DISCLAIMER: I do not own My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic. My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic is the property of Hasbro and any other legal owners. Any other works referenced by the author not property of the author are property of their respective owners. Original characters that appear in this fanfic are mine.
NOTE: This is a sequel to the infamous "Cupcakes" fanfic. Character death is a given. The first paragraph is taken from "Cupcakes", with the story taken from there. Gore is present. Viewing the episode "Too Many Pinkie Pies" before reading would also be useful, as some major plot points come from that particular episode. This fanfic is more "sad" than "horror", but still rated Mature. Shipping warning: Rainbow Dash/Applejack; Rarity/Pinkie Pie; Twilight/Fluttershy. I am sure there are some continuity issues, and some out-of-character moments, but this is a fan fiction, not an official canon. Any constructive criticism would be appreciated, as I am still new at writing fan fiction. Hope you enjoy.
Chapter 1
The blade sunk into the blue throat and worked its way up to Dash's chin. Coming back down, Pinkie's scalpel then circled Dash's neck. The last think Rainbow Dash felt was her skin being cut away from her skull, and the metal of the blade scraping her teeth.
Than she was gone.
Pinkie stirred at the gruesome mess she had just made. It sunk into her Pinkie head that Rainbow Dash was gone. Pinkie was momentarily sad she would not get another chance to hang our with her friend ever again. No more pranking or aerial stunts. Pinkie cheered up as she saw the last few drops of Dash's life force drip into a pan. These ingredients would make the best cupcakes! And the body was relatively well preserved. Maybe she could...keep the skin...stuff Rainbow like one of those safari trophies...and keep her friend forever! She had both the special ingredient and her friend...she could have her cupcake and eat it too. Pinkie chuckled at this pun.
Her chuckling was interrupted by the opening of the basement door. In the doorway was a purple alicorn.
"What the...?" Twilight Sparkle exclaimed, stupefied by the sight before her.
No no no. This was suppose to be an exclusive party. Twilight wasn't invited...her number hadn't come up. But since she had crashed the party, Pinkie figured, might as well collect some more ingredients. Pinkie had made cupcakes from earth, unicorn, and pegasus ponies, but never alicorn...these would be extra special cupcakes. Excited at the prospect of trying a new recipe, Pinkie charged at Twilight, bloody knife in her mouth. The startled Twilight shot out a few sparks from her horn, stopping Pinkie in her place, knife cluttering on the floor as Pinkie fell. Now that the immediate danger had passed, Twilight surveyed the room more, until her glaze stopped at a blue pegasus on a rack.
"Dear Celestia, no."