This story is an alternate reality which takes place after "If You Can't Take The Heat"...
The sound of the toilet flushing was subsequently followed by a sigh. She was definitely going to get a lecture from Heather once she got back. Why should she have to be yelled at when it was Owen who cost the team the challenge because of his incompetence? Like some dumb curse would have effected that. She kicked a rock in frustration which hit the stump of a tree and bounced back. Following this, she walked back to the cabin irritated.
A shadow cast behind her, a mysterious figure was following her. They had a knife gripped in one hand and their boot made impact with a fallen branch. This prompted the person to jump behind a series of bushes. "Who's there?", she called out, but upon not getting a response, believed that her mind was playing tricks on her. Just to be sure, she walked at a quickened pace, before tripping over what appeared to be a mask. "What was that doing there?", she said to herself.
Mustering the strength to get back up, she was pushed down and her glasses fell a few feet away. Once she got ahold of them, she looked up to see her attacker. This was the last time that Beth was able to open her eyes on Total Drama Island.
A shrill cry awoke the campers the next morning. It was Sadie, back from a trip to the lavatory, who stood, mouth agape pointing at Beth's body which had been perched next to a tree. She had been left clutching her stomach and her clothes were drenched with blood. Soon after this, the bubbly twin fainted.
"What the hell is this? Is it another one of Chris's sick jokes?" Courtney said, seething with anger.
Gwen was the one who had the guts to check for Beth's pulse. Her silence indicated that nothing more had to be said. Coming to a realization, Lindsay bawled while the rest of the contestants struggled not to make eye contact.
Close to the sight, Courtney noticed something peculiar sticking out of the ground. Wiping off the dirt with her sleeve, the rustic look that it had indicated that it had been used to carve wood. It was Duncan's knife, she thought. Looking around her, she noticed that he wasn't with the rest of the campers.
She quietly slipped away in order to look for him.
Dead: Beth.