Author's note: These fics are based on real episodes from all four seasons of Supernatural. The characters and plots belong to the creator and writers for the show. I have my own plot twists and also additional, original episodes later in the series.
Scarecrow
Piece of apple pie: $2.50
Rope to tie your human sacrifices to trees: $19.99
Having the creepy scarecrow show up and kill the people who've been feeding it humans for decades…Priceless.
Kayla watched the scene from behind a tree she couldn't help but laugh, which gave away her hiding spot. The three innocents turned to look at her.
"Bet they didn't see that one coming." She commented.
The taller one, the one she'd heard called Sam, questioned her first. "Who are you?"
"No time for chit chat!" Kayla glanced past the girl to the two guys, her eyes lingered a moment as she walked by them. "Though I'd like to…but I have a tree to burn."
Sam turned to his brother in question but rolled his eyes when he saw him checking the girl out. Dean un-tilted his head and smirked to Sam before following her.
"Wait up."
"Yeah?" She tried not to look at them while she doused the tree in gasoline; they were most definitely a distraction.
"How long have you been standing back there?"
"Well," she started as she walked around the tree. "I saw you two tied up, I would have helped you out but your buddy was already headed your way. So I thought I'd get a jump start on the tree."
"So you knew about all this. You knew what was happening?" Sam asked but it sounded more like an accusation.
"Just recently, it's not like I was sitting on the information."
Dean pried a little further. "And you thought you'd be a good samaritan and lift a curse."
"No, I thought I'd do my job."
"Your job?"
She glanced to Dean and paused a moment before answering. "I guess that sounds kind of psycho. It's more like, a hobby? Wow that's worse. But anyway it's really no big deal I mean there are a lot of hunters…" They both gave her disbelieving looks and she sighed quietly. "Just never mind."
"You're a hunter." Dean stated with skepticism. "We're hunters." How much damage could she possibly do?
The young girl, who had been quiet up until this point, took the matchbook out of Kayla's hand. "Let me."
"Help yourself." They watched her light the tree.
Sam focused in on the flames. "How'd you find out about this place?"
"I got a tip, from another hunter." Kayla replied with a smile, there was no reason she couldn't be nice to them in the short time they would know each other. "Looks like we happened to cross paths." She wiped her hand off on her jeans and extended it towards Dean. "Kayla."
He shook her hand. "Dean. This is my brother…"
"Sam?" She blurted out, instantly linking all the information from a pretty recent conversation she'd had.
Sam raised an eyebrow and shook her hand. "Yeah."
"Dean and Sam Winchester?"
Dean smiled, leaving out the humble. "That's us, we're probably pretty well known around the hunter community. You know, get around to all these…"
"Yeah or your dad talked about you a lot." She didn't let his ego get too inflated. "You look a lot like him, he didn't tell me you guys were like, super hot."
"You talked to our dad?" Sam was completely unphazed by the comment.
"I met him while I was investigating a ghost. He worked with me for a couple days, gave me what I needed to finish and took off."
"Sounds like dad."
"He was really nice, he's the one who gave me the tip to come here."
Sam glanced to his brother. "That's weird, he gave us the tip too."
"Maybe he thought you boys needed a little help." She smirked. "I'm starving, you guys want to find something to eat besides apple pie?"
"Hell yes." Dean answered with enthusiasm. He wondered why his dad would send another hunter on the same job as them. It definitely wasn't because he thought they needed help. Maybe he thought the girl needed help; he was a little old fashioned in some ways and never really liked the idea of women working solo in the field. Whatever the reason, he obviously wanted them to run into each other. He'd find out.