DISCLAIMER: I DON'T OWN GLEE
Setting is Rachel running out of Finns house because they were going to have sex but then Finn told the truth so Rachel ran out. Enjoy-sorry if it sucks it was an idea and written quickly
"Rachel!"
"Leave me alone Finn"
"Rachel stop!" he grabbed my arm.
"Don't touch me!" I yanked it back
"Rach-please I'm sorry."
"You're sorry? Well that makes everything all better now doesn't it?" my voice dripped with sarcasm "You lied. You lied to me Finn. You told me you didn't sleep with Santana, you told me you were waiting for the right person. Was she the right person to you Finn? Did you lie when you told me you loved me?"
"No!"
"Then why did you do it?"
"Because of you and Jesse!" he yelled "Because you were with Jesse and I was jealous. Ok? Santana told me you were sleeping with him, and she offered to help me lose my V card. She said it would make you jealous."
Crap. "Finn-"
"When you told me you were ready I panicked and it slipped out-I was gonna tell you though Rach, I had it all set I was gonna tell you this week. I know that when you slept with Jesse-"
"I didn't." I said barely loud enough for him to hear. He looked at me
"What?"
"I didn't have sex with Jesse. . .I lied too. I only told you that to make you jealous. I shouldn't even care that you slept with Santana-we weren't even together at the time-I'm being irrational and, I mean, who hasn't slept with Santana?"
A huge smile started to spread across his face. "What?" I asked "Why are you staring at me?" he still didn't answer "Finn?" no answer "Finn I swear if you don't-" he hugged me and spun me around in a circle.
"You didn't sleep with Jesse?"
"No-" he kissed me
"You lied about it?"
"Yes-" he kissed me again
"You couldn't go through with it?"
"No-" he kissed me once again and pulled back.
"I love you."
"I love you too Finn." I was so confused at the moment; he wasn't yelling at me-no voices were being raised. Why? "You're not mad?" I spoke each word slowly
"Nope." he smiled.
"But I lied."
"Yep."
"To make you jealous."
"Uh huh."
"I yelled at you."
"Yeah." he smiled.
"I'm confused." I said. He laughed
"Rach, you lied to me about sleeping with Jesse, and I lied to you about sleeping with Santana."
"Yeah?"
"I have no right to be mad at you. I'm happy Jesse St. Jackass wasn't your first."
"So...we have no right to be mad at eachother? We can move past this?"
"Yes."
"We can continue the night like it was originally planned?" I asked lacing my fingers though his. He raised his eyebrows
"You mean-?" I nodded
He smiled. I walked towards his house with him towing behind me. Tonight was gonna be great