What if when the girls meet Leo, Phoebe fell in love with him instead of
Piper? What if Piper had stayed with Dan? And what if Andy never died? Well
this how I see it.
Prue and Andy got married; they had a baby, Elizabeth. Prue died (the same way as on the show) three months after she had Elizabeth), she is now 2. Phoebe and Leo are married. Piper and Dan are married. This story takes place in present time. Paige is dating Glen.
Phoebe & Leo Piper & Dan Paige & Glen Prue(dead) & Andy = Elizabeth is 2 What If? Part 1
Manor
Piper and Dan are in the kitchen talking "Dan we can still adopt. Dan look at me please." "Are you sure there is no other way Piper, are you sure about what the doctor said" "Dan I wish there was but he said it would be almost impossible to conceive. I'm so sorry." Piper said as she finally broke down and put her head in her husband's arms. They had been trying to have a baby for about 6 months with no luck. "Piper it's not your fault, don't blame yourself Piper." Dan said as he looked into her eyes and he felt so bad for her, he knew that she want to have kids so badly, and for the doctor to say it was almost impossible was killing her. "I love you Piper so much." "I know." She said as she tried to pull her self together. "Phoebe and Leo are going to be here soon and I have to start dinner." "Paige is coming with Glen, and I think Andy might stop by with Elizabeth. She is getting so big." "I know. I can't believe she is already two. It seems like yesterday she was born." She loved her nice so much. " She looks so much like Prue." Just then Phoebe and Leo orb in while making out. "Gross get a room." Piper said trying not to laugh at her younger sister. "Oh be quiet, I remember when you and Dan use to be all over each other." Phoebe said with a smile. Then she looked at her older sister and noticed something was wrong. "Piper are you ok." Phoebe whispered to her oldest sister. Piper pulled her younger sister into the living room, Phoebe already knew about Piper and Dan's problem "What did the doctor say, is there something wrong." Phoebe asked with concern. "Well he gave us some bad news", she said trying to hold back the tears, "and he said that we probably couldn't have any kids." "Oh Piper I'm so sorry." "It's ok," she said as she put her head in her sisters arms, "I mean there are other ways right. Dan and me were talking about adopting, but I don't.I'm just not sure what to do. "Oh Piper sweetie, I am so sorry." Just then the doorbell rang. "I'll get that, why don't you go upstairs and wash your face, ok" "Phoebe, thank you." Andy was waiting outside with little Elizabeth, he sometimes hated coming to this place, there were so many memories of Prue here. But he knew Elizabeth needed her aunts, she has so many questions about her powers. "Hey Andy," she said she opened the door, "hey Elizabeth how's my favorite little nice." "Hi aunty Phoebe." She said with a big smile, and gave her aunt a big hug. "Hey phoebe." Andy said with a little smile on his face. "Dan and Leo are in the kitchen, I'll take Elizabeth and we can go see aunty Piper, huh Liz." "Can I daddy?" "Sure." Phoebe picked up Elizabeth. She was exactly like Prue. She wished her older sister were here to see her daughter grow up. Phoebe loved Elizabeth, and was happy that her and Leo were going to have there own little bundle of joy soon, she just didn't know how to tell Piper. As they were going up the stairs Piper was coming down. "Hey Elizabeth." She said as she picked her up." I missed you so much." "I missed you too. Aunty piper you look sad." "I'm am honey; me and uncle Dan have some bad news." Just then they heard Paige come in. "Hello. Hey Elizabeth, how are you baby." Paige says coming over to Piper and Elizabeth. "Hi aunty Paige." Elizabeth says running over towards Paige. "Hey Paige. Come on Elizabeth lets go fine some color books. Piper said as she took Elizabeth into the conservatory. Uh Paige I need to talk to you, please. They walked into the living room. "Paige, Piper is a little upset. She got some bad news from the doctor." "What is she sick? Is she ok?" "No she is fine; she got her fertility test back and they weren't good. She can't have kids." "Oh my gosh, but she was so happy she really wanted kids." "I know and that's why my news might be even harder on her." "What is it?" "I'm pregnant." "Oh my, Phoebe I'm so happy for you. Does Leo know?" "Yes, I was going to tell Piper, but she told me about her problem first. Paige what do I do? I feel so lost." Paige wasn't really sure what to say to her sister. "I think you just need to give Piper a couple of days before you tell her the news." "Tell me what?" Piper just came into the living room "Oh piper, well um. we uh. were talking about." Paige cuts her off "We were talking about throwing you and Dan a surprise anniversary party." "Yeah, well so much for the surprise, uh Paige." She said as she gave her sister a little nudge in the arm. "Yeah" "Ok what is going on that I should know about. Come on tell me, you can't hide forever." "Piper were not hiding anything from you what would give you that idea." "I don't know what you two are hiding from but I will find out. I'm watching you two." Piper leaves to the kitchen and Phoebe and Paige follow her. (Whispering) "Why did you have to bring me into this?" "Oh stop complaining."
Prue and Andy got married; they had a baby, Elizabeth. Prue died (the same way as on the show) three months after she had Elizabeth), she is now 2. Phoebe and Leo are married. Piper and Dan are married. This story takes place in present time. Paige is dating Glen.
Phoebe & Leo Piper & Dan Paige & Glen Prue(dead) & Andy = Elizabeth is 2 What If? Part 1
Manor
Piper and Dan are in the kitchen talking "Dan we can still adopt. Dan look at me please." "Are you sure there is no other way Piper, are you sure about what the doctor said" "Dan I wish there was but he said it would be almost impossible to conceive. I'm so sorry." Piper said as she finally broke down and put her head in her husband's arms. They had been trying to have a baby for about 6 months with no luck. "Piper it's not your fault, don't blame yourself Piper." Dan said as he looked into her eyes and he felt so bad for her, he knew that she want to have kids so badly, and for the doctor to say it was almost impossible was killing her. "I love you Piper so much." "I know." She said as she tried to pull her self together. "Phoebe and Leo are going to be here soon and I have to start dinner." "Paige is coming with Glen, and I think Andy might stop by with Elizabeth. She is getting so big." "I know. I can't believe she is already two. It seems like yesterday she was born." She loved her nice so much. " She looks so much like Prue." Just then Phoebe and Leo orb in while making out. "Gross get a room." Piper said trying not to laugh at her younger sister. "Oh be quiet, I remember when you and Dan use to be all over each other." Phoebe said with a smile. Then she looked at her older sister and noticed something was wrong. "Piper are you ok." Phoebe whispered to her oldest sister. Piper pulled her younger sister into the living room, Phoebe already knew about Piper and Dan's problem "What did the doctor say, is there something wrong." Phoebe asked with concern. "Well he gave us some bad news", she said trying to hold back the tears, "and he said that we probably couldn't have any kids." "Oh Piper I'm so sorry." "It's ok," she said as she put her head in her sisters arms, "I mean there are other ways right. Dan and me were talking about adopting, but I don't.I'm just not sure what to do. "Oh Piper sweetie, I am so sorry." Just then the doorbell rang. "I'll get that, why don't you go upstairs and wash your face, ok" "Phoebe, thank you." Andy was waiting outside with little Elizabeth, he sometimes hated coming to this place, there were so many memories of Prue here. But he knew Elizabeth needed her aunts, she has so many questions about her powers. "Hey Andy," she said she opened the door, "hey Elizabeth how's my favorite little nice." "Hi aunty Phoebe." She said with a big smile, and gave her aunt a big hug. "Hey phoebe." Andy said with a little smile on his face. "Dan and Leo are in the kitchen, I'll take Elizabeth and we can go see aunty Piper, huh Liz." "Can I daddy?" "Sure." Phoebe picked up Elizabeth. She was exactly like Prue. She wished her older sister were here to see her daughter grow up. Phoebe loved Elizabeth, and was happy that her and Leo were going to have there own little bundle of joy soon, she just didn't know how to tell Piper. As they were going up the stairs Piper was coming down. "Hey Elizabeth." She said as she picked her up." I missed you so much." "I missed you too. Aunty piper you look sad." "I'm am honey; me and uncle Dan have some bad news." Just then they heard Paige come in. "Hello. Hey Elizabeth, how are you baby." Paige says coming over to Piper and Elizabeth. "Hi aunty Paige." Elizabeth says running over towards Paige. "Hey Paige. Come on Elizabeth lets go fine some color books. Piper said as she took Elizabeth into the conservatory. Uh Paige I need to talk to you, please. They walked into the living room. "Paige, Piper is a little upset. She got some bad news from the doctor." "What is she sick? Is she ok?" "No she is fine; she got her fertility test back and they weren't good. She can't have kids." "Oh my gosh, but she was so happy she really wanted kids." "I know and that's why my news might be even harder on her." "What is it?" "I'm pregnant." "Oh my, Phoebe I'm so happy for you. Does Leo know?" "Yes, I was going to tell Piper, but she told me about her problem first. Paige what do I do? I feel so lost." Paige wasn't really sure what to say to her sister. "I think you just need to give Piper a couple of days before you tell her the news." "Tell me what?" Piper just came into the living room "Oh piper, well um. we uh. were talking about." Paige cuts her off "We were talking about throwing you and Dan a surprise anniversary party." "Yeah, well so much for the surprise, uh Paige." She said as she gave her sister a little nudge in the arm. "Yeah" "Ok what is going on that I should know about. Come on tell me, you can't hide forever." "Piper were not hiding anything from you what would give you that idea." "I don't know what you two are hiding from but I will find out. I'm watching you two." Piper leaves to the kitchen and Phoebe and Paige follow her. (Whispering) "Why did you have to bring me into this?" "Oh stop complaining."