A/N: I really like the idea of having a season with Heroes vs. Villains; It's a good chance for all the contestants to redeem themselves (especially the ones from RotI). I feel the ones that were included in this story never finished their story, and I want a crack at the ones in here.

Disclaimer: I own none of the characters, I own no themes, but I do own some of the challenges and the plot.


Episode 1: Part 1: But I Was Nice in that Season!


Chris McClean stood on the now- famous dock of Wawanakwa Island, the island that held Seasons 1 and 4 of Total Drama. The island had retained its beauty it had in Season 1. He was bailed out of prison, and a new season was ready to begin.

"Hello to all the beloved, crazy, deranged, hatred- filled, but still beloved, Total Drama fans!" Chris greeted with his famous white toothy smile.

"I'm here, on Wawanakwa Island, all fresh and good looking! The island too!" Chris got hit with a boot. Chef came running and took his boot back while Chris rubbed his head.

"Here is where the next season of the Total Drama series commence. What will be this season's theme you ask? We took 24 of the past contestants of the last 4 Seasons who we thought should come back in their final stretch to become famous and one be a millionaire! In one of the best themes that we stole from CBS, we have:

"HEROES,

"VS.

"VILLAINS!"


(The theme song plays)


Chris stood by the dock, awaiting the first boat to come revealing a player.

"Every six players, I will reveal who will be on which team. There's the first boat!"

The boat docked, and Heather stepped off. She walked past Chris, staring at him intently and flipping her hair.

"Of course I'D be back on this show. I'm the best player!" Heather said smugly. Chris laughed.

"That's exactly what I want to hear from our very own Heather! I think it's easy to tell which team she'll be on." Chris said as Heather sat down on a log and started to file her nails.

"Whatever."

The next boat arrived and Leshawna came out of it and onto the dock. She took one look at Heather and rolled her eyes. "Great! I'll be on a team with her!" Leshawna yelled, glaring at the Queen Bee.

"What makes you think you're good enough to be on the Villains tribe?" Heather asked, frowning. "I don't really count being gullible as a evil move. I don't even think it's a friendly move, either."

Leshawna ground her teeth in anger. "I have done plenty enough to earn a spot on that team! Member when I threw you off the cliff?" Heather was interrupted as Sam jumped off the boat without looking up from his DS.

"Hi ladies. Nice to meet you two. My name's Sam!" Sam stuck out a hand for Leshawna to shake.

"Uhh... no thankyou." Leshawna rejected. Heather slapped her forehead.

"You're not evil!" Heather yelled. Leshawna growled as Sam sat on the grass and played his game again, but Chris snatched it and threw it in the water.

"No electronics, Sam! For the last time!" Chris yelled.

"!" Sam yelled and jumped in the water, only to get hit by a boat as Duncan walked off.

"Great, I just have to come back to this season. Whatever, I'm the best one here anyways. I already won a season!" Duncan scoffed. Leshawna and Heather looked at him with slits.

"Shut up, punky." Leshawna said. Duncan flipped her off and sat on the edge of the dock. Sam got on the dock and laid down and cried.

"She's gone! Gone I say!" Sam yelled and cried. Duncan kicked him.

"Shut up, nerd." The next boat arrived and Jo came off.

"What's up, future losers!" Jo yelled out. Leshawna groaned and Sam jumped up.

"Someone from my season!" Sam cried out, "How's it been, Jo?" Jo kicked him in the chest.

"Shut up, nerd." Her and Duncan laughed in unison, then glared at each other.

"Ew, it looks like a guy, but I see boobs." Heather said, examining Jo. Jo growled and punched her in the face.

"SAY IT AGAIN, I DARE YOU, BITCH!" Jo yelled in her face. Heather ran away, and Leshawna laughed.

The next boat arrived, and Noah stepped off.

"I wanna say that I'm gonna be on the Heroes team, but I know I'm going to be put on the Villains team just for my pure sarcasm and cinicalness. Well, McClean?" Noah said in a monotone voice.

"Why the hell did you bring him back." Duncan said.

"Go get a piercing in your tongue, will yeah? That way we don't have to care about what you say because it'll all be jibberish. But we already don't." Noah said to him. Duncan got up and held him by the shirt collar.

"What'd you say, Egghead?" Duncan snarled menacingly. He was stopped by Chris.

"It's time to place you 6 on your team!" Chris announced. "Heather and Duncan, you two are obviously on the Villain team."

"How nice." Heather said, making the 'ick' sign as Duncan wiggled his unibrow.

"Sam, you're on the Heroes team." Chris announced. Sam smiled and sat in the grass again.

"Looks like we're on the Villains team, Noah.." Leshawna said, dragging Noah towards Heather and Duncan.

"Hold it!" Chris yelled. "Noah is on the Villains team, and so is Jo. Leshawna, you're on the Heroes team!"

"WHAT?" Leshawna exclaimed. "B- but- bu-"

"You can honestly pretend you're shocked?" Noah asked. Jo and him walked to the Villains side, while Leshawna skulked to the Heroes'.


Heroes: Leshawna, Sam

Villains: Duncan, Heather, Jo, Noah


Confessional: B- But- But


Leshawna: But I'm plenty evil! *Looks around* Remember when I-... Or when I-... CRAP!


The next boat came, and Lightning jumped off, looking pumped.

"Alright! Let's do this! Lightning's ready! Let's go!" Lightning yelled, doing a jog around the others. He took one quick look at the old contestants, and immediately noticed a beauty. A big, loud, black, beauty.

"Hey baby," Lightning approached her, "Lightning can't see any others through your bright light. It's like your a juicy angel!"

Leshawna gasped and giggled. All the Villains burst out laughing at the two, the loudest being Jo.

"Shut up, crazy dude!" Lightning yelled. Jo stopped laughing, "I'm a GIRL!"

Another boat, another camper, and Harold stepped off, looking nerdy as ever. "Hi guys. I really hope I'm on the Villains team; I always thought I was more of a Villain type, but I also think being a Hero would be good for fans. I can't wait to find o-"

Harold saw Lightning and Leshawna giggling and talking over in the corner. He fumed.

"WHAT ARE YOU DOING, LESHAWNA!" Harold yelled, shocking the two. "I THOUGHT WE WERE TOGETHER! YOU WERE MY SUGAR MAMA!"

Leshawna rolled her eyes. "Get out of here, lil' punk!" Leshawna yelled, and Harold skulked away and sat next to Sam. The next boat arrived, and Lindsay came off of it.

"Hiii everyonee!" Lindsay greeted. "It's great to be on Wawananakaka Island again, Chip!"

Jo looked at Noah. "She's not so smart, is she." Noah shook his head. Lindsay walked over to Jo.

"Hello, my name's Lindsay! You look like a really nice guy!" Lindsay greeted. Jo punched her in the face and she staggered back onto Sam's lap. "Oh hi!"

"H- hello?" Sam said. At the perfect timing Dakota stepped out of the next boat.

"SAM! HOW COULD YOU?" Dakota ran to him and shoved Lindsay off. "WHAT THE HELL WAS THAT, SAM?"

"It was nothing, I promise!" Sam said, standing up and bringing Dakota close to him. "You know I love you, Dakotabear."

Harold stood up with him. "Yeah, that guy punched her and she fell on him, and then you came!" Sam looked at Harold with thanks.

"Okay, I guess that explains it..." Dakota said and hugged Sam. "Sorry.."

"Man, I can see why Chris would want to replace us with them.." Duncan sighed. Another boat came and Cody jumped off.

"Hey guys!" He walked over to Lindsay, "Ladies..."

"Hi Cod!" Lindsay greeted. Cody sighed.

"Yeah, hi Fish!" Heather snickered. Cody glared at her and walked towards Noah.

"Hey Noah! What's up?" Cody greeted his friend. Noah glared at him.

"I don't want to talk to you. Go away." Cody back away and left him.

"Touchy." Cody grumbled. Everyone looked at the boat that came next, and the person who came off.

"Oh my God.." Duncan gasped. Courtney greeted the people she didn't know with kindness.

"Hello, my name is Courtney!" Courtney said as she shook Sam's hand, and then Dakota's. She walked over to Jo.

"Pleasure to meet you!" She held out a hand for Jo. Jo pushed her off.

"You look like a fake. I don't like fakes." Jo grumbled. Courtney gasped.

"But I'm only being nice!" Courtney burst out. All the old campers laughed, while the newer ones looked confused.

"Lightning's confused." Lightning said.

"Don't be. Don't trust that girl, she's plain devious." Leshawna stated, staring at Courtney. Courtney stared back. Chris popped out of nowhere, because now it was the time to announce who's on what team.

"Okay, let's see... Cody and Lindsay, you two are on the Heroes team!" Chris announced. Cody and Lindsay smiled and stayed where they were by Sam. Dakota was crossing her fingers.

"Dakota... Heroes!" Chris said. Dakota cheered and hugged Sam. "Lightning is on the Villains team!"

"WHAT?" Leshawna yelled. She stared at Lightning in shock. Lightning shrugged sheepishly. "But that means... we can't hang out or talk!"

"Harold; Heroes. Courtney; Villains!" The newer contestants all looked at Courtney suspiciously.


Heroes: Cody, Dakota, Harold, Leshawna, Lindsay, Sam

Villains: Courtney, Duncan, Heather, Jo, Lightning, Noah


Confessional: I Almost Got Away with It Too, If It Weren't for You Meddling Kids.


Courtney: My whole plan was to be nice to the newer ones... but I guess I should have seen that coming. *Sighs* I need to rethink this through...

Lightning: When Lightning and Leshawna locked eyes, it was true love... but now we're separated by teams in the worst possible way! What is Lightning supposed to do now...?


A foot stomped onto the dock, and everyone went silent as they saw Eva. Even Duncan and Jo went silent.

"Hey." Eva said in a regular sounding- tone. No one answered. "I SAID HEY!"

Various versions of nervous hi's to Eva were uttered. She grunted and sat by Jo.

"What's up?" Eva asked. Jo looked at her.

"Look, let's not play nice. We both know we don't like each other, so why don't we just stay out of the other's way until it comes time I beat you, okay?" Jo told her. Eva growled at her menacingly and turned away.

The next boat unloaded Beth, who looked around at the newer players happily.

"Hey everyone! My name's Beth! I'm happy we get to compete together!" Beth greeted.

"Is she fake too?" Dakota asked, pointing at Beth. Lindsay jumped up and ran to Beth and the two best friends shared a bear hug.

"Beth! I missed you so much!" Lindsay yelled. "And now we get to be on the same team with Sam and Cod and Lefawnda!"

"Aww, Lindsay!" Beth said, "I'm glad I'm the one name you remember!" Beth looked over at the Villains team and cringed when she saw Eva.

"Glad I'm not on that team..." Beth sighed in relief. Another boat docked, and off stepped-

"WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!" Owen yelled. He jumped off the boat, shaking the dock. He ran to the others and grabbed Dakota and Sam. "I'm so stoked to meet you guys! My name's Owen!"

Dakota shoved Owen away, detaching herself from him. "Ew, you smell like bologna!"

Sam however was laughing and when he got out of it he gave Owen a high- five. "You're a pretty fun guy, Owen!"

"Thanks, buddy!" Owen said. Jo and Lightning looked at the old contestants.

"These people are weird..." Jo said. Lightning nodded.

"Except for Leshawna... they all deserve the Horrible Award." Lightning responded.

"Alright, where's Zoey!" Anne Maria yelled as she jumped off the boat. She looked around, but couldn't find her. "Where da heck is she?"

"Zoey's not here. I don't even know if she's coming back!" Sam answered. Anne Maria snorted.

"Oh, she's comin' back. She's too weird for her not to come back on this show!" Anne Maria stated. "Ohhhh, when I lay my hands on her I'm gonna choke her!"

"What did this... Zoey, do?" Beth asked. Anne Maria turned to her.

"She stole my Veto!" The Jersey Shore Reject answered.

"Why is this Vh1 reject here? She looks like an Oompa Loompa met the 70's." Heather said, looking at Anne Maria. Anne Maria turned around and looked straight at her.

"WHY I OUTTA!" Anne Maria yelled and ran to Heather, punching her in the face. Meanwhile, Alejandro stepped off the boat, looking tan as ever with burn scars here and there.

"This seems highly inappropriate for this show. We should not be fighting." Alejandro said calmly, walking towards Anne Maria and Heather. The two girls looked at him; Heather snorted and Anne Maria marveled at him.

"Oh wow!" Anne Maria said. "Can I feel your arms? They look so... big!"

"Sure, if you want." Alejandro put out his arm and Anne Maria clasped it. Alejandro smirked at Heather, who just blew a cherry bomb.

"Stay away from him!" Courtney yelled out, pushing Anne Maria out of the way. "Anne Maria, he's evil! In World Tour he got almost everyone out by flirting with girls! DON'T trust him!"

Alejandro stared at Courtney while Anne Maria looked back and forth from the two.

"I don't care! His muscles are so gorgeous!" She went back to rubbing his arms.

"UGH!" Courtney yelled. Another boat docked and Tyler did a flip off of it, landing on his head and crashing through the dock.

"Hey... guys..." Tyler said as Cody and Sam helped him up. He shook himself dry and walked over to the Heroes, passing a silent Lindsay.

"Hello Lindsay." Tyler greeted. Lindsay took one look at him and turned the other way.

"What happened between you two? You used to be madly in love! Now it looks like Lindsay's sick of seeing you." Cody inquired. Tyler looked sad and stared at the ground.

"Things happen.. people drift apart.." He closed his eyes. Cody and Harold looked at each other and back to Tyler.

"Well cheer up!" Harold said enthusiastically. "Don't be such a sour puss!"

"Yeah, you're right!" Tyler yelled out. "Why let something that happened ages ago ruin me now?"

"That's the spirit!" Cody cheered. Chris came out of nowhere again to announce the teams.

"Okay, even though it's kind of obvious where people stand, I want to announce it anyways!" Chris said. "Owen and Tyler, you two are on the Heroes team!"

"Awesome!" Owen yelled, hugging Tyler.

"Anne Maria and Eva are on the Villains team with Alejandro, and Beth is on the Heroes team!" Chris announced. The three newly proclaimed Villains shrugged, not caring.

"Yay! I get to be on your team, Lindsay!" Beth cheered.


Heroes: Beth, Cody, Dakota, Harold, Leshawna, Lindsay, Owen, Sam, Tyler

Villains: Alejandro, Anne Maria, Courtney, Duncan, Eva, Heather, Jo, Lightning, Noah


Confessional: They're Thirsty for Vengeance


Anne Maria: Zoey will pay! As soon as she gets here I'm gonna beat her up before she's forced onto the Heroes side!

Alejandro: Im not dumb. Of course Heather and Courtney would try to reveal me. But unfortunately for them, I'm just way too nice for the Revenge of the Island contestants to resist... *Smirks*

Tyler: Me and Lindsay broke up, right after she came off her RotI cameo. It's been kind of hard to deal with, and just when I can get away from it all here, it comes with me..


The next boat arrived, and most of the girls were shocked. Justin stepped out, smiling at them all.

"Hey everyone." Justin said calmly and flipped his hair and added a charming smile, which had even Owen drooling.

"He's so..." Dakota started, "Dreamy..."

Beth and Lindsay remained unfazed and held straight faces. Justin looked at Beth and walked over to her.

"Hey Beth, hows my favorite girl doing?" Justin said. Beth held her composer.

"I don't like you anymore Justin. Me and Lindsay aren't Katie and Sadie! We're not gonna follow you around like mindless servants after you tried to use us!" Beth stated, with Lindsay nodding all the way through. Justin bent down to whisper in Beth's ear.

"Listen, don't ruin me and I won't ruin you. I can tell anyone here that you voted me off after pushing me off the castle, and no one would say anything." Justin whispered deviously.

"How do you know they wont defend me?" Beth asked, glaring.

"Because, Duncan wouldn't care, Courtney would say it to save her own reputation, Harold was knocked out, and Lindsay's too stupid to remember." Justin said.

"Get away from me." Beth said angrily. Justin walked away, and out from another boat came Dawn.

"Hi everyone. It's very nice to meet all of you." Dawn said peacefully.

"Hey white girl! Man are you WHITE!" Leshawna greeted, shaking her hand.

"It's nice to meet you, Leshawna. I sense you are very nice by your yellow- green aura!" Dawn stated.

"I don't know what that means, but okay, girl!" Leshawna said, smiling happily. Dawn walked over to the grass and stroked it soundly. All the while Noah was staring at her, weirded out by her nature.

"You gonna marry the grass and have babies with it?" Noah said, but with no use on Dawn.

"If you could please wander off.. I do not associate with people with gold- colored aura. Tell me, have you ever thought of being less cynical?" Dawn retorted. Noah huffed and left.

Another boat docked, and Sierra jumped out.

"Oh my God." Cody whispered. Sierra was prancing around, saying hi to everyone.

"Hi! My name is Sierra!" She greeted Dawn, shaking her hand.

"Hi Sierra, it's very nice to meet you. I love people with lavender aura!" Dawn stated. Sierra smiled and walked to Cody.

"Hi Cody! It's been a while, how are you?" Sierra asked, surprisingly calm. Cody stopped cringing and smiled a little.

"Good.. good.. how about you?" Cody asked.

"I've been great!" Sierra said happily. "Nice talking to you!"

"You too..." Cody said, thinking about what happened as Sierra walked away and another boat docked. A certain red- haired girl walked out, flower in her hair. Anne Maria looked at the boat and charged.

"Hi everyone, it's gre- OOPH!" Zoey was interrupted by Anne Maria punching her in the stomach.

"Take that you boy stealer!" Anne Maria yelled. Zoey punched her back in the face, making everyone gasp.

"You... little... BITCH!" Anne Maria tried to jump on her when Alejandro held her back, and Zoey was about to pounce on Anne Maria when Brick held her back.

"Brick? Let me go! I wanna get her back!" Zoey said, squirming around. Brick shook his head no.

"Sorry Zoey, but I cant let that happen. You'll turn into a Villain if you were to let this fight continue!" Brick told her.

"Let her go! I wanna fight her before she goes on that loser Heroes team!" Anne Maria yelled. Both girls struggled, but were still held back.

"I didn't steal Mike! He was mine to begin and end with!" Zoey yelled.

"Damn. They're crazy." Heather said. The last boat arrived, and off jumped the last contestant... Ezekiel!

"Hey guys.." Ezekiel said sheepishly. He scanned all the contestants, and saw his queen: Anne Maria. He immediately dashed to her.

"Anne Maria!" Ezekiel yelled. Anne Maria looked at him, trying to process who he was. Then she realized.

"YOU!" She yelled, "YOU GAVE ME A FAKE DIAMOND AND I QUIT BECAUSE I THOUGHT IT WAS REAL!

"I'm sorry! I honestly am!" Ezekiel begged. Anne Maria turned cold shoulder.

"Whatever. Be sorry all you want!" Anne Maria said. In came Chris, ready to announce which team the last 6 would be on.

"Okay! Final team members! Brick is on the Heroes team!" He said. Brick smiled bright and moved over to the other guys on his team and looked over them, and suddenly wasn't happy anymore.

"Dawn! Heroes!" Dawn also looked happy and joined her new team. That left 4: Justin, Zoey, Sierra, and Ezekiel.

"Ezekiel and Justin! You're both on the Villains!" Ezekiel looked downtrodden, but Justin already knew it was coming. Zoey and Sierra both sighed and Sierra went to the Villains' side and Zoey the Heroes'.

"Wait!" Chris yelled. Both girls looked at him. "Sierra, your on Heroes. Zoey, that means you're on Villains!"

"WHAT! B- BUT I WAS NICE IN THAT SEASON!" Zoey yelled, utterly shocked. Anne Maria snickered at her, while Sierra happily joined the Heroes side and Cody greeted her.

"When we come back, we have our season's first challenge! Stay tuned for Total Drama:

"HEROES!

"VS.

"VILLAINS!"


Camper Count:

Heroes: Beth, Brick, Cody, Dakota, Dawn, Harold, Leshawna, Lindsay, Owen, Sam, Sierra, Tyler

Villains: Alejandro, Anne Maria, Courtney, Duncan, Eva, Ezekiel, Heather, Jo, Justin, Lightning, Noah, Zoey

Eliminated: None


Well that's it for Chapter 1! I thought it looks pretty good.

I'm thinking about updating once a week, and I'll update next week on Wednesday! That's kind of the one day I don't do anything. But I'm basing this on predictions, so if I have to do an ROTC thing Wednesday then there'll probably be no update. We'll have to see!

Well, review/ comment telling me what you think of the teams and people competing! I'll eventually post chapters of