Pirate's Cove had been shut down for quite some time now but the animatronic that stayed there still came to life at night when everyone was gone. The night guard was the only one there on nights as they were supposed to watch over the place and make sure nothing went bump in the night. Every night the animatronics came to life; Bonnie the Bunny, Chica the Chicken, Foxy the Pirate, and the star of the Pizzeria; Freddy Fazbear who was obviously a bear from having "bear" in his name. Freddy and the others try to kill the guard and Foxy always tries to help but when he leans into the office to warn the guard, they die from a heart attack. Then Freddy, Bonnie, and Chica stuff the dead body in an empty unused Freddy suit to wither away.

The forgotten red fox never knew why he had been shut down, he always thought it had something to do with the Bite of '87. He hadn't meant to hurt the poor child; hadn't meant to bite her frontal lobe. He didn't want to hurt anyone ever again. It had always been an accident; the bite had been. He didn't mean to hurt the innocent child.

"Argh, matey's," Foxy's voice box bellowed beneath his red fur. "Time for ye to walk the plank."

The small children screamed with joy and watched their favorite fox as they ate their pizza.

After Foxy's performance, the children went to the show stage to watch Freddy, Bonnie, and Chica sing their songs. One child though was not watching, she was at Pirate's Cove.

"I wuv you Foxy," she had a lisp.

"Har har har," Foxy's box then began to short circuit.

The little girl had been hugging him and pulled back, fear evident on her pale face.

Suddenly Foxy couldn't control himself and he lunged and bit down on the child's head. Blood exploded into his mouth and his metal teeth stayed locked in the skin of the child's cranium. Screams erupted from the other children, their parents, and the little girl too. Bones crunched under Foxy's sharp metallic teeth.

"Someone get that... thing off my daughter!" The mother of the girl screamed. "Shelly!"

Foxy's mouth vibrated as the girl tried to scream for her mother. He tried to release the grip his teeth had on her head but they were stuck.

Immediately two staff members came and tried to lift him off without making it any worse. After ten minutes of trying, they had finally gotten Foxy's secure jaws off of the child's frontal lobe. The girl had blood on her head, running down her face. She was unconscious and barely breathing.

"Shelly, oh my God," the mother was crying.

"Ma'am, if I were you I'd get your daughter to a hospital before she..." one of the staff trailed off.

The mother nodded, took her daughter and began to walk away. She turned around and said, "You need to get rid of that monster." Soon, the woman was gone, taking the girl who may not live because of Foxy with her.

Foxy was left brokenhearted, even though he had no heart. Pirates Cove was left with a sign that read "OUT OF ORDER" in big red letters.