Hey guys so this is a new story that I've started. It will be in chapters. I hope you enjoy this story and the beginning is a little messy but I will try to explain it to the best of my abilities. Caroline and Elena are sisters and vampires. Caroline is drawn to Stefan because of someone of her past. It will follow the season 1 story line specially the first few chapters. It is a role reversal story. If you have any questions feel free to ask. Hope you enjoy!
For over a century I've lived in secret; hiding in the shadows, alone in the world, until now. I am a vampire, and this is my story. I shouldn't have come home, I know the risk, but I had no choice. I have to know him. Caroline wrote in her diary knowing it was a mistake to come back to her home but knew it was worth because she would find out the truth of who Stefan was. From the first time she saw him when she saved him from drowning. It's been over a century since she saw that face, she just needed to make sure it wasn't him, before she comes to town.
Dear Diary
Today will be different, it had to be. I will smile, and it will be believable. My smile will say "I'm fine thank you. I feel so much better" I will no longer be the sad little boy who lost his parents. I will start fresh, be someone new. It's the only way I'll make it through. Stefan wrote in his diary knowing that writing down his thoughts will make him feel better. He hasn't been the same since that night. The night his parents died, and he survived. The only reason they'd been out there was to pick him up. Nobody could explain how he survived, he should've died with his parents, but he was pulled out of the car.
Stefan realized the time and got up from his desk and went to change clothes. It was the first day of school and he didn't know if he was ready to go back, but it was the only way to be normal again. He had grieved the whole summer not knowing how he would go on without them. The only good thing he had in his life was his brother Damon. He kept it together that whole summer for Stefan. Damon was there for Stefan during the whole grieving process, he showed no weakness for him. He could never repay Damon for what he did. He got ready for school and headed out into his red Porsche.
When he got to school he saw Matt, Tyler and Bonnie talking by their locker, so he headed their way.
"Hey guys." Stefan said approaching his friends. All his friends looked at him with happiness and sadness in their eyes. They knew he's had a rough summer, but they where all there for him.
"Hey man. How are you doing?" Matt said waiving hi at Stefan.
"I'm good, really I'm fine." Stefan said wanting to sound convincing. When the bell sounded they headed to their class passing by the office. Tyler, Matt and Stefan walked to their class when they passed the office they saw a blond tall girl wearing a black leather jacker and white blouse with black skinny jeans and black boots talking to the receptionist.
"Hold up. Who is this?" Tyler asked.
"All I see is back." Stefan said looking at the girl.
"It's a hot back and a nice ass" Tyler said smirking at the guys. Tyler and Matt left to their classes leaving Stefan looking at the girl, after a while he went to his locker to grab a few things before heading to class.
"Your records are incomplete. You're missing immunization records, we do insist on transcripts." The secretary said.
"Look again. I'm sure everything you need is there" The Caroline said looking at secretary, pupils dilating.
"Well you're right. So, it is." The secretary said, handing Caroline her schedule and locker number. As soon as Caroline was handed her things she left the office. She went to her first class. As she walked down the hall to get to her class she accidentally bumped into someone, it was Stefan.
"I'm sorry I wasn't looking where I was going." Stefan said looking at the blond.
"I's okay. It was my fault." Caroline said smiling at the boy.
"I'm Stefan by the way." Stefan said taking his hand out.
"Caroline Forbes." Caroline said shaking Stefan hand.
"I should get to class." Caroline said breaking eye contact.
"Right. I guess I'll see you around." Stefan said as Caroline left for class. Stefan went to his class thinking about Caroline.
When Caroline left Stefan, she couldn't stop thinking about him. He reminded her so much of Samuel, but it wasn't him she knew that. She wanted to find out why he looked exactly like him. It's been so long since she had felt this way, but it could only last for a while. Caroline made it to her class, and she saw Bonnie sitting there. During the summer she had observed Stefan making sure he wasn't Samuel and she saw Bonnie with him, if there was a way in with Stefan it was Bonnie. She also wanted to know if she was a witch like her ancestors, since her last name was Bennet. When entering the class, she sat close to Bonnie.
"Hey, you're the new girl, right?" Bonnie asked Caroline.
"Yea, I'm Caroline. Caroline Forbes." Caroline said smiling at Bonnie.
"I'm Bonnie Bennet, nice to meet you." Bonnie said smiling. "Would you like to go out tonight? My friends and I are going to the grill, that's where everyone hangs out plus I'll get to introduce you to everybody."
"Sure, sounds like fun." Caroline said smiling at Bonnie. She couldn't believe that it was so easy to make friends with Bonnie.
"Great, do you want me to give you a ride?" Bonnie asked
"How about I give you a ride?" Caroline asked Bonnie
"Sure, I'll give you my phone number and text you my address." Bonnie said writing her number on a piece of paper and handing it to Caroline.
"Okay, I'll pick you up around 7?" Caroline said to Bonnie.
"Yea that'll work." Bonnie said back, Caroline just smiled back to her. As first period started her and Bonnie where texting, since class was boring. Bonnie was asking her questions about her life.
Bonnie: So where did you grow up?
Caroline: I was born here but I moved, and I've travelled a lot with my sister.
Bonnie: You have a sister? Where is she?
Caroline: Yup, she is not here with me she's 2 years older and I don't really know where she is. She travels a lot and where not that close. We used to be but not anymore.
Bonnie: And with you and your sister, well that too bad. What happened between the two of you?
Caroline: We meet a boy and we both fell in love. It caused a rift between us and ever since then we aren't the same.
Bonnie: Oh well I hope you and your sister's relationship get's better.
Caroline: Thank you, I hope so too.
Bonnie and Caroline decided to spend the last 20 minutes of class to pay attention. As soon as class ended they headed to their next class which was history. They headed their way to their class, and as soon as they walked in Caroline saw Stefan sitting there. She just smiled when they made eye contact and he smiled back. During the class period Caroline would turn back to where Stefan was sitting and smile at him. All he could think about was her, he didn't know why but there was something about her that he was drawn to. She knew it was a mistake to fall for him specially given the history with the man wearing his face and her sister. After school ended she went home to change and get a few things done before she went to pick up Bonnie.
It finally struck seven o'clock, so she decided to go pick up Bonnie. She got to her house rather quickly, when she got to her house she texted Bonnie that she was there already. Within 5 minutes of texting her, Bonnie was outside and getting into Caroline's car. As they drove to the Grill Bonnie was telling Caroline about her friends.
"So, first there's Tyler, he's a total ass, but we've been friends since we were little, so we are kind off used to it. Then there's Matt, he's the best friend you could have. He lives with his mom and sister, even though his mom is almost never around so he has to work to pay everything, but he has a good heart. Then there's Lexi, she the best girlfriend ever. She's so fun to be around, you'll like her. Lastly there's Stefan, his parents died last summer so he's been going through a lot, but he has a lot of people in his corner that care about him." Bonnie said
"Good to know and I know the pain of loosing your parents. When I lost my mom and dad it was the worst pain I've ever felt but I got through it. I'm sure he'll heal soon." Caroline said smiling. When they got to the Grill Bonnie saw her friends by the pool table, so they headed over to them.
"Hey guys. I wanted to introduce you to Caroline Forbes, she just moved here." Bonnie spoke up to her friends.
"Well I'm Lexi, it's so nice too meet you. This is Tyler, Matt and that broody one over there is Stefan." Lexi said smiling at Caroline.
"Wait Forbes, as in Sheriff Forbes?" Tyler asked
"Yea she's my aunt, I'm staying with her." Caroline said.
"I want to play pool, anybody in?" Lexi said. Everyone answered except Caroline and Stefan.
"I stay here. Not feeling like playing right now." Caroline said.
"Yea me too." Stefan said looking at his friends then at Caroline. The group just nodded and went to play. Stefan and Caroline just sat there for a couple of minutes until Caroline spoke up.
"So, what's the deal with this bonfire thing tomorrow night?" Caroline asked breaking the silence.
"It's a beginning of the school year tradition thing. Basically, it's just a bunch of teenagers drinking around a big fire, it's fun thought the whole school goes." Stefan said to Caroline looking at her.
"Are you going?" Caroline asked Stefan with a smile.
"I might. Are you?" Stefan smiled his tone very flirty.
"I might." Caroline responded smiling at him.
Bonfire
When Stefan arrived at the bonfire he looked for Caroline. He wasn't sure if she was going but after them talking the night before he thought she might show up. He skimmed through the crowd and was finally able to spot her, he made his way over to her.
"Hey stranger" Stefan said
"Hey. I thought you weren't coming." Caroline said
"To be correct I said might." Stefan spoke up
"True. Do you want to go grab something to drink?" Caroline asked pointing to the keg.
"Sure. Lead the way." Stefan said letting Caroline walk first, following Caroline. They grabbed their drinks and started walking around the woods.
"I've missed this town. It's been forever since I came here." Caroline said smiling and feeling the breeze.
"You've lived here?" Stefan asked not knowing she had lived here before.
"Yea, I was born here, but moved away." Caroline said. Stefan looked at her and all he could do was smile, he saw her fidgeting with the ring she had on her hand.
"I like your ring, where you'd get it?" Stefan asked looking at her hand.
"Family heirloom." Caroline responded. They kept walking until finally stopping at the fall.
"There so beautiful at night" Caroline said looking at Stefan and the falls. Caroline didn't know if It was just her or if it was happening, she and Stefan where getting closer, their lips about to touch when they heard a scream coming from the wood. They quickly ran over to where everyone was standing. They saw Matt carrying a girl who had a bite on her neck.
"Oh my god, that's Matt's sister Vickie." Caroline saw the bite on her neck and knew who did this to her. It was her sister, the person she thought she left a long time ago. Caroline left the bonfire and went home. When she arrived she quickly went upstairs to her room knowing that she was already waiting for her there.
"Hello, Sister"
"Elena"