A/n: Italics = Shane/ Caitlyn's voice in phone conversations and Lyrics
Bold/ Italics = Shane and Mitchie talking through the door.
Bold = Flashbacks
Disclaimer: I don't own the characters, they are own by Disney. If I did Nick would be mine. I don't own Should've Said No, Taylor Swift does. The only thing I do own is this plot.
Should've said no
Hey Mitchie this is Cailtyn…Would you like to go to the movies tonight. Just call me at 735-856 when you get this message.
"Hey Cailtyn" I said.
"Hey Mitchie I guess you got the message" Cailtyn said.
"Yes Caitlyn I did and I would love to go to the movies" I said.
"Great I'll meet you there at six" Cailtyn said. Bye…
"Wait Cailtyn what movie are we going to see"? I asked.
" I knew I was forgetting something, 17 again" Caitlyn answered.
" OK then, I can't wait," I said. "See you then, bye" I said.
"Bye Mitchie" Cailtyn said.
--------------------------Three hours later----------------------------------------
"Wow this movie theater is packed," I said surprised.
"Mitchie it is the premiere of 17 again, what did you except"? Cailtyn asked.
"It is," I said surprised. "I guess I haven't been paying a attention," I said.
"Obviously" Cailtyn said. "Mitchie it's your turn to get a ticket" Cailtyn said.
I then paid for my ticket and Cailtyn did the same. We then got are popcorn and soft drinks and walked in to the Movie Theater.
The first thirty minutes of the movie turned out to be real good, but that's when I noticed a couple making out. It just wasn't any couple it was my boyfriend Shane and another girl. I couldn't believe it that Shane was cheating on me. I then told Cailtyn I had to leave pointing to the couple and she noticed it right away and nodded. I then left the movie crying tears that shouldn't have ever been wasted on that jerk. I then go in to my car and drove home.
----------------------------------------The next day-------------------------------------------
"Mitchie this Shane, please pick up, why are you ignoring me" Shane said.
"Because you cheated on me you insensitive jerk," I said.
"What are you talking about Mitchie, I never…
"Don't deny it Shane, yeah I saw you do it "I said angrily. I saw you making out with that blond girl of a creep last night, so don't deny it.
"Mitchie I'm sorry, I'll take it all back, let's just forget the whole thing," Shane said. Just give me a chance, please he was crying.
"How about no" I said angrily, then hanged up the phone really hard.
It's strange to think the songs we used to sing
You're the missing piece I needThe song inside of me (this is me)
The smiles, the flowers, everything: is gone
"I love you Mitchie" Shane said smiling. He then handed me a bouquet of roses.
"I love you to" I said smiling.
Yesterday I found out about you
I looked around and saw this couple making out, but it wasn't just any couple; it was my boyfriend. I couldn't believe it; he was cheating on me.
Even now just looking at you: feels wrong
The door rang and I opened it to see Shane and I just slammed it shut in front of his face. It felt wrong even looking at him.
You say that you'd take it all back, given one chance
Mitchie please take me back he yelled through the door, I'll take it all back, please just give me one chance.
It was a moment of weakness and you said yes...
You gave in and kissed her I yelled. It was moment of weakness.
You should've said no, you should've gone home
You just should've have gone home, instead of giving in the to that creep.
You should've thought twice before you let it all go
"Mitchie please I need you" Shane said.
"You should have thought twice before you kissed her" I screamed.
You should've know that word, bout what you did with her
Would get back to me...
You should have known I would have found out, before cheated on me.
And I should've been there, in the back of your mind
I shouldn't be asking myself why
"Why did he do it"? I thought to myself.
You shouldn't be begging for forgiveness at my feet...
"Please Mitchie give me one chance, I'm begging you" Shane said.
You should've said no, baby and you might still have me
You should've said no and you still would have had me, but we are through Shane Adam Grey. Forever!
You can see that I've been crying
There where tear stains on her face and she had red puffy eyes
And baby you know all the right things: to say
Mitchie I promise I won't do it ever again. You're my whole world, my reason for living.
But do you honestly expect me to believe
We could ever be the same...
If you believe it could ever be the same your wrong. I can never trust you again.
You say that the past is the past, you need one chance
Mitchie the past is the past and I need one chance to show you that I'll never do it again.
It was a moment of weakness and you said yes...
Let's face it, your weak and will give in to any girl.
You should've said no, you should've gone home
You just should've have gone home, instead of giving in the to that creep.
You should've thought twice before you let it all go
"Mitchie please I need you" Shane said.
"You should have thought twice before you kissed her" I screamed.
You should've know that word, bout what you did with her
Would get back to me...
You should have known I would have found out, before cheated on me.
And I should've been there, in the back of your mind
I shouldn't be asking myself why
"Why did he do it"? I thought to myself.
You shouldn't be begging for forgiveness at my feet...
"Please Mitchie give me one chance, I'm begging you" Shane said.
You should've said no, baby and you might still have me
You should've said no and you still would have had me, but we are through Shane Adam Grey. Forever! Know just leave.
I can't resist... before you go, tell me this
Was it worth it...
"NO" Shane sobbed out!
Was she worth this...
"No she wasn't worth the pain or regret" Shane said.
You should've said no, you should've gone home
You just should've have gone home, instead of giving in the to that creep.
You should've thought twice before you let it all go
"Mitchie please I need you" Shane said.
"You should have thought twice before you kissed her" I screamed.
You should've know that word, bout what you did with her
Would get back to me...
You should have known I would have found out, before cheated on me.
And I should've been there, in the back of your mind
I shouldn't be asking myself why
"Why did he do it"? I thought to myself.
You shouldn't be begging for forgiveness at my feet...
"Please Mitchie give me one chance, I'm begging you" Shane said.
You should've said no, baby and you might still have me
You should've said no and you still would have had me, but we are through Shane Adam Grey. Forever! Know just leave.
I then open the door and told him to leave.
"Please Mitchie don't do this to me" Shane sobbed. I love you more then life it self.
"Yeah right, Shane and then I give in and you hurt me again" I said. "Not going to happen I said.
But Mitchie I promise I'll never…
"No matter how many times you say it, I'll never believe you or forgive you" I screamed. So just leave Shane, please.
"Fine, but you'll regret this for the rest of your entire life" Shane screamed! He then left my house and to never see me again.
But little did I know that wasn't the last time I'll see him.
A/n: I came up with this idea, when I was listening to Should've Said NO. So please review. I hope you guys like it and yes there will be a sequel, How do I know that you love me.
Summery: Mitchie found the perfect guy, but then Shane comes back a different person. But how does Mitchie know if Shane really loves her or not.