Contents:

1. 5x04, A Katy or a Gaga, What if Kurt had made out with Elliot and told Blaine about it

2. 5x05, End of Twerking, Jealousy will drive you mad

3. 5x07, Puppet Master, How the endscene should have been

4. 5x08, Unaired Christmas, Secret Santa

5. 5x12, The Blam Confusion

6. 6x02, Bad Timing

7. 6x03, (Sam is) Annoying Karofsky

8. 6x04 It's Back Shave Day

9. Glee Goodbye


A Katy or a Gaga 5x04

What if Kurt had made out with Elliot and told Blaine about it

„You… you what?"

Blaine stared at the phone though this wouldn't undo what Kurt just told him.

"I'm sorry, Blaine. But maybe you can forgive me seeing as you did the same –"

"What do you think this is, a game? Getting even? I thought we agreed to try our best in this second attempt", Blaine said. He massaged his temples. Kurt had had no right to go and make out with someone from his band just because Blaine had cheated on him some time ago. They had put this past them, hadn't they?

"Of course not! It just happened and –"

Kurt's high voice bored almost painful into Blaine's ear. He couldn't do this. Before he knew it he had broken the connection. His hand clenched hard around his phone. He got up from his bed and threw the phone into a corner, letting out a scream.

"Is someone murdering you?"

Sam came into his room. Blaine's parents had probably let him in, they usually did. The blond looked worried as he closed the door and turned to Blaine. Worried but also cute and Blaine wondered why on earth he had put so much energy into forgetting all about his crush on Sam in the last few weeks when Kurt simply went with the first opportunity to kiss another boy.

Screw it!

With three big steps Blaine stood before Sam. In the back of his mind he asked himself what he was doing but in addition to his rage there was an upcoming rush of his feelings for Sam. It didn't give him a chance to be rational. He pushed Sam against the door and kissed him.

Sam made an "oh"-noise and put his hands lightly on Blaine's waist. His lips were warm and soft and the touch of them immediately remembered Blaine how much he had yearned for them. And they responded to his kiss, too. Very carefully and hesitant but they did. Blaine's heart started to race but his limbs went weak.

After a few moments Blaine got a grip on himself, moved back and took a deep breath before he opened his eyes.

"I'm sorry", he said.

"What happened?"

"It's just… Kurt." Blaine sighed. He drove a hand over his eyes and stepped away from Sam.

"Did you fight with him?"

"Yes. Well, he… he kissed someone else."

"Oh, I see. Yeah, totally reasonable to do the same instead of talking with him", Sam said. He went to the bed and sat down on it while Blaine remained standing and shook his head.

"What's the point? He was making lame excuses and I… I couldn't bear it anymore. It's the same as last time when he was in New York and I was here. Exactly the same! Almost no contact and when we skype he just talks about himself. Has he forgotten we're engaged?"

"Okay, so… break up with him."

Blaine stared at Sam. "What? No. He's my soul mate."

"Dude, you never even had another boyfriend. How can you be so sure?"

"I just am. My soul knows. One day you'll know what I am talking about."

"So… because I don't think this about Penny you think I should break up with her and just wait for something that maybe never comes?"

"No! Of course not… maybe you'll… maybe she is exactly this for you and you just need more time and…"

Blaine sighed, sat down next to Sam and buried his face in his hands. How should he know about Sam's relationships? It dawned to him that he didn't even know much about his own. Not when Kurt did things like this. Soul mates were supposed to be true to each other no matter how much distance was between them.

Then again Blaine had cheated first. So maybe it was really all about forgiving each other. Yeah, he should forgive Kurt. This so wasn't worth another fight or even break up. It just had been a kiss.

Apropos…

"I'm sorry, Sam. I didn't think and you had really bad timing coming in and… what can I say. I'm sorry."

Sam nodded.

"Okay."

"Okay?" Blaine snorted. "You shouldn't let yourself get kissed by anyone."

"It wasn't anyone. And I don't. If any other boy – or girl – from Glee club had kissed me I wouldn't have kissed back, don't be afraid."

"I'm…" Blaine turned his head to Sam. Suddenly his heart made a wild loop and he had to clear his throat before he could talk on.

"Then why… did you?"

Sam nudged Blaine. "Come on, sooner or later it had to happen, right? Now don't get all excited about it, I'm still not gay."

"Oh."

Without knowing he had had some Blaine's hopes were crashed and his heart made a dump sound as if shutting a door. He drove over his face once more and straightened his shoulders. No, he wouldn't run away from Kurt anyhow. He – they – would get through this.