Love's Little Compromises
A/N: I'm sorry…..I'm not sorry. My hand slipped…Blame tumblr for this.
The room was unnaturally quiet. For once, Laura had the camera turned off. The internet did not need to see this. Danny leaned against the wall by the doorframe and Carmilla reclined on her bed. They both tried to look casual, but the tension in the room was palpable.
Laura took a deep breath before speaking. "So, first of all, I need to apologize to you Danny. I really shouldn't have said some of the things I did. I was really stressed out and I said some hurtful stuff. I know you were just trying to keep me safe." Laura bit her lip and waited for Danny to reply.
"It really did hurt, Laura." She crossed her arms and shifted uneasily. "I know I was maybe a little too…forceful, or demanding, but I wasn't trying to control you. I'm sorry if you felt that way."
Laura caught Carmilla rolling her eyes. "Hey, your turn," she said.
Carmilla frowned. "I'm sorry that I choked you," she said to Danny. To her credit, Carmilla actually managed keep from sounding sarcastic.
Danny sighed. "I'm sorry that I tackled you and then tied you up in a chair."
Carmilla smirked. "Under different circumstances Red, that could have been pleasant." Both Danny and Laura blushed.
Laura cleared her throat. "Which brings me to why you're both here." Both women turned to Laura, giving her their full attention. "I've been doing some thinking about the situation. I care for both of you deeply. Apparently, you two have some chemistry as well."
Both of them looked uncomfortable. "About that-" Danny began.
Carmilla interrupted. "Don't even try to deny it Red. If Laura had walked in seconds later you would have been bent over her desk."
Laura held up a hand to halt Danny's rebuttal. "So, I wanted to propose a solution." Laura glanced between the two of them. She did not know how well her proposal would be received. "We all share." Laura held her breath.
"Share?" Danny asked. "What do you mean share?"
Carmilla grinned. "Cupcake, I didn't think you had it in you."
"What? What does she mean?" Danny glanced between Laura and Carmilla.
"We would all date…each other," Laura clarified, her face growing hot.
"The three of us?" Danny asked, her voice a little higher pitched than normal. "Like…a threesome?"
"I am definitely okay with that," Carmilla said. "But I think what she means is kind of like a limited open relationship. Laura, you, and I would all be able to date each other; either one on one, or all together. Sharing. They did teach about sharing in your little Summer club, right Amazon?"
Danny's fingers clenched.
Laura stood up, moving between them. "Carmilla, if this is going to work, you two are going to have to get along."
Carmilla laughed. "Oh you don't get it cupcake. Part of the appeal Red has for me is that I piss her off. She wants to hate fuck me." She turned to grin at Danny. "Don't you?"
"Shut up," Danny muttered.
Carmilla simply smirked. "See?"
"So, are you both okay with this?" Laura asked.
Carmilla got off her bed and moved to Laura's side. "I'm on board." She took Laura's hand and toyed with it. "What's it going to be Red?"
Danny was quiet for a moment before moving to Laura's other side, taking her free hand. "The idea does appeal to me, I'm not certain if it really will work out in practice." She gave Laura a look. "But I'd like to try."
"Okay, good." Laura released a sigh as she relaxed.
"So what do you want to do now?" Carmilla asked. The suggestiveness in her voice made Laura tremble.
"Honestly, I hadn't thought that far. I assumed you two would be killing each other by now," Laura admitted.
Carmilla traced her fingers lightly up Laura's forearm. "Well Red, I think we can cooperate for a bit, don't you?"
Danny's brow furrowed before she caught on. "I think that would be okay, if it's okay with Laura?" She cupped Laura's cheek.
"If what's okay with Laura?" Laura asked. She was having trouble focusing with both of them touching her.
"I believe I heard someone mention a threesome?" Danny murmured.
Realization finally hit Laura. "Now? But we haven't talked!"
"I thought that's what we just did?" Carmilla replied.
"I mean about boundaries…and, and rules!" Danny was behind her now, kissing the side her neck. Carmilla's hands brushed along her sides.
"Carmilla, are there any rules I need to know about?" Danny asked. Laura felt the redhead nip gently at her neck.
"Nope. You?" Carmilla leaned forward, kissing along the side of Laura's neck that Danny was currently occupying.
Danny met Carmilla's eyes. "Don't feed from me."
The vampire shrugged. "Fair enough." Carmilla met Danny's mouth somewhere along Laura's throat and they kissed, Laura still between them. Laura could barely believe what was happening. She thought that she might faint. They broke the kiss and Carmilla turned to Laura.
"What about you Cupcake? Got any rules I need to know about?" The words were nearly a purr. Laura's legs felt like they might give out at any second.
"Um, uh…Safe word! The safe word is 'red light.' We need one of those, right?"
Carmilla smiled slowly, and then her mouth was on Laura's kissing her fiercely. Laura moaned into her mouth, her hands finally coaxed into movement. One reached up to cup Danny's face, the other circling around Carmilla's waist, pulling them flush.
Carmilla broke the kiss and her fingers found the buttons on Laura's shirt, quickly undoing them. Danny took a step back, pulling the shirt over Laura's shoulders and letting it fall to the floor. Danny undid Laura's bra and Carmilla tossed it into the corner of the room. Danny took the opportunity to turn Laura around, kissing her hard. Laura's hands found Danny's shirt and she pulled it up, taking her sports bra with it. Laura felt Carmilla's warm body press against her back. She must have taken her shirt off. The thought flickered through her mind and shattered when Carmilla's hands slowly traveled over Laura's hips and rubbed between her thighs. She gasped, breaking the kiss and arching into Danny.
"I think you had a brilliant idea Cupcake," Carmilla whispered into her ear.
"I think you two are going to kill me," Laura rasped. Danny's hands moved to the buttons on Laura's jeans. She hesitated and glanced at Laura.
"Too fast?" Danny asked. Carmilla's hands stilled, waiting for an answer.
"Oh God, don't you dare stop. Either of you!" Laura cried. Danny smirked and she could hear Carmilla chuckle.
"I think we should take her over to the bed before she falls over," Danny said. Laura nodded vigorously.
"I think we're all wearing too many clothes." Carmilla trailed her hands over her body, down to her impossibly tight pants, and slowly stripped out of them. Laura could only stare. She was surprised to hear a soft whimper from Danny.
"Laura, it looks like she needs help out of her jeans." Carmilla nodded at Danny. With shaking hands and a nervous smile, Laura helped Danny remove the last of her clothing. For a moment, Laura stood there and took in the sight of both of the beautiful naked women in front of her.
She glanced at the bed, trying to think of how three of them were going to fit on a twin bed. Carmilla followed her gaze.
"Are we going to fight over who gets to touch her first?" Carmilla asked Danny.
Danny shook her head. "I take it you have something in mind?"
"Sit down, back against the headboard," Carmilla directed. Danny raised a brow but relaxed on Laura's bed. "Laura, sit in between her legs, facing me."
Danny's eyes darkened as Laura settled between her legs and leaned back against her chest. Danny's hands started to wander over Laura's body, pinching and rolling her nipples between her fingers.
"You're getting the idea." Carmilla moved in front of Laura, trailing her hand up the inside of her thigh. Laura tilted her head back, resting it on Danny's shoulder. Danny kissed along her neck, grazing her teeth across the skin. Laura moaned and arched into the touch. She was already more aroused than she had ever remembered being. Carmilla leaned down, kissing Laura's chest before brushing her fingers against her clit.
"Carm, God, stop teasing." Laura rolled her hips, desperately seeking more contact.
"So impatient," Carmilla chided. Danny continued teasing Laura's nipples, and kissing along her jawline. Carmilla smirked. "Danny, why don't you take over?" She placed her hand over Danny's and guided it downward to Laura's clit. Danny moaned softly.
"Fuck Laura, you're so wet." Danny began moving her fingers with long, sure strokes. Carmilla watched for a few moments, her eyes transfixed on the scene. Laura's gasp broke the spell and Carmilla moved her hand once again between Laura's legs, this time gently pressing inside her as Danny continued to stroke her clit. Laura groaned and gripped Carmilla's shoulders tightly.
"Danny, Carm, God…" Laura could no longer form words as Danny and Carmilla worked together. Finally the sensation of both of the touching her was simply too much. She bit down hard on Carmilla's shoulder to muffle the scream that threatened to escape as she reached her climax. Carmilla's free hand moved to Laura's hip, trying to hold here steady as she continued to thrust inside her. Gradually, Carmilla's hand slowed and Danny brushed a strand of hair off of Laura's forehead. Laura smiled lazily, looking first at Carmilla, then turned to see Danny.
"This is definitely turning out better than I had planned," she murmured. "But it isn't all about me. I want to touch both of you."
"Do you need a minute, Cupcake?" Carmilla asked.
Laura shook her head. "As long as I don't have to stand up."
"Lay down," Danny said softly. "There's something I want to try." Her face was deeply flushed, from arousal or embarrassment, Laura couldn't be sure. She disentangled herself from Danny and the redhead stood up to make room for Laura to lay down.
"Hey…um Carmilla?" Danny wouldn't meet the vampire's gaze. "Come here a sec." Carmilla stood up and moved over to Danny who whispered something in Carmilla's ear. Carmilla's face slowly spread into a smile that settled between delighted and mischievous.
"Oh, I think I'm going to enjoy this," she kissed Danny roughly, gripping her hair and pulling her towards the bed. Danny straddled Laura, then leaned forward until she was on all fours, bracing herself with her hands, her face inches away from Laura. Laura leaned up and kissed her fiercely. As much as she'd enjoyed the earlier attention, she was eager to give Danny some as well. Laura let her hands wander over the taller woman's body, exploring her curves. Suddenly Danny gasped and arched. Laura looked up to see Carmilla kneeling behind Danny with her hand slowly moving between Danny's legs.
"Tell Laura what you wanted me to do Danny," Carmilla said. Danny whimpered and bit her lip.
"I told her to touch me like this," Danny whispered.
"Like what?" Laura asked.
"From behind."
"That wasn't all you wanted, was it Danny?" Carmilla asked. Laura's hands found Danny's breasts and began caressing the sensitive skin.
"I told her to…" Danny gasped and moaned, as Laura brushed across her nipple.
"Finish your sentence," Carmilla commanded. Laura could feel a blush returning to her face. She had not realized she would enjoy watching Danny and Carmilla like this.
"I wanted her to spank me." Danny groaned and Laura could see Carmilla pressing inside Danny. Remembering what they had done earlier, Laura let her hand slide over Danny's body and began touching her clit. A few moments later Laura heard a resounding smack.
"Fuck," Danny gasped. "No harder than that, okay?" Danny half turned to meet Carmilla's eyes.
"Okay," Carmilla agreed. She began slowly thrusting inside Danny, occasionally bringing her hand down against her backside. The red head whimpered and moaned over Laura, who continued to stroke her. Laura could see Danny's arms trembling as she struggled to retain some measure of control.
"Admit it Danny, you like that I'm fucking you like this." She thrust in hard, moving the bed with each stroke. "You asked for me to fuck you like this." She smacked her ass again. "I want you to come all over Laura." That seemed to be what sent Danny over the edge. Laura could feel Danny's wetness covering her hand as Danny continued to rock her hips with Carmilla's thrusts. Carmilla didn't stop, she kept thrusting, Laura tried to match Carmilla's rhythm with her own hand, and a moment later Danny cried out as she came once again. Carmilla still did not stop moving. Concerned, Laura cupped Danny's cheek.
"Danny? Is this okay? You still want more?" Danny's eyes met hers and she nodded, beyond words at this point.
"Carm, hold on." Carmilla froze, and Danny whimpered in protest.
"Is she alright?"
"She's alright, but I'd like to touch her now since you just gave her two orgasms." Laura pointed out.
"You hear that Danny? You're going to get pounded by Laura. How does that feel? Shy little Laura is going to take you from behind."
Laura maneuvered herself out from under Danny and took Carmilla's place behind her. Laura didn't waste time with foreplay. She could see that Danny was still extremely worked up. She pressed her fingers inside Danny and moaned softly. It felt so good to finally be able to touch her like this. She could hardly wait to feel Carmilla… Suddenly, an idea struck her. Laura turned to Carmilla, who stood by the bed, watching as Laura slowly moved in and out of Danny.
"Carm, you haven't come yet have you?" she asked.
Carmilla looked up. "Not yet, no. Why?"
"If you sit in front of Danny, and she is down on her elbows she could um…put her mouth to work." Laura flushed. Carmilla's eyes darkened at her suggestion. She leaned down to Danny's ear.
"Would you like that? Do you want to taste me?" Carmilla asked.
"Yes," Danny breathed. Carmilla moved to the head of the bed and spread her legs. Danny lowered her head to Carmilla's body. Carmilla tilted her hips upward to give Danny better access. Meanwhile Laura watched as Danny licked and sucked Carmilla. She thrust harder into Danny, who rolled her hips against the motion. Carmilla moaned loudly.
"God, you're so much better when you don't talk," she murmured. Carmilla ran her fingers through Danny's hair, urging her on. Danny moaned against Carmilla, and let her hands slide under her thighs. Laura couldn't see what Danny was specifically doing, but watched as Carmilla's back bowed, and she cried out with pleasure.
"God whatever the fuck you're doing, don't stop." Carmilla panted. She bucked against Danny's mouth as the red head tried to hold her steady. Laura shifted her hand to get a better angle and increased the pace. She could hear Danny's whimpers, somewhat muffled by Carmilla's loud moans. Danny was close; Laura could feel it.
"Oh fuck," Carmilla groaned and her whole body went rigid. A second later, and Danny followed, coming again all over Laura's hand.
For a long moment, the room was only filled with panting as the three of them tried to regain their breath. Danny had her head resting on Carmilla's thigh, and Laura leaned against the wall, lightly running her hands over whatever parts of Danny and Carmilla she could reach.
Carmilla laughed softly. "For fucks sake Danny, what the hell was that thing with your tongue?"
Danny's grin was smug. "Maybe I'll teach it to you sometime." Danny turned to look at Laura. "We should have a conversation at some point about what we all want." She looked up at Carmilla, flushing. "I probably shouldn't have just sprung that on you."
"I will dominate you anytime, Red." Carmilla's grin was nearly predatory. "But we should talk about stuff, like how someone has some very interesting role play scenarios." She looked pointedly at Laura, who grinned.
"I can't believe that this might actually work. I was so worried," Laura said. With the heat of the moment dying, her whole body trembled with sudden exhaustion. Carmilla tapped Danny's head, motioning her to scoot over. The three of them adjusted until Laura was safely in the middle of both of her lovers.
"It's a little crowded, but I'd like to lay like this for a little bit, if that's alright?" Laura said.
"Maybe later we can push our beds together," Carmilla suggested.
Danny laughed. "Well that's going to be fun to explain to Perry and LaFontaine."
"Feng shui?" Laura offered.
Carmilla smiled and kissed Laura softly. "Get some rest Cupcake, between the two of us, you're going to need it."
Danny leaned in and kissed her as well. "I have lots of things I want to do, and try." She met Carmilla's eyes. "With both of you."
Carmilla winked and blew the red head a kiss "I look forward to it, Red."