4: Why

"Guys" Justin said into his phone. "Ashlee's dead." Justin was talking to Donna, Ashton & Mrs. Smith. "What happened?"Donna asked. "She was crushed by a falling sign," Justin replied. "The thing that was creepiest was that the letters that didn't get blood on them spelled die. Listen, I've got to go home. I've got blood all over me." "Come back as soon as you can" Donna said as she & Justin hung up. Donna decided to call Binns. "Tell me exactly how they all died," Donna said as soon as she heard Binns' voice. "They all had different deaths," Binns said. "One who got hit by a bus, one who got decapitated by an elevator, one who got killed by a car engine fan-" "No," Donna interrupted. "What order did they die in?" "They died in the order they would've died," Binns said, "If they had gotten on the ship." "Thanks," Donna said as she hung up. "Let me write this down." "What?"Ashton asked. "The order we die," Donna replied. When Donna was done writing this is what the list looked like:

Ashlee

Mrs. Smith

Justin

Ashton

Donna

"You're up Mrs. Smith," Donna said. Mrs. Smith looked grim. "I don't know why this is happening," Donna said. "I didn't want any of this to happen. I really didn't. I want to know why I got this." Neither Mrs. Smith nor Ashton had an answer. So they all were silent, waiting for Justin's return.