Rachel is not "Rachel Barbra Berry" in this story, she is Racehl Barbra Karofsky. Weird I know. She went to Carmel High School and dated Jesse and Shelby is not her mom. She never went to McKinley but now she does. Puck and Finn and all those other Glee People are in Glee already. Rachel will try out soon. Quinn never gets pregnant. So... yeah!
-x-x-x-x-x-x-x-
Dave Karofsky walked into McKinley High School, dragging his little sister, Rachel, around. "Now Rachel, look, the guys here aren't like the guys at your old stupid Carmel High School. Most of the guys here just want sex. Like... Puckerman over there." He pointed to the mowhawked boy leaning against a locker flirting with a cheerio. He looked over and nodded in regonization."Then, there's guys like Finn there. He's only dated one girl, Quinn Fabray. You won't find anymore Jesse St. James' here." He told her. Rachel nodded.
"Don't talk about him, please." She said queitly. Dave nodded.
"Sorry, I know you miss him. He was nice and sweet." Dave said, not really caring. "I'm going to class." He said. Rachel rolled her eyes.
"Bye."Racehl said, walking to her new locker. She put all her binders she was going to use in it and touched her necklace. It was a gold star necklace that Jesse had gotten her. She jumped a bit as someone leaned against the locker next to her. She closed her locker and came face to face with Noah Puckerman.
Puck grinned and winked at her. "Hey." He said, looking her up and down. Smiling at the short skirt she was wearing, it was shorter then the cheerio skirts.
"Hi." Rachel said, looking at him. OK, he was pretty cute. But she still had feelings for Jesse and they never really broke up. She smiled slightly.
"I'm Noah Pukerman, everyone calls me Puck though." He winked at her. Rachel's smile grew a bit.
"Nice to meet you, Puck. I'm Rachel Karofsky." She said. He nodded.
"So, you're the missing Karofsky?" He said, amused.
"I guess." She said and lookd at him.
"Where have you been? He asked. "Something as hot as you not at my school.
"I went to Carmel High." She said. "I was in their Glee Club there." Puck smiled. They needed one last person to have all 12 members.
"I remember you, the lead female right?" He asked. Rachel nodded. He smiled again. "Thinking about joining the one here?" He asked again.
Rachel shrugged. "Maybe." Puck raised an eyebrow.
"But you'd be amazing, and we need one more member." He said, practically begging. She smiled.
"Then, yeah, I probably will." She said with a smile He smiled back and winked. "I better go." Rachel said, turning to walk away. Puck watched her walk away with a smile.
-x-x-x-x-x-x-x-x-x-x-
Rachel walked into the chior room after school, Puck had told her at lunch about that day's practice. She looked around and saw some faces from her classes that day. She smiled a bit and saw Puck who grinned at her. She smiled back at him. That's when Mr. Schuester walked in and saw her.
"Can I help you?" He asked, looking her up and down.
"Yes, I'd like to audition for the Glee Club." She said with a smile. Some people looked at her with shocked faces. No one ever just auditioned knowing what the Glee Club went through. And Rachel did know how they were. Dave had told her about them.
Mr. Schuester smiled. "Great. How about right now? Do you have a song?" He asked. She nodded.
"That would be perfect." She walked over to the musicians and whispered in their ears.
Mr. Schuester took a seat in the back next to Puck. He smiled and nodded as the music started.
"I'm just a girl.
You're just a boy.
This is my heart.
It's not a toy.
So what's with you playing with my mind?
We use to be cool.
This use to be love.
Now it's become
Something like a job.
Like it or not.
Baby don't pretend like you know me so well.
I tried to be a picture perfect girl.
But you were in your own fantasy world.
Trying to control me like some kind of Barbie.
But that just ain't me.
'Cause I ain't a doll.
This ain't a dollhouse.
You're way too old to be
Putting me down like this.
And playing around like this.
I ain't a doll.
This ain't a dollhouse.
No I could never be.
Stuck living life like this.
Behind these four walls.
I ain't a doll."
Puck grinned, her voice was amazing. She was amazing. He looked around to see shocked and happy faces.
"You called the shots.
Right down to my shoes.
I liked what you liked.
'Cause you told me to.
And I don't think that you could even tell.
I fell out of love.
But it never showed.
I gave up on us.
So long ago.
But you'll never know
Baby don't pretend like you know me so well.
I tried to be a picture perfect girl.
But you were in your own fantasy world.
Trying to control me like some kind of Barbie.
But that just ain't me.
I ain't a doll.
This ain't a dollhouse.
You're way to old to be.
Putting me down like this.
And playing around like this.
I ain't a doll.
This ain't a dollhouse.
No I could never be.
Stuck living life like this.
Behind these fours walls.
I ain't a doll.
I'll never be made of plastic.
So glad that my heart's elastic.
No matter what you do.
I'll bounce back off you.
Cut me but I'm not bleeding.
I tried to be a picture perfect girl
But you were in your own fantasy world.
Tyring to control me like some kind of Barbie.
But that just ain't me!
I ain't a doll.
This ain't a dollhouse.
You're way to old to be.
Putting me down like this.
And playing around like this.
I ain't a doll.
This ain't a dollhouse.
No I could never be.
Stuck living life like this.
Behind these fours walls.
I ain't a doll.
And I come with imperfections.
Epitome of perfection.
If you can't understand.
Loving the way I am.
Then your no good for me.
So glad I kept my receipt." She finished singing and Puck stood up clapping. Santana glared at her. Puck was her man. Even if Barbra Streistand here was a great singer and hot. Mr. Schuester also stood up with a smile.
"Wow, what did you say your name is?" He asked.
"Rachel Karofsky." She said with a smile. Some of the groups mouth dropped open. Karofsky's sister!
"Welcome Rachel!" He grinned. "We got our 12th member!" He said. Rachel grinned and smiled at them.