"Captain Tory" by Ethan Webb
A father and his son were walking from a pizza place down town. They were walking by the sea, and he swung his lantern three times and slowly the schooner appeared.
The man and the boy slowly crept to the ship. Then pirates jumped out of the ship and kidnap them. The man and boy were screaming, and people walking down by the sea heard them screaming and called the police.
The police came to the scene nothing was there. The cops were talking to the witnesses what happened. Then a cop looks down stream and lights on a suspicious boat, so they went to check it out.
The cops were chasing the ship and the cops hit a pot hole then the car flipped. The boat and the father and the kid were never seen again….Five years later, the same thing happened.