Author's note: I DON'T OWN GLEE! This story is about Rachel, Puck, and Santanna. It will deal with polygamy and contain sexual situations and adult content so if you're uncomfortablt then please don't read. Everything in season 1 happened. This story takes place after 'Sexy' and will be A/U from there. Santanna is a full blown lesbian, Finn is with Quinn, and Brittany is with Artie. If you like this, then please review! Happy reading! :D
I strolled down the halls of Mckinley like I usually did, snarling at freshman, batting my eyes at people who started, and holding my head up high. I was still the number one bitch even though I wasn't popular anymore. There was still only one thing that was missing. I didn't hold hands with Brittany and I wasn't in my Cheerio's uniform. So much had changed over the past couple of weeks. I discovered I was a lesbian and madly in love with my best friend Brittany, my parents had let me get my own place, and I choose the glee club over Cheerios.
I knew why I did it, I was going anywhere Brittany was going, and she was following Quinn who was going for Finn. It was all a big circle and it made perfect sense to me, in the end I realized I did it for Brit.
I had been shot down by Brittany and that hurt. I had finally given up on her and let her go. That didn't make the pain any better though. I realized that if I had really loved her, I would let her be with who she chooses and that unfortunately wasn't me. Just because I was a bitch, didn't mean I didn't have feelings.
I continued my way down the hall when I was hit with an ice cold slushy by none other than Dave Karofsky. God he was an asshole, it was then that I made up my mind. I was going to re-join the Cheerios and become popular again. I don't deserve to have my heart broken and be treated like shit. I am going to make a comeback and be the HBIC yet again, but first I'm going to take a shower.
I went to my locker, grabbed a change of clothes, and unlocked the door to the girl's locker room. I still kept the key Coach Sylvester had given Quinn and I incase of emergencies. As I set my stuff down on a bench, I noticed a pair of clothes with grape slushy all over them. I immediately felt bad before I realized whose clothes they were, the animal sweater and short skit belonged to no other than Rachel Berry. So she had been shushed today too.
"Rachel" I called out into the locker room. Ever since Brittany had dumped me, I've become a little nicer to Rachel. She had been dumped by Finn yet again and I could relate to how she was feeling. There was no answer, so I made my way into the stalls and took a shower. I wrapped myself in a towel and was about to go blow dry my hair when I was stopped dead in my tracks.
There was Rachel. She was standing in front of a mirror completely topless in a pair a sexy pink lace boyshorts, curling her hair. I felt myself getting extremely wet, who the hell would have thought that Berry was that smoking under the grandma clothes? I hid behind a row of lockers and continued to check her out.
Her long brown hair looked silky smooth and fell down her back in soft waves. Her breasts were small, but full and perfect and her little brown nipples stood straight up. I trailed my eyes down lower and notice something shiny in her bellybutton, was that a belly ring? That's seriously fucking hot. I raked my eyes down her legs and fought the urge to slip my fingers in my panties, she was seriously hot. Like way hotter than Brittany and that was saying something cause Brittany had the best body in the school. I brought my eyes back up to look at her ass. It was perfectly round and I was dying to squeeze it and before I could stop myself I was walking over to her, rubbing my arms up her sides and kissing the back of her neck. She tasted like heaven.
"Santanna w-what are you doing?" she yelled pulling away and trying to cover herself. I laughed as a cute little pink blush spread out all over her face.
"Getting my mack on, what's it look like Berry?" I asked, pulling her hands away from her chest so I could see her breasts again.
She struggled, but after a while she gave in and let me kiss her chest. "Damn you're beautiful" I said sucking on her left nipple while playing with her right.
"S-santanna why are you d-doing this?" she moaned.
"Because I'm lonely Rachel and I know you are too" I said, stopping to look her in the eyes. "We can help each other out" I said. It didn't occur to me to ask her if she was into girls, so I continued to suck on her breasts.
I could tell by her little breathy moans and the way she fisted her hands through my wet hair that she was enjoying it.
"You like this baby?" I asked kissing my way up her neck, letting one of my hands drift down her toned stomach.
"Mm..yes" she said.
"We could work well together Rach, you know that?" I asked.
"N-no, you don't even like me" she said pulling away.
"That's where you're wrong Berry. I like you very very much" I said cupping her through her panties. "And I can tell by how wet you are that you like me to" I said kissing her full lips.
After a few seconds, I could feel her kissing me back and I felt something different. I had the best intention of sleeping with Rachel and then leaving and never speaking to her again, but something about the way she kissed pushed all those thoughts out of my head. Suddenly, it occurred to me that I could actually date Rachel. I could have the relationship I wanted with Brittany with Rachel. Sure she was loud, annoying, and self-centered, but she was also kind, caring, and a great listener.
"Hey Rach" I said as she nibbled on my bottom lip.
"Yeah" she answered out of breath.
"I meant it when I said, I really liked you. I wanted to see if maybe we could..um..ya know go out with each other?" I asked nervously. I would seriously be embarrassed if Rachel Berry turned me down.
"You want me to be your girlfriend?" she asked biting her lip.
"Well..yea" I said running my hands up and down her sides, her skin was soft as fuck.
"I-i don't know Santanna, I've never been with a girl before" she said.
"Oh, it's okay. I understand completely" I said letting her go. I was honestly kinda pissed now, we could have really been something special.
"That doesn't mean I'm not willing to try" she said cupping my face.
"Are you serious?" I asked with a smile.
"Yes, I'm serious. I've seen how much you've changes since you've joined glee, you've become a different person, and I like that person. You've even become my friend" she said kissing me again.
"You have no idea how much this means to me, Rach. I mean it, I'll be the best girlfriend to you, I swear. I'll be faithful and loyal, and I'll keep all the slushies away from you after I re-join the Cheerios. I promise" I said happily.
"You're gonna go back to the Cheerios?" she asked sadly.
"Yea, but not because I'm quitting glee. I really loved cheerleading Rach and I hated that Coach Sylvester made us choose, but I think she's cooled down and she might let me re-join. Besides, I've gotta hold some type of a reputation around here if I'm gonna protect you" I said kissing her head. Damn she was short, but then again I kinda liked that about her.
"Really?" she asked with tears in her eyes.
"Of course, no one's gonna mess with my girl" I said wiping her eyes. "You wanna get outta here?" I asked, suddenly wishing I hadn't, what if I was being too forward or moving too fast?
"But it's only first period" she said.
"Yea, but I kinda wanted to spend some time with my new girlfriend" I said kissing my way back down her neck, forgetting about my earlier thoughts.
"Where will we go?" she asked.
"My place" I answered, sucking on her nipples and slipping my hands in her panties.
"What about your parents?" she gasped as I ran my fingers up my her slit.
"They bought me an apartment last year" I whispered as she shuddered.
"T-that..mm..that was..god that fees good..that was nice of them" she moaned as I slipped two fingers inside of her, while I rubbed her clit with my thumb. Damn I'm good, I made Rachel Berry speechless.
"Yes, so now I'm all alone" I said gasping as she undid my towel. "No one will interrupt us" I moaned as she kissed her way across my chest.
"uh huh..god San..I've never felt like this before" she said biting my nipple. God this girl was trying to kill me.
"Wait, you're a virgin?" I asked her removing my fingers. I thought she had slept with that Jesse St. Douche last year.
"Yes" she answered breathlessly. "Why'd you stop?" she asked as she ran her hands over my ass and squeezed it.
"I will not take your virginity in a dirty locker room" I said. This was Rachel, she deserved to be wooed and loved, and have all types of romantic candles and stuff. Besides, we've only been going out for a few minutes and I was already trying to have sex with her. What was wrong with me?
"But I want you to" she whined biting on the back of my neck. That was all the reassurance I needed.
"Not here" I said grabbing my towel and wiping off my fingers. "Let's go back to my place and I'll show you how good it can really feel" I whispered in her ear.
"Okay" she said holding up her pink matching bra. "Buckle it for me?" she asked turning around.
"God you're hot" I said as I turned her around.
After we had gotten dressed, we snuck out to the parking lot and jumped in my car. I looked over at her and saw that she was sitting with her head down. I squeezed her hand, realizing that I hadn't let it go since we left the locker room.
"What's the matter Rach?" I asked pushing her hair behind her ear.
"I've never done anything like this before" she said looking up at me.
"I know" I said cupping her cheek and pressing my lips against hers.
"No, I mean. I've never fallen for anyone so fast" she said pulling away embarrassed. "Not even Finn".
She was falling for me? We hadn't even been out on a date yet. I knew I like Rachel a lot, but would I be able to love her? I looked up into her big chocolate brown eyes and knew the answer.
"Me either, baby. I don't know if it's because you're so fucking sexy or if it's because we're both desperate for someone else, but I really like you Rachel" I said pressing my forehead against hers and rubbing our noses together. "And I'm sorry for the way I treated you in the past".
"I like that" she said quietly looking my in the eyes.
"What?" I asked.
"When you call me baby. It's sweet and who knew Santanna Lopez could be sweet?" she asked giggling.
"Only with my girl" I said. "I've got a reputation to protect baby" I said wrapping my arms around her back. It felt really nice holding her. I could picture us spending a day out shopping, or going to the movies, or to the park, and then coming home and cuddling. I would do anything if it meant I got to hold her like this.
"Whatever you say sweetie" she said kissing my lips and leaning back in the seat. I cringed at the nickname.
When we got to my apartment, I took her bag for her and grabbed her hand and led her upstairs.
"This is where you live?" she asked looking around in shock.
"Yea, do you like it?" I asked nervously.
"It's amazing and so girly" she shrieked and wrapped her arms around me.
"I am a girl Rachel" I said pretending to be hurt.
"I'm well aware of that Santanna. I'm simply stating that I didn't expect you to have such a girly house" she said worriedly.
"I know baby, I just like to mess with you" I said kissing her delicious full lips.
She quickly returned the kiss and it turned into a passionate embrace with the two of us fighting for dominance.
"Can we go to your bedroom?" she gasped out when she pulled away.
"Absolutely" I answered, lifting her up by her butt so she could wrap her long legs around me.
I pressed her against the wall and rubbed my hands up and down her thighs.
"God I love your legs" I moaned into her hair.
"I love your ass" she giggled while she reached down to squeeze it.
"Two can play that game Berry" I said using my weight to hold her up, so I could lift her shirt over her head and kiss her chest.
"Mmm..Santanna" she moaned as I removed her bra and kissed her breasts.
"Yea baby" I answered. Hearing her moan my name did all types of stuff to my body.
"Can we go to the bed now?" she asked impatiently.
"Why in such a hurry?" I asked licking my way up her neck and behind her ear to inhale her sweet scent.
"Because I can't touch you like this" she whined.
I almost dropped her on the ground, did she have to be so sexy without trying?
"Let's go" I said carrying her to the bedroom and plopping her on the bed.
"Now what?" she asked giggling.
"Now I get you naked, wet, and moaning my name" I smirked while pulling down her pants and underwear at the same time.
Once I had us both naked, I looked her dead in the eyes.
"Are you sure you wanna do this baby? We don't have to, I want you to know that I'm not with you for sex. I want a relationship Rachel" I said seriously.
"Yes, I'm sure. What did you think you were going to do? Sleep with me and then ditch me? I am not a one night stand Lopez and I expect to be romanced" she said playfully.
"Baby, I'll romance you all you want" I said kissing my way down her body to her core.
"W-what are you doing?" she asked sitting up.
"Trust me baby, it'll feel good" I said kissing her thighs and spreading them apart.
"Okay I trust you" she said laying down.
With that I buried my face between her legs and plunged my tongue into her tight wet heat.
"God you taste amazing baby" I moaned replacing my tongue with my fingers, pumping them in and out slowly but forcefully.
"Oh..my..god..this feels amazing!" she moaned tangling her fingers in my hair.
"You like that baby" I said licking a long swipe up her slit.
"Santanna!" she screamed sitting up as I flicked my tongue over her clit.
"Fuck" she moaned.
"Who knew Rachel Berry swore in bed?" I asked, realizing that this was something that only I would get to know about her.
I continued to pump my fingers in and out of her while teasing her clit until she came with a loud scream. I popped my fingers in my mouth to clean them off and licked up her sweet come.
"That was amazing" she said smashing her lips against mine. "Your turn" she said rolling over and straddling my hips.
"Baby you don't have to, this is supposed to be all about you" I said moaning and she sucked my breasts.
"Nope, not gonna happen. You made me feel amazing, what kind of girlfriend would I be if I didn't return the favor" she said rubbing her middle finger over my clit.
"Jesus Christ Rach" I said.
"You'll have to tell me what feels good, I've never done this before" she said.
"Fuck, just keep doing that" I moaned.
"I like that I can make you feel good too" she said plunging two fingers inside me.
"Uh..god..are you sure you've never done this before" I asked.
"Only on myself" she groaned in my ear.
Images of Rachel sprawled out on her bed naked filled my head and I came in seconds.
"God that was amazing" I whispered pulling her onto my chest.
"I had no idea, it was like that" she said in a relaxed voice.
"Baby, there's so much more I can show you" I said kissing her forehead before she fell asleep.
The next day I woke up excited for school. I ran downstairs and made two cups of coffee for both me and Rach, jumped on the shower, put on my Cheerios uniform, and went to go pick up my girlfriend.
I walked up the steps to her door and knocked until a tall African American man opened the door.
"Hello, can I help you?" he asked.
"I'm Santanna Lopez" I said shaking his hand. "Is Rachel ready for school?" I asked.
"I'm sure she is come on in" he said opening he door.
"Daddy who's at the do-" she stopped suddenly when she noticed me. "Santanna, I had no idea you were coming" she said throwing her arms around me and kissing me on the lips.
"I came to give you a ride to school, I know you don't have a car" I said smiling as I hugged her.
A loud sound of someone clearing their throat brought us back to the real world.
"Oh! Daddy, this is Santanna, my girlfriend" she said hugging him.
"So you're the new person in my daughter's life. It's a pleasure to meet you, I didn't know you were a cheerleader" he said.
"I'm not, well not yet. I quit to be in the glee club, but I miss it a lot so I'm going to re-join" I said proudly.
"That's wonderful, well I must be going now. I've gotta get to work" he said disappearing out the door.
As soon as he was gone, I grabbed her around the waist and kissed her as hard as I could until the doorbell rang.
"Oh shoot, I forgot about Noah" she said trying to pull away.
"Why the fuck is Puck ringing your doorbell?" I asked refusing to let her go.
"He's usually my ride to school" she said.
"Oh, I had no idea. I mean I knew you and Puck were friends, but I didn't know you were that close" I said. There was so much I still didn't know about her.
"He's been having a hard time getting over Lauren since she turned him down and I think he really liked her. We've become closer since then" she said pecking me one last time before flouncing away to open the door and throw her arms around him.
"Hey babe" he said as he wrapped his arms around her.
"Good morning Noah" she said kissing him on the cheek.
"You ready to g-" he stopped when he saw me. "What're you doing here Lopez?" he asked, not letting go of Rachel.
"I'm here to take my girlfriend to school if that's okay with you" I snapped. I did not like how comfortable he was holding her like that.
"Wait, hold on, what?" he said backing up.
I walked over and wrapped my arm around her waist and kissed her temple. "You heard me, Rachel and I are dating" I said confidently.
"Are you serious?" he asked clenching his fists.
"Yea, we decided we were both tired of being lonely" I said rubbing the skin above her skirt, watching as he was getting jealous.
"Is this some kind of joke, Rachel?" he asked in a hurt voice.
"No, actually it's not. I care for Santanna and she cares about me so we decided to give it a try" she said looking me in the eyes.
I felt that tingling feeling again, the one I recognized was love. I loved Rachel Berry and I had only been with her for two days.
"S'true" I said. It was then that I noticed that same look in Puck's eyes. That same look of love, he loved her too and by the way she looked at him she loved him back.
"Why don't I go get you bag and we'll head out?" I asked stepping behind the door, feeling slightly uncomfortable.
"Rach why are you with her?" he asked, thinking that I was gone.
"I like her Noah, I already told you that" she said quietly.
"But I care about you and I know you care about me. Loose her and go out with me" he said.
"It doesn't work like that Noah" she said.
"Why not? We would be great together" he said begging.
"I can't leave behind someone I care about Noah. I won't do that to her, no matter how I feel about you" she said. "I'm sorry" she said with her head down.
"Me too. Just know that I'll be waiting and 'll wait as long as it takes, but I'll do it" he said kissing her head and leaving.
"You ready to go?" I asked grabbing her hand.
"Yea let's go before we're late and you know I don't condone tardiness" she said with a smile.
I saw right through that smile, she was hurting over Puck. I loved her, I knew she loved me, but she also loved him and there was no doubt in my mind that he didn't love her back.
We walked in the doors with our pinkies locked. People stared and whispered and were truly amazed. I stomped my way into Sylvester's office, dragging Rachel behind me.
"I want my spot back and I want it now. I'm sick of this glee club bullshit, you need me" I snapped.
"I couldn't agree more" Sue said. "Practice is at five, don't be late. Oh and Lopez?" she said as I was leaving.
"Yea" I answered.
"Good luck with Barbra as your girl, I hear you two are dominating the top of the school's gossip chart" she said.
"Thanks" I said.
I walked Rach to her first class, kissed her on the lips, and took off to find a certain someone.
"Puckerman" I yelled as I watched a mohawk turn the corner.
"The fuck do you want?" he asked looking like someone kicked his puppy.
"I know you love Rachel" I said softly.
"You don't know shit. Besides she's with you anyway so it doesn't matter" he said sadly.
"I love her too and I know she loves you back" I said.
"What're trying to do, make me feel like shit, cause you're doing a damn good job" he snapped.
"I have a proposition for you" I said. "One that'll make us all happy".
I knew this was a risky thing to suggest, but I wanted Rachel to be happy and if Puckerman made her happy then she would get him too.