A/N: Fire plus Star VS Ice plus Star! Can you guess what this'll be about? Nalu VS Gracy! Who'll win when a Flame Dragon Slayer competes against a powerful Ice mage for one of FairyTail's most popular woman: Lucy Heartfilia! Hope you enjoy reading! Post a review naming who you want to win! Nalu or Gracy!

Chapter 1: Confrontation

Lucy's POV

"Lucy/Luce! I like you!" The moment I walked into Fairy Tail that one day, Natsu and Gray had simultaneously confessed to me in front of the entire guild.

"Back off flame-brain Lucy likes me. She would never want to be with a dense idiot like you who always destroys his surroundings!" Gray was furiously yelling at Natsu. I simply sighed as their daily brawl began.

"WHAT!?" Natsu was equally enraged at Gray and the two started head-butting like any other day. "What makes you think Luce would want to hand out with a stripper ice princess?!" Natsu was hissing in Gray's face and they started punching.

"Squinty eyes!"

"Droopy eyes!"

"Hot-headed brat!"

"Stripping bastard!"

"Stop it you two!" Yay! Erza's here to stop them!

"Aye!" I giggle at the sight of Natsu and Gray surrendering so easily.

"Mira! Can I have a strawberry-blueberry smoothie with whipped cream on top?" I yelled to the beautiful barmaid and she gave me a beaming grin.

"Sure thing Lucy. That'll be 200 jewel, here you go!"

"Thanks Mira." I smiled warmly and handed her the jewels, taking the drink. I was taking a sip when:

"Ne~ Lucy? If you had to choose, who would you pick? Natsu or Gray?" Mira's question startled me and I spit out the sip I was about to take.

"Mira!" She giggle innocently and handed me a napkin. After wiping my mouth, I started thinking about it.

Who WOULD I choose? Natsu was nice enough to bring me to Fairy Tail and it's cute how he's so protective of his nakama, but he's so dense. Gray is always protecting me and is pretty hot, but his stripping habit gets annoying sometimes.

"I actually don't know Mira. Natsu's too dense to take a hint and Gray is like the older brother I never had. I love both of them!" Mira frowned at my answer and I sweatdropped at her reaction.

"Lucy!~ That does NOT qualify as answer! Natsu and Gray, choose ONE? Who do you like the most?" Mira was leaning forward and was obviously anticipating my answer so she could tease me about this later in the future.

"Ummmm...I don't know..." I couldn't decide right there. I would need time to think hard.

"Of course you like me the most right Luce/Lucy?!" Natsu and Gray had stopped their fight to eavesdrop in my conversation with Mira.

"Wha-? Stop copying me you bastard! Don't follow my movements or copy my words!" I laughed at how cute the two looked whenever they got into their usual fights. They looked hilarious; Natsu and Gray's expressions were priceless! They were like monkeys copying each other!

"Pffft...BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA... hahahahhaha! Y-you guys look ridiculous!" I laughed and the two eased up a little.

"I challenge you Gray! Whoever wins Lucy's heart wins! Loser has to follow orders from the winner for a week! Bwahaha! I'll definitely beat you!" Natsu pointed at Gray who only smirked and shook hands with Natsu to seal the deal.

"You're on flame-brain! Lucy will pick me! The battle is ON!"

"WHAT? I never gave my consent on this matter!" I yelled in an attempt to stop the fire and ice mages' competition over me. I cringed backwards in the bar as they sat on the ground staring at me with puppy dog eyes. "Th-that's not fair! Ugh, fine! Go ahead and try to win my heart!"

"Yes! You're on Ice Princess/Flame-Brain!" Natsu and Gray sprang up off the floor and started their usual brawl again.

"Mira~ Levy-chan! Save me! Dasuke te Kudasai~! (A/N: Help Me~)" I turned to my best friend and the matchmaking barmaid.

"Hehehe! Lucy! Who would you choose: Natsu or Gray? Now you have no choice! Mwahaha!" Mira laughed evilly and started going into her dreamland. "Wai! Pink hair and brown eyes? Or blonde hair with dark blue eyes? Or black hair and brown eyes? Or blonde hair black eyes? KYAAAA! So cute~!"

"Ugh. Levy-chan!"

"Sorry Lu-chan, but I'm kind of trapped by my own dilemma." I looked over to her and see her sitting next to Gajeel. Gajeel had his arm slung over her shoulders and Jet and Droy were gaping at the sight. Mira was giggling creepily behind me and I instantly regretted turning around.

"Blue hair, red eyed babies! Also, black hair, hazel eyed babies! KYAAA!" Mira squealed and Levy and I face-palmed, sighing.

"Luce! Who are you going to take out first?" Natsu and Gray were looking at me with expectant eyes.

"Our competition will be 5 rounds. Two dates for each guy and the fifth will be a triple outing! The triple outing will be all three of us at once." Gray explained their agreed battle and I cringed.

"I have to choose who will be first?" I asked and they nodded. "Um, Levy choose one!"

"Um, go with Natsu first!" my best friend yelled over Jet and Droy's bickering.

"Got it." I turned my attention back to the duo. You heard her, Natsu will be the first date. Sorry Gray. Then you guys will alternate, got it? Natsu, meet me at this bar by 7:00 am tomorrow morning k?" I commanded them and Gray pouted. Natsu grinned and hugged me.

"Sweet, got it Lucy! 7:00 am!" I pushed Natsu off and he bragged to Gray. "See?! I'm first! Lucy likes me more! I'm going to win this thing! I'm fired up!"

"Shut up flame-brain! Just because you got to go first doesn't mean you'll win! Plus, can you even get up that early?! I bet 200 jewels that you'll be at least an hour late! New rule: if the date is more than 1 hour late, the opponent gets to take the date and the original partner will go next time!" Gray yelled in Natsu's face and smirked.

"Okay! You're on!" Natsu accepted it and I sighed.

"Ugh, boys. Well see you guys tomorrow. I'm going to head home now okay?"

"Bye Lu-chan! Good Luck!"

"Bye Levy-chan!" I waved and walked out. "Gate of the white doggy, I open thee. Nicholas!" I summoned Plue the second I reached the river. He accompanied me on my way home and I walked along the edge of the water, arms outstretched.

"Be careful Lucy-san!" some of the men out on the water in boats warned me like they always do everyday.

"I will!" I shouted back and hopped off the edge. I arrived at my apartment and ended up just jumping up to the window. I sent Plue back and opened the window. Natsu had rubbed off on me and I found it more exhilarating to enter through the window.

I closed the window, locked it and closed the blinds before throwing off my clothes. I grabbed my towel and a hairbrush. I went to take a shower and brushed my hair in the bathroom when I was done. I changed into my pajamas and went to drink some apple juice before going to sleep. I lay under my pink blanket and relaxed my body against my comforter. I gave into the darkness and allowed my consciousness to fall into a deep sleep.

A/N: That's the end of chapter 1! I apologize if the chapter is kind of short. The next chapter is pretty predictable, but I hope you enjoy this story. I'm starting to get a little lazy from writing fanfics, so I'm not 100% up on my game. I'm having more frequent writer's blocks and my ideas don't flow as smoothly. Sorry if anything I write is a little crummy. Review anyways and stay tuned for the next chapter! Also, read my StiCy: Light Meets Star and my LoLu collab with HiILikePie1937462: A Star's Reliable Lion! I also have a RoLu oneshot: A Shadow Comforting a Star and a LaLu coming soon! Follow HiILikePie1937462 and I for update notices on our Fairy Tail shippings!