This story takes place after New York (2x22) during Christmas except Sam and Mercedes never went out.
Quinn POV
"I don't think this'll work Santana" I said.
"It will. Once he kisses you he'll realize he still loves you. Now stand under the mistletoe and I'll direct Sam to you" Santana commanded. I walked over under the mistletoe and waited for Sam to walk in.
Sam POV
I walked into the glee room and Santana approached me.
"Quinn wants to talk to you"
"Why doesn't she come to talk to me herself?" I asked confused.
"Just go talk to her" She pushed me towards Quinn.
"Hey Quinn. Santana said you wanted to talk to me"
"Yeah I—"
"MISTELTOE!" Santana interrupted Quinn. I looked up to see we were standing under mistletoe.
"Kiss kiss kiss kiss!" Brittany shouted.
Quinn POV
I put my lips on Sam's and I ran my tongue across his bottom lip. He granted entry to his mouth and we started making out. Once he started to get excited he pulled away.
"That was some kiss" He said looking down, clearly embarrassed the whole glee club saw us making out.
"I love you" I blurted out. I covered my mouth. I did NOT just say that.
"You do?" He asked.
"Yeah. I miss you so much and I really really really want you back. I promise I won't cheat on you again. Please say you wanna be with me"
"You promise?" I asked.
"I promise"
"I missed you" He picked me up and spun me around.
**********************************Later*********************************
Sam POV
Quinn approached me and Puck.
"Can I have a condom Puck?" She asked.
"Yeah" Puck pulled a condom out of his pocket. Quinn took the condom and put it in her bra.
"My house after school Sam"
The end!