A/N: This fic is set in the First Kiss universe. This idea came to me after a review from addrianna818, but I'm just now writing it. Kurt has 304 reasons to be with Finn.

All the Right Reasons
One

"I don't know why you would even want to be with me, Kurt," Finn said sadly.
This was Kurt's chance to tell him how he felt about him. But he couldn't. Not yet
"I have a list, if you want to see it," Kurt said. "I'm up to 304… reasons to be with Finn." ~ First Kiss.

***

"I want to see, Kurt. Please?" Finn gave him his trademark puppy dog look, but Kurt would not be swayed.

"No," the other boy said, and then went back doing his homework.

"Come on, I don't see what the big deal is."

"Finn, I don't know why you keep asking me." He looked up at his boyfriend.

"Cuz, I really want to know. You said I could see …"

"That was several months ago, and you had your chance, mister. Now, it's too late."

"Why?"

"Honestly, Finn. It's embarrassing. I started that list like in 8th grade. When I said you could see it, I was just so happy we were getting back together that I just wasn't thinking." Kurt paused. He wondered if Finn was thinking the same thing. That they broke up again the next day because he caught Finn kissing Rachel Berry. No sense in dwelling on that… it had all worked out. Finn was his boyfriend now, and they were very happy together. If only he could get Finn to drop this list thing. "There are just some things you don't need to know."

"I think you're gonna change your mind, Kurt," he said in a singsong voice.

Kurt shut his book then, giving up on what he had been working on. Honestly, it was hard to concentrate when Finn was around. Of course, he usually didn't mind…

"And why would I do that?" He tried to keep himself from smiling, but the earnest look on Finn's face was so adorable.

"Because I have my own list."

"Really?" Kurt said, tilting his head.

"Yeah. Don't you want to know what my list is about?"

Kurt smiled and patted the bed, motioning for Finn to sit next to him.

Finn joined him, a grin on his face.

"What's your list about, Finn?"

"Not sure if I should tell you…"

"Fine…" Kurt reached for his book, but Finn grabbed his hands.

"Okay," he said. "My list is called… 10 Reasons Kurt should share his list with Finn. I'm still working on it so that's why it's not very long."

Kurt giggled at him then. "Finn, you are so freaking adorable." He kissed him softly.

Finn continued to hold his hands.

"So are you going to tell me what's on your list?" Finn asked.

"Just did… that was number 101."

Finn smiled even wider. "Really? Wait… do you have the whole list memorized? I had to write mine down… and I only have 10."

Kurt giggled again. "No, but there are some that I remember by heart. Like how freaking adorable you are."

"Oh, I see," Finn said with a grin before kissing Kurt once again. This time he lingered, exploring Kurt's mouth with his tongue.

As they pulled apart, Kurt tried to remember what they had even been talking about… oh, yeah.

"So are you going to tell me what's on your list?" Kurt asked.

"I just did… that was number 1."

"What?" Kurt was confused. Finn either wasn't making any sense, or Kurt was still feeling the effects of the kiss.

Finn took out a piece of paper that had been folded up and stuck in his pocket. "Kurt should share his list with Finn because … he likes to kiss Finn."

"Um…" He really didn't know what to say to that. It didn't make any sense to him, but it probably did to Finn.

"Don't you see? You tell me something from your list and I… give you a kiss."

Now Kurt understood. "Okay, let's see… there's number 10 … Finn has an amazing smile."

Finn showed off his smile as he let go of Kurt's hands and moved them up to his face. This time when he kissed him, it was more insistent.

"I have to admit, Finn, your first reason was really good. What's your second?"

Finn looked down and for a second Kurt thought he wasn't going to answer. "It's just… sometimes I don't feel very smart … and I wonder why you'd want to be with me. Maybe if you tell me what's on the list …?"

Kurt tipped Finn's face up so he had to look at him. "Finn, I want to be with you because I love you … and I will always love you. Okay?"

Finn nodded his head as Kurt leaned into him. "Always," Kurt whispered before he kissed him again.

Kurt couldn't believe that Finn was still insecure about how he felt about him. They had definitely had a rocky start, but these last few months had been wonderful. He tried to convey how much he loved him in that kiss. Of course, he wanted to show him in other ways, as well, but his dad was home … and would probably be checking on them.

"Just in case you're interested," Kurt said as they pulled apart once again, "that was number 304. I stopped making my list after that one. It's the only reason that really matters."

"Kurt, you're so sweet," Finn said. "I love you, too."

Kurt thought maybe they were at a turning point.

"So what were your other 8 reasons, Finn?"

The taller boy just shrugged his shoulders. Kurt picked up the scrap of paper and looked at Finn. "Do you mind if I look?"

"No … go ahead," Finn said.

Kurt was surprised to see that the small piece of paper only held the two reasons.

"Finn?"

"I couldn't actually think of 10. I only thought of 2…" He paused and started looking around on the bed.

"What are you doing?"

"You'll see…"

He found what he was searching for… Kurt's pen. Finn then took the piece of paper out of Kurt's hands and wrote on it.

"Now I have three," he said proudly.

Kurt smiled at him as he took the paper Finn was holding out to him and read it.

His smile faded.

"Number 3," he read out loud. "Kurt should share his list with Finn because… Finn shared his list with Kurt."

Finn smiled triumphantly.

Kurt knew he had him then. He was surprised … and a little impressed.

"So, Kurt … about that list."

***

A/N: There's more to come. I have a few ideas about what's on Kurt's list. If anyone wants to contribute some list ideas just let me know. I think at the end I will actually list them… but no, not all 304. Who do you think I am? Kurt?

Don't forget… anyone who wants to bid on me at the Author's Auction, it starts tonight. Details on my profile.