She was Sonny Monroe. And he was Chad Dyland, so that's why it simply could never be.
To her, he was perfect. She knew he was hiding oh so much underneath his mask. His real emotions and real thoughts were carefully tucked away where no one could see them. Only Sonny could see the pain in Chad Dylan Cooper's eyes when he was fake smiling.
But she was Sonny Monroe. So happy, random and nice so no one could see.
The perfect Sonny Monroe. She was pretty and random, but she was invisible. No one could see how great she was of an actress.
In fact, she was so great at it that she could conceal her eyes from almost everyone else.
It was Chad Dylan Cooper's fault. He knew how to read her like a book, even though she didn't see. He just continued the same act everyday so that he couldn't hurt her. To him, she was so very beautifully broken. Like sunshine that had hidden imperfections. He could see her pained eyes whenever he was flirting with another girl.
Yet they still loved each secretly. It hurt them so badly, yet they still acted like they were fine. They wished so badly to take off their masks and just tell each other.
But forever underneath cracked masks and paper hearts will they remain.