Hello everyone! Now that All That Glitters is ending soon, here is a new idea I've been wanting to try out. Enjoy!

Plot: After having a one night stand, Rachel finds herself in a situation she never imagined: she's pregnant. The father? Her high school crush, Puck, who is as unprepared for a baby as she is. Now that their worlds have collided, they will not only have to iron out individual issues but also deal with tension that remains from their past together. All while preparing to be parents.

Chapter 1

The sunlight woke Rachel up and as soon as she tried to move, her head started pounding. She had never had a headache that was that bad and it was that moment that she remembered the events from the previous night. When she looked and saw a man next to her, her heart stopped.

"Please tell me I didn't," she whispered before looking under the covers and finding herself naked. "Crap I did."

When she looked closer at the man's face, her eyes widened when she realized it was Noah Puckerman. The guy she had been crazy about since high school who, before last night, she hadn't spoken to since graduation. She had to get out before he woke up and remembered it was her that he slept with.

Rachel carefully got out of bed and quickly got dressed before grabbing her shoes and purse and leaving. When she got outside, she took a sigh of relief before catching a cab back to her friend's apartment.

When she got there her friend, Santana, looked at her as she made breakfast. "Hey there you are. Never thought I'd see you taking the walk of shame."

"The what?" Rachel asked, setting her stuff down.

"You know, what women do after a slutty drunk night out," she smirked. "I'm just glad you're back early so I won't have to send out a search party for you. After your voicemail I got worried, which is fairly new for me."

Remembering the previous night, she frowned. "Brody said he didn't want to get married and that the wedding was off. He even asked me to return the ring to him."

"That bastard," Santana said, giving Rachel a cup of hot tea. "Knew I should've put hair removal in his shampoo when I was at your place."

"Well it's not my place anymore. He asked me to move out so now I guess I'm homeless."

The Latina rolled her eyes. "Don't be dramatic you know you can stay with me, besides you leave some of your stuff here anyway. I'll go by the apartment and get the rest of it so you won't have to see donkey face. You still have your key?"

Rachel nodded. "Yeah I remember him saying that I could keep it until I moved all my stuff out."

"How thoughtful. Still doesn't explain where you were the whole night though."

She sighed. "Okay please don't freak out. I kind of…slept with Puck."

Santana's jaw dropped. "Puck as in high school Puck? The guy you've been in love with since? He's in New York?"

"Yeah something about expanding his horizons but that's not important. I had sex with Noah Puckerman. How does something like that even happen to me?"

"Yeah got to say I'm surprised. Rachel Berry had a drunken hookup. Wow, I'm actually kind of proud right now."

She groaned. "Santana this isn't funny. I'm not the kind of person who does this."

"Relax, everyone has a random hookup or two that they have. It's nothing to be ashamed of, besides Puck has had tons so it's not like it's anything new to him. Just focus on one thing at a time. Get your hangover under control while I go and get your stuff. Hopefully the jackass is gone."

"Santana?" Rachel called before she walked out. "Thanks."

Santana gave a small smile. "What are friends for?"

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Puck woke up and stretched as he remembered the events from the previous night. He just went to the bar to get his mind off work for a little while and the next thing he knew he was in bed with Rachel Berry from high school. He remembered them both complaining about how crappy their lives were at the moment and how they kept downing drink after drink. Somehow, they ended up back at his place.

When he looked next to him and found the spot empty, Puck sighed. It's not surprising she ran off before he woke up. She was probably embarrassed which is what he remembered about her. One night stands were not something the girl he used to know was into.

Before he could get out of bed he heard someone hitting the buzzer into his apartment. He groaned before getting up and putting pants on.

"What?" he asked into the intercom.

"Good morning to you too," Finn laughed. "I'm guessing you forgot I was coming to get you out of your funk from your rough start at work?"

Puck cursed to himself. "Maybe." He heard Finn laugh as he buzzed him in. A minute later, he walked in. "What I didn't realize was that we were starting early."

"Well I figured the earlier the better. Plus my idea involved us getting away from the city."

"Fine with me. But give me a minute, I'm still recovering from my own pity party last night."

"Went to a bar?" Finn guessed.

"Yeah and guess who I ran into? Rachel Berry," he told him, going to the kitchen to grab a water bottle.

"Not surprising she's been here for a while."

Puck took a sip. "Oh and we slept together."

"Wait what?" Finn asked with his eyes widening in shock. "You slept with Rachel? How did that even happen?"

"Not entirely sure but a lot of drinks were involved."

"Wow. Where is she?"

"I'm assuming home by now. She was gone before I woke up so I'm guessing she was embarrassed and wants to act like it never happened."

"And that's okay with you?" he raised an eyebrow. "You have had this thing for her since high school."

"Perfectly fine with it. Not in the best position to be dealing with a relationship and everything that comes with it right now."

Not believing him, Finn said nothing more about the subject. Even though they never got a chance to date for a reason unbeknownst to him, Finn knew his best friend always had a soft spot for Rachel. He never understood why nothing ever happened between them and Puck would never tell but he could only assume it must've been bad.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Weeks later, Rachel ran to the toilet to empty her stomach. She never threw up or got sick for that matter so she was very confused why all of this was happening.

"You know, this is the third day in a row you've had to puke," Santana said from the doorway. "And you usually don't get sick."

"Yes I'm aware," she said, leaning against the bathtub.

Santana hesitated. "Did you use protection when you hooked up with Puck?"

Rachel went to respond but froze. She couldn't remember Puck ever pulling out a condom but that could be from being so drunk. Right? "Oh no."

"Don't panic. When did you last get your period?"

She grabbed her phone and checked her calendar before feeling her stomach drop. "I'm late. Santana I'm late."

"Okay don't start panicking yet."

"The common symptoms of pregnancy are throwing up and a missed period, how can I not panic?"

Seeing there was no way of calming her down, she sighed. "Alright relax. Let's just get a test so you can rule it out. For all we know, you could've eaten something bad and your period could be late because you're stressed."

"Right," Rachel nodded, trying to stay calm. "You're right, it could be a coincidence."

They went out and bought a test. Rachel couldn't even look the cashier in the eye when she bought it. The thought of her even possibly being pregnant worried her and she couldn't imagine what would happen if she was.

When they got back to the apartment, Rachel took the test and went back out into the living room with Santana, who was timing it.

"I can't believe this is happening to me," Rachel said. "Who would've ever thought I would be the one to run into this issue?"

"You're not the first girl to take a pregnancy test after a drunk hookup. When I was into guys I had a stash of them just in case," Santana tried to joke but Rachel frowned.

"How much more time?" As soon as she asked, the timer went off and she picked up the stick. "Oh my God."

"What's it say?"

Rachel handed her the test with a little plus sign staring back at them. "Positive."

As she started crying, Santana held her. "It'll be okay. We'll figure this out."

As much as she wanted to believe it, Rachel couldn't. She was pregnant from a one night stand with a guy who probably had forgotten all about it by now. She had no idea how they were going to figure this out.

Let me know your thoughts! Bye for now :)