Disclaimer: I don't own Glee, but just think of all the beautiful gay parades there would be if I did.
A/N: One of my fans who wishes to remain anonymous asked me to write a graphic G!P one-shot for Glee. I decided to expand on the idea give though. So I'm out of my comfort zone still while writing futa so I guess practice makes perfect. Please bare with me. Anyway enjoy!
Rachel's P.O.V.
I slowly walk downstairs in confusion as I hear the doorbell ring repeatedly. Normally I would never even consider answering at this time of night with dad and daddy away, but the voice on the other side is unmistakable.
"Berry! If you don't open this goddamn door right now I swear to god I'm going to break it down!" Santana shouts from the other side as she starts banging on the door.
I quickly unlock and open the door before she has time to damage the wood. I'm shocked to see that Quinn is with her. "Santana, Quinn what can I help you lovely ladies with time as such an hour?" I ask politely as Santana shoves me out of the way of the door as she invites herself inside with Quinn close behind.
My relationship as of late with the two Cheerios have been surprisingly friendly. They finally accepted my offer of friendship as things have really been going well for the past few months.
"Is it true?" Quinn asks me softly as she stands beside me as I gently close the front door and again lock it.
"I'm sorry Quinn but I have no clue as to what you are referring too. Is what true exactly?" I hear Santana release a fierce growl as she paces my living room like a caged animal.
"Finnocence has been bragging to the whole football team about how you invited him over tomorrow to "hang out" while your dads are away. So basically he thinks you're going to finally let him pop your berry cherry. Are you?" Santana asks as she stops pacing momentarily to look at me.
I look between Santana and Quinn in confusion. Why does what I do concern them suddenly? "Santana if you are concerned I truly do appreciate it, but what Finn and I do does not concern you. Either of you." I add for emphasize.
"So after him cheating on you more times than even you can count and being a dick to you on a daily basis you're just going to give it up to him? What the hell did he do to deserve it?!" Quinn yells looking at me in disbelief.
"Well Finn and I do have our issues I still don't see what he and I possibly having sex has to do with the two of you." I say as I cross my arms over my chest.
"Are you serious Rachel? You know Finn doesn't even love you! He just wants to be able to say that he took your virginity and then walk away like he always does!" Quinn yells again as she advances towards me causing me to move back.
"Quinn, I can assure you that Finn would do no such thing. Even so I don't see how it would be any of your business. Please do not pretend like we are the best of friends Quinn." I say as I see Santana advancing as well.
"I'm willing to bet that we actually care about you more than the man child does. Besides it's not like he could hold out long enough for you to actually have sex. He'd probably only last long enough pop your cherry and that's about it." Santana says rather crudely.
"You two make it sound as though there is a list of people wanting to be with me! Anyway what he and I do does not concern either of you. I would like it if you two would please leave now." I say as I quickly walk over to the front door and unlock it.
Both Quinn and Santana are faster than I gave them credit for. Before I had the chance to open the door it's locked again and I'm being pinned to it by both Quinn and Santana.
"We're not going any damn where until you either talk to us or give us what we want instead." Santana whispers in my ear softly as she runs her hands along my stomach underneath my tank top which I'm starting to regret wearing slightly.
"I do not know what you are doing Santana, but I would appreciate it if you would stop." I say trying to keep my voice even as her hand starts to advance higher.
"You know we could make you feel way better than Finn could even imagine." Quinn whispers in my other ear as I feel her finger tease the waistband of my short shorts.
"While I would never question your skills in the bedroom I do not see how that is relevant at this point in time." I fight the urge to sigh as Quinn starts to move the tips of her fingers along my abs.
"Give us a chance to prove it to you. We have waited so long for a chance to show you how we feel." Santana says almost pleading as she strokes the back of her hand along my cheek.
"Girls, I am sorry but seeing as I am with Finn it would not be right for this to occur at the present time. I really do think you should both leave." It takes every ounce of strength I have in me to say that. I would love nothing more than to fall for the both of them but given their history it is probably too good to be true.
I hear both of them growl as they press their bodies into me pinning me more firmly against the door. "Besides Finn give us one good reason why we can't have you right here right now." Quinn growls in my ear as I feel myself getting wet.
"I…..I…because….." The ability to form a coherent sentence has completely left me.
"Sounds like she doesn't actually have a good reason Q. Even more reason why we should claim what is rightfully ours." Hearing Santana sound so possessive is actually turning me on more.
"All you have to do is tell us to stop and we will Rachel. We would never force you to do anything you weren't comfortable with." Quinn says softly as she slowly leans in to kiss me.
I try to find something to say, but I lose all conscious thought the second her lips connect with mine. I moan softly as I feel Santana gently running her nails up and down my stomach as her lips latch onto my neck.
Quinn reluctantly pulls away when breathing becomes an issue and latches onto the other side of my neck. I gasp as both of their hands move up my tank top and easily find my nipples.
"Girls," I sigh as I close my eyes and lean my head back against the door. I honestly can't decide if I want to stop or not.
"Rachel, baby we need you to decide. Do you want us to continue or stop?" Quinn sighs into my ear softly.
"If we continue we will show you more pleasure and satisfaction than Finn ever could. If we stop we'll leave you alone and pretend that this never happened." Santana says as she rests her head on my shoulder as she continues to play with my breast.
"Before you make your decision we have decided that there's something you should know." Quinn says as she and Santana each grab one of my hands and places them over their crotches.
"Oh my god," I moan as I feel something big and hard twitching against my hands.
"We're both so hard for you Rachel. If you were doing this with Finn he would have blow his load by now and left you all wet and unsatisfied." Santana growls softly in my ear as she removed my hand from her crotch pinning it against the door again.
"Are you wet right now Rachel?" Quinn asks as she starts to push my tank top higher.
"Dripping," I groan as they both release my arms long enough to get rid of my tank top before pinning my hands to the door again.
"Are you wet because of us estrella?" Santana whispers in my ear as her hands slowly starts to travel down my stomach into my shorts.
I bite down on my lip hard as I feel Santana slip her hand into my shorts. I feel like my skin is on fire right now. She's so close yet so far away.
"Answer the question baby girl. Are you wet because of us?" Quinn growls in my ear as she watches Santana's hand disappear.
"Yes," I hiss as Santana easily finds my clit.
"Oh shit. Quinn we need to get her in bed and naked now. I can't resist much longer she's so wet." Santana groans as she reluctantly removes her hand from my shorts.
"Is that want you want Rachel?" Quinn asks softly as she looks at me hoping that I haven't changed my mind.
All I can do is nod silently as I feel myself being picked up bridal style and carried off into my room. I can't even comprehend who's carrying me, my mind is too clouded by lust to really care at this point in time.
Before I know it we're in my room and I'm being set down on my bed gently. "Lay back for us estrella." Santana says softly as I feel her grab only my shorts but my underwear too and begin to pull them off.
I quickly follow her instructions as I watch her throw my clothes off to the side. I moan softly as they each place one of their hands on my knee and spreads them apart slowly.
I hear them both groan as I lay fully exposed to both of them. "Dear god she's so wet." Quinn groans as I feel her starting to trail her hand down my thigh.
"I wonder if she's as tight as she looks." Santana groans as she too starts to trail her hand down my thigh.
"Will one of you please touch me already?" I groan as I begin to become impatient with their painfully slow pace.
"Somebody's eager," Santana chuckles softly as I look down and see her finger starting to circle my opening.
"I'm just tired of waiting for those orgasms you two said I would have." I hiss as Quinn starts to circle my clit gently.
I hiss louder as I watch Santana slowly insert one of her fingers. It feels so different than when I do it. "Oh god," Santana moans as she suddenly comes to a stop.
"Santana, why did you stop?" I groan as I try thrusting into her finger. I'm tired of them teasing me.
"Quinn she still has her hymen." Santana groans as I feel her push her finger deeper hitting my barrier.
"Oh shit. Rachel do you want us to stop?" Quinn asks as I hear Santana release a soft whimper in the background. I can tell by the look on both of their faces that neither of them want to stop.
"Keep going, but can you please be gentle?" I whisper softly as I watch them both nod slowly.
"Just relax for us baby girl." Quinn says softly as I feel her gently adds one of her fingers strengthening me slightly.
I sigh softly as I feel them both move to lie down on either side of me. I close my eyes as they gently start to work their fingers in and out making sure not to go too deep as they figure out a rhythm.
"Look at us estrella." Santana whispers in my ear softly as she combs her fingers through my hair. Slowly I open my eyes and am met with to of the most intense and lust filled gazes I've ever seen.
"We want you so badly Rachel, but we don't want to hurt you." Quinn says as she moves to rest her head on my shoulder. I hiss sharply as I feel both of them push deep enough to press against my barrier.
"If you want me so badly then take me." I say with a shaky voice as I spread my legs further apart to give them more room.
"We don't want you to regret this later because we most certainly won't." Santana says softly as she lays gently kisses along my neck and shoulder.
"Santana, you know how seriously I take having sex. If I wasn't sure I wouldn't be lying here waiting for both of you to take me." I groan as I reach down and start playing with my clit gently.
"But what about your plan to lose your virginity at 25?" Quinn asks and it warms my heart that I can hear true concern in her tone.
"Plans change Quinn. Now will you both please stop teasing me and fuck me already!" I groan as I start rubbing my clit faster and harder.
"Ay dios mio! You are truly going to be the death of us." Santana groans as she latches onto my neck leaving her mark.
"It would be very inconvenient if you died before giving me an orgasm." I say trying to be serious as I feel them both consistently hitting my barrier.
"Rachel, baby this is going to hurt." Quinn says softly as I watch her and Santana have a silent conversation.
"I know." I sigh as I mentally try to prepare myself for the unavoidable pain.
I yelp in a mixture of pain and surprise as they pull back before effective pushing through my barrier at the same time shredding my innocent. I can't help the few tears that escape because damn that hurt more than I thought it would.
"We're so sorry estrella." Santana whispers in my ear softly as she gently strokes her fingers along my cheek wiping away the tears.
All I can do is bit my lip and nod. I feel them gradually begin to sperd up as they focus on hitting a particular spot inside of me that has me seeing stars.
"Oh my god," I moan as I feel my orgasm beginning to build rapidly.
"It's okay baby girl. Cum for us." Quinn whispers in my ear as I feel the coil in my stomach snap as I cum hard.
Quinn and Santana continue to thrust inside of me until I've ridden out my orgasm. I hiss softly as I feel them pull out leaving me to feel empty.
I watch, in a silent post orgasmic haze, as both of them strip off the rest of their clothes. I feel myself starting to become anxious when they leave their underwear on.
"If I'm naked both of you have to be naked too that's the only way this really works." I say trying to lighten the mood. I can see them giving each other nervous glances. "What's wrong?" I ask.
"We just don't want you get freaked out and change your mind." Quinn says softly as she looks at me with an unsure expression.
"Feeling our dicks is one thing, but actually seeing them is completely different." Santana says also sounding unsure. I don't think I've ever heard either of sound unsure in the whole time I've known them.
"I promise I won't feel any differently about either of you. You both should know that I'm very open minded." I say hoping to reassure them. I watch as they both silently nod at each other before finally removing their last piece of clothing.
"Oh my god," I hear myself say before I have time to stop myself. I don't quite know what I was expecting, but both of them are very well endowed. Quinn was at least 10 inches, and while Santana was only about 8 what she lacked in length she made up for in girth. Don't get me wrong though, they are both quite thick.
"I think it's safe to say that we're both easily bigger than the man child." Santana says with her usual confidence as I watch her begin to stroke herself slowly. Quinn quickly follows her lead.
"Not even close." I say as I watch them transfixed. I can tell that it's going to be a tight fit for whoever takes me first because not even they can fit their whole hand around their shaft. This only makes me more aroused because I know I'll be feeling them for days.
"Santana did you bring the condoms?" Quinn ask quickly before lust us a chance to cloud her mind.
"I'm on the pill just in case." I say with a simple shrug as I watch both of their eyes bulge out of their heads.
"Are you sure Rachel? We don't mind wearing condoms if that's what you would prefer." Santana says groans as she strokes her cock faster.
"I want to be able to feel all of you without anything in the way." I moan softly. I watch as they both nod slowly with their mouths hanging open.
Ultimately it's Quinn who decides to place herself in-between my thighs. I groan as Santana climbs on the bed and settle on her knees in front of my face. I watch as she strokes herself a few more times before offering her deliciously hard cock to me.
I quickly wrap my lips around the head as I feel Quinn spread my legs further around so she has more room. "Are you ready Rachel?" She asks softly as I feel her run her cock through my folds a few times before she lines herself up with my entrance.
I feel Santana pull away causing me to groan softly. "Yes, Quinn I am ready. Please just try and go slow." I say as I sit up slightly so I can watch her enter me. I hiss in pain as she begins to force the head of her thick cock in my hole. I close my eyes and try to will away the pain as she slowly tries to feed me more.
"Oh god Rachel you're so fucking tight. I don't think I'll be able to fit if you don't relax some." Quinn groans as she tries to slowly enter my pussy.
"I'm sorry but you're bigger than I think I can handle for my first time. Please just go slowly." I hiss again as I look down and see that I barely even have two inches of her cock inside of me.
"Quinn pull out. I don't want you hurting her by accident." Santana says as she moves to stand beside Quinn.
Quinn immediately follows her instructions and I can't help but feel disappointed. I'm really hoping they don't decide to just leave.
I watch as Santana quickly slides off the bed and drops to her knees. Without pause she wraps her lips around the head of Quinn's cock. I feel my jaw drop as I watch Santana take Quinn deeper into her mouth.
"Rachel baby why don't you play with your nipples some while I play with your clit. We want you as wet as possible so I don't hurt you anymore." Quinn says softly as I feel her circling my clit again.
I quickly start playing with my nipples as a whole new wave of wetness starts to leak out of my pussy. I feel like I'm ready to try again after a few minutes.
"I think I'm ready to try again." I moan as I look over and see Santana deep throating Quinn's thick cock.
"Fuck! You look so sexy spread eagle waiting for Quinn's dick to split you in two." Santana says as she releases Quinn's cock and slides back onto the bed.
I never really thought I would be one for dirty talk, but it sounds so sexy and erotic coming from Santana. "Please," I moan as I pinch my nipples harder.
I bite my lip in anticipation as I feel Quinn lining herself up again. This time around the head of her cock goes in without too much resistance. I feel her gently force about half of her thick cock in causing me to bite my lip to hold back a soft scream. This feels way better than last time.
"It's taking all of my willpower to not just say fuck it and claim you the way I want too." Quinn groans as she continues her slow and gentle pace as she continues to feed me more of her cock.
I take a few deep breaths as I remove my hands from my nipples. "Take me Quinn. Fuck me like I know you want too." I hear Santana release as deep groan as she strokes her cock to match Quinn pace.
"We don't want her to hurt you baby." Santana moans.
"Quinn, either you take me right here and right now or I'll call Finn maybe Puck. I'm sure they'd be happy to do it." I watch Quinn's eyes darken.
I scream in pleasure as that seemed to have the desired effect. I hear Quinn growl as she finally bottoms out and doesn't waste any time setting a hard and brutal pace.
"You don't get to threaten us you slut. We all know that neither of them could fuck you the way we can." Quinn groans as she pulls almost all the way out before slamming back into me. "Oh fuck, Santana keep her mouth busy for me." My mind is too clouding by a beautiful mixture of pain and pleasure to register what's being said.
I feel the head of Santana's cock against my lips and without thinking I open my mouth. I never thought I would be so happy to not have a gag reflex. I feel Santana push until her cock hit the bad of my throat.
I decide to challenge myself by forcing my throat to relax so I could swallow the rest of her cock. "Shit!" Santana hisses as she looks down at me in shock.
I'm very glad I decided to research how to give a proper blowjob. I start bobbing my head as I moan around Santana's cock. I've heard stories about how giving a blowjob is very unpleasant, but I must admit I'm enjoying this. Having Santana at my mercy as she gently thrust into my mouth.
"You look beautiful sucking my cock. I bet this is what you were born to do. Oh fuck!" Santana moans as she delivers a particularly sharp thrust.
"Shit I can't wait until we get to fuck this tight slut in both her slutty holes. Would you like that Rachie? Would you like getting split open on both of our cocks?" Quinn growls as she starting hitting that same spot inside of me that had me seeing stars. I move my hand up to wrap around Santana's cock as I remove it from my mouth.
"Oh fuck! Quinn harder please I'm so close." I moan as I stroke Santana's cock as I release a loud scream.
"Fuck S her pussy is squeezing my dick so hard. I don't think I'll have the strength to pull out. Is that what you want slut? Do you want me to cum in your tight pussy?" Quinn asks as she starts pounding me even harder.
"God yes!" I scream as I nod my head enthusiastically before I take Santana all the way into the back of my throat. God this feels so amazing.
"Look at this Quinn, our little slut really loves our cocks. She has mine all the way in the back of her throat again." Santana says as she leans over to gain more leverage to start fucking my face.
"Oh god I can't hold on much longer. I need you to come for me." Quinn groans as she lifts my legs to place them on her shoulders. I feel her go impossibly deeper.
"Ah shit I'm coming. Fuck!" Santana hisses as I feel her starting to shoot thick ropes of cum into the back of my throat. I've heard stories about cum tasting horrible, but Santana surprisingly taste really sweet.
I swallow the last of Santana's cum as she removes herself from my mouth. I scream softly as I feel Quinn starting to rub my clit in tight circles.
"I want you to scream my name when I make you cum. Can you do that for me slut?" Quinn asks as I feel my vision starting to blur from my impending orgasm. All I can do is nod silently.
It only takes a few more deep thrusts before I Quinn shooting thick ropes into me as I scream her name as loud as I can as I feel the waves of my orgasm wash over me. I feel myself go limp as Quinn continues to shoot inside of me, filling me up in the most delicious way imaginable.
As I gradually come down from the most intense orgasm possibly in history. I feel Quinn and Santana gently maneuver us into a best position on my bed. I feel Quinn gently remove herself from inside me causing intense aftershocks to make my vision start to blur.
As I lie in the middle of my bed completely spent I can't help but replay the earlier events of tonight. I feel Quinn and Santana cuddle up on both sides me as I try to regulate my breathing.
"Just so you know we don't actually think you're a slut. We just kind of got caught up in the moment." Quinn says with a faint blush on her cheek.
"I know you don't, but I must admit I do rather enjoy dirty talk." I chuckle softly as I hear both of them groan. We continue to lie in silence for a little while longer as I think of what to say next.
"Would now be a good time to mention that I was inviting Finn over tomorrow to breakup with him?" I ask between gasps as I feel both of them wrap a possessive arm around my waist.
"Wait, seriously? Why?" Quinn asks in genuine curiosity as I fell Santana move her hand up to gently play with my left nipple. I feel myself starting to get wet again as Quinn's cum starts to slide out of my thoroughly fucked pussy. I don't think I can handle another round though.
"He and I don't match on a more physical level. I could never imagine giving my virginity to somebody who can barely kiss without orgasming." I sigh softly as Quinn matches Santana lead and starts to play with my other nipple. Why are these two still horny?!
"So if you're planning on ending things with the man child does that mean you'll be our girl?" Santana asks as I feel her hand abandon my nipple as it slowly starts to travel further south.
"That entirely depends," I groan as I reluctantly place my hands over both of theirs stopping them.
"On what exactly?" Quinn asks as she keeps her eyes focused on my strained nipples. Clearly she's thinking with her other head at the moment.
"What will change if I agree to be your girl as you say? Does this mean we'll be dating or am I just something both of you will use when you're horny?" I ask with a bit more bite than necessary.
"Rachel," Santana sighs as she slips her hand from underneath mine and wraps it around my waist pulling me close. Quinn also moves over as well so I'm meshed between the two. "We're both hoping that this isn't a one time thing, but we both want the whole Rachel Barbra Berry package deal. We want to take you on dates, and hold your hand as we walk down the hallway." Santana sighs softly.
"We want to spend Saturday's hanging out with you on your couch as you force us to watch Funny Girl for probably the thousandth time. We want to have petty fights with you that we all know you're going to win, but we're still going to try." Quinn says easily picking up where Santana left off.
"We want to walk you to class and be forced to carry your books. We want you to complain to us about how everybody in Glee is inferior to you to which I will, of course, tell you to shut up, but I promise to do it with a smile." I giggle softly as Santana's special twist on being nice.
"We've thought about this for a long time Rachel. We don't just want to have sex with you. We want to do all of it with you, for you." Quinn whispers softly finishing quite possibly the most heart melting speech I've ever heard.
"We've waited so long to tell you how we feel. I know we have a lot of making up to do, but we would love it if you would at least give us a chance to do it. We know without a doubt that we could make you happier than Finn ever could. All we ask is that you give us a chance. We know we kind of did this out of order, and we're sorry. We just couldn't allow Finn to have you before we lost our chance forever." Santana says softly as I feel her gently nuzzle my neck. I'm honestly surprised, I never knew Santana could sound so soft and gentle.
"I honestly don't know what to say right now. I'm sorry. Would it be okay if I took the night to think about everything?" I ask softly as I look between the two of them.
"Of course. Take all the time you need estrella we don't want to rush you." Santana says softly as she kisses my forehead and removes her arm from around my waist as she moves to stand up.
"Please don't leave. I don't want you to go." I say softly feeling extremely vulnerable right now, and after what happened tonight I kind of feel like I have the right to be.
"We don't want you to feel like we're trying to influence your decision baby girl." Quinn says softly as she too kisses my forehead and starts sliding off the bed.
I quickly grab her wrist before she can get too far. "I umm….I am feeling rather vulnerable right now and you two being close I believe will help." I say softly as I close my eyes afraid of their reaction.
After a few intense seconds I feel the bed behind me dip as I feel Santana lie back down. She quickly repositions me so I'm spooned tightly against her body. I open my eyes and see Quinn siding back in as well. She faces me as she lays the front of her body flush against my own. Both she and Santana possessively wrap their arms around my waist again and I start to feel better.
"Get some rest estrella. I'm sure you're tired." Santana says as she gently kisses my shoulder as she lies her head down.
"Don't worry we'll be here whenever you wake up baby girl." Quinn says as she gently kisses my forehead as she too lies her head down.
I nod slowly as I feel my exhaustion finally catch up with me. I fall asleep with the thought of the two women I'm sandwiched between running through my mind.
A/N 2: I know I need to work in being more graphic, but really I just wanted to see if I could write something like this. I enjoy a challenge and finding ways to expand my writing arsenal. I was thinking about doing another chapter or two because I now lack the ability to do a true one-shot. So tell me what y'all think.
