A/N: Hello everyone. This is my very first story on fanfiction. I love iCarly; it's one of my favorite shows. I want to know what you guys think, so let me know by sending me a review, please. :)

Summary: Melanie returns! She surprises Sam when she comes into town. She and Sam begin to get along, but Melanie has a secret. Carly tells Sam her secret, but Sam doesn't know who to believe. Will she choose friendship, or her own flesh and blood?

Disclaimer: I don't own iCarly :(. That would be awesome though!

Here is the first chapter! Enjoy!

Chapter 1: Melanie?

"Carly!" Sam called from outside Carly's apartment door.

"Come in!" Carly called. Sam came in and set down her bag. She suddenly saw a giant taco where the couch was.

"Where's your couch?"

"That's my question."

"What up, Giblets?" Spencer said coming through the door.

"Hey," Carly said. "What's with the taco?"

"Well, you know that taco place down the street?" he asked.

"El Taco Guapo?" Sam asked.

"Yeah, well, they need a new sign out front and they asked me to build it."

"Cool," Carly said.

"Hey," Freddie said, coming through the door. "We need to rehearse for the next iCarly."

"Hey, what's that smell?" Sam asked, suspiciously.

"Oh, we had chili last night," Carly said.

"Is there any left?"

"Sam!"

"Sorry."

"Come on, we gotta rehearse."

"I'll be up in a sec."

"Okay, but hurry." Carly pushed the elevator button. As soon as the elevator door closed, Sam ran into the kitchen, and opened the refrigerator. She pulled out the bowl of chili.

"That's the good stuff."

"In 5, 4, 3, 2,-" Freddie pointed to Carly and Sam.

"I'm Carly!" Carly said.

"I'm Sam!" Sam said.

"And this is iCarly!" They both said.

"We're gonna start off the show with a pretty weird video. Freddie?"

"Cuing the video." There was some old guy on the screen.

"Hi Carly and Sam, watch this!" He started break dancing like he just won the lottery.

"That's one of weirdest videos we've ever gotten." Carly said, laughing a little.

"Disturbing." Sam said.

After the show, Carly, Sam and Freddie went to the Groovy Smoothies.

"Ok, here we go." Carly said, sitting the smoothies on the table.

"Finally," Sam said, annoyed.

"Great show tonight," Freddie said to Carly and Sam.

"Yeah, I thought so too," Carly said. "What did you think, Sam? Sam?"

"What?"

"Did you think we did a great show tonight?"

"Oh, yeah," Sam said, slurping her smoothie. Carly and Freddie were starring at her. "I was thinkin' about fried chicken!"

"We're home!" Carly called. "Spencer?"

"Hey, Carly," Spencer said.

"I brought you back a blueberry banana blitz." Carly handed Spencer the smoothie.

"Thanks."

"How's the sculpture going?"

"Awesome! I'm almost finished with it, see?" Spencer pointed to his almost finished taco.

"Awesome," Carly said.

"Hey, I rented Galaxy Wars from that video place across the street. Let's watch it!"

"Ok, but first I need some food," Sam said.

"Sam, you just had a large smoothie," Carly reminded her.

"What's your point?" Just then the doorbell rang. Spencer was putting the DVD in.

"I'll get it." Sam walked over to the door. She opened it slowly. She saw the person at the door. She froze.

"Hey, Sam!" A high soprano voice said.

"Melanie?"