Author's Note: This is a totally new experience for me. I watched Rumours again and thought about it a little bit and came up with this idea.

Disclaimer: If I owned Glee, I wouldn't be writing this story.

Summary: What if Finn and Rachel had told Blaine what they saw at the motel? Before finding out the truth.

Finn stared in shock at the scene that was before him. He could barely utter a word. He chanced a glance at Rachel and saw that she wasn't much better. It didn't just make sense. He blinked, hoping that it would right the scene. No, Kurt was still standing on the motel porch with Sam. They were talking quietly, Sam was nodding to whatever Kurt was saying.

After a few minutes, Kurt turned and started for his car. Finn blanched and ducked, hoping that they wouldn't be seen. Luck seemed to be on their side because he never glanced the truck's way.

"Hey Rachel, do you still have Blaine's number?" Finn asked, turning to his passenger. She nodded once and fished her phone out of her pocket.

"Why?"

"I think he deserves to know about this."

She was already typing out a text message while he spoke. She finished about a moment later. "I told him to meet us tomorrow at the Lima Bean. This isn't something that you can say over the phone."

"Yeah, that's probably a good idea." He started up the truck. He figured they were far enough behind Kurt that their wouldn't be any suspicion.

Dropping Rachel at her house didn't take anymore than 10 minutes. He sighed, cranking up the radio on the drive to his house. He had no idea how he was going to face Kurt after what he saw tonight.

Luckily, that wasn't a problem. Kurt didn't leave his room all night. That surprised Finn somewhat but it was good. Now there wouldn't be a shouting match.

School the next day was a mess. He could barely look Kurt in the eye and tried his hardest not to glare at Sam. Glee made it slightly better but the songs were mediocre and focus was impossible.

It was about 3:45 when he pulled into the Lima Bean parking lot. They were supposed to meet Blaine at 4.

"Are you sure this is a good idea Finn?" Rachel asked. She was sitting beside him with a half-worried look on her face.

"Yes. Blaine deserves to know the truth." He pulled off his seatbelt and opened the door. He heard the other one slam shut.

They picked a table in the back that wouldn't be easily seen from the doors. Rachel was waiting at the counter for their coffee and Blaine. Just in case Kurt would happen to come.

Sooner than expected, Blaine and Rachel were walking to their table. Blaine had a bemused look on his face. Like he wasn't exactly sure what to make of the two of them. Finn tried for a smile but ended up grimacing instead.

"Please sit down Blaine. Finn and I have some difficult news to share with you." Rachel said somberly taking the seat next to him.

Blaine looked even more confused but did as she asked and took the seat across from them. "So why did you want me to meet you here? Why couldn't I tell Kurt about this?"

Rachel looked at him to explain. He sighed but nodded.

"Kurt's cheating on you Blaine. We caught him at a motel room with Sam, and Sam was wearing Kurt's jacket to school today."

Shock, pain, surprise and finally anger crossed Blaine's face. He stood up and walked out the door without a backwards glance.

Rachel and Finn looked at each other, asking the same silent question. Did we do the right thing?

Unfortunately, they didn't and sometimes you should just keep your mouth shut.