I requested this fic a while ago, but then after it was written decided to write it more in the way I wanted it. The one written for me by carebearfan on OTHC was a very good story, just not how I pictured it. This was the request (plot summary):
When Haley came back at the end of the finale she tells Nathan she's pregnant, he doesn't believe that it's his. When the baby (girl) is born she looks just like Haley except for the eyes, but both Chris and Nathan have the same color eyes so he still doesn't believe it. Then flash to 16 years later when the child is attending Tree Hill High after Haley and her had left and just came back. Nathan is a basketball coach after Whitey retired and sees her trying out for basketball, then realizes who she is and that she's his daughter.
Also: Haley never signed the annulment papers, but Nathan doesn't know that, the kids last name is James-Scott.
All flashbacks will be in italics, but if you see italics as a continuation of a sentence, then it is a thought!
Prologue
"Hi," Haley said after Nathan had opened the door. That's all I could think to say, Hi?
After what seemed like a lifetime, but was only two minutes, Nathan finally spoke.
"What are you doing here?" he said harshly. Ouch!
"I wanted; no I needed to see you. I need to talk to you too."
"I don't want to hear what you have to say anymore. You had your chance to talk to me when I came to see you on tour. You said we made a mistake, so I left."
"I have something important to tell you," Haley said, pleading him to talk to her.
"Then say it and leave," he said, still in an angry tone. He couldn't believe she was back. He was finally starting to live his life again, a life after Haley. Why did she have to come back now? He was leaving the next day for High Flyers and she would be back on tour by the time he got back.
"I'm pregnant," she said softly. Nathan stood there, not even thinking about what he was saying anymore. He was so angry with her for everything she had done.
"Then why are you here with me, just go back and be with your baby's daddy," he said even more harsh than before.
"I am, that's why I'm here with you."
"There is no way that the baby you claim to be having is mine. You've been gone too long and have done too much to me for me to believe that it is mine." Now Haley was getting angry too.
"I never slept with Chris, you know how much sex means to me. Why would you think I slept with someone else?"
"Well I thought I knew how much our marriage meant to you, but you had no problem destroying that. So, go back on your tour, back to Chris, and leave me alone." Nathan shut the door and left Haley standing there surprised.
Please let me know if I should continue or not, if I get reviews I'll have the first chapter up soon.
Stephanie JJ
Disclaimer: I do not own One Tree Hill and am not in any way affiliated with it's production, I'm just a big fan!
