyes closed. Whoever it would be destiny would have chose it. She hovered her fingure above each one, finally stopping she peeked through one eye then the other. She had chose one.

Now she has to think of a plan to get him back.

I know its short but the next one will be longer. Review.