Barry and Caitlyn are held captive by Zoom in his lair. The villain is frustrated that Caitlyn refuses to accept his feelings but is unable to bring himself to hurt her. But, there's Barry in the cage next to her, shouting at him to leave Caitlyn alone …
Well, I screwed things in the show. T-T SERIOUS disturbing NON-CON ahead. BE WARNED. This piece takes place after Zoom kidnaps Caitlyn, but with the idea that Barry wasn't able to phase out earlier.
"Caitlyn. Talk to me," Zoom said, frustration clear on his handsome face as he knelt by her side. "You know I care about you."
She turned away, lips held tight and arms wound about her knees. "I cared about Jay Garrick. You're a monster."
Teeth audibly grinding, Zoom tried to enfold her in a hug. Across from them Barry pounded on the carbine cage in which he was kept. "Get away from her!"
Zoom snarled and in less than a blink had grasped Barry by the neck and slammed him against the wall. "Shut. Up." he said evenly. "You're in no position to make demands." Zoom raised a clawed hand to eye-level. "I'd be quiet if I were you."
"Go ahead," Barry gasped. Caitlyn leapt to her feet, immediately realizing that Barry would do whatever it took to keep Zoom's attention focused on him. At Caitlyn's abrupt movement, Zoom started to turn, but Barry kicked into the man's sternum, forcing Zoom to stumble back.
For a heart-stopping few moments the two were a yellow-orange and black blur in the small confines of the cage, until Zoom got the upper hand and wrestled Barry onto his front, yanking his arm back at an unnatural angle and planting a knee in the small of his back.
"I've had about enough of you," Zoom told him. Barry grunted and twisted but could not break the man's hold. "The great hero of Central City. So useless. So helpless."
"Wait—you said you need the Flash's speed," Caitlyn said quickly, flattening herself against the glass in panic.
Zoom cocked his head, gaze speculative. "I do need the Flash alive. But perhaps not in one piece." At that moment Barry's efforts to free himself temporarily succeeded, just enough to flip himself over and throw Zoom off. The victory was small, though, and Zoom returned to his assault with a vengeance, punching and flinging Barry around like a rag doll until the boy was dazed, skin vividly bruised and bones undoubtedly fractured.
The thought that even now Zoom calculated his strength to a certain degree, chilled Caitlyn. "I'm sorry! I'm sorry! Do whatever you want to me, just stop!" she shrieked.
Zoom smiled at her. "It's too late for that. And I can't hurt you, Caitlyn. I love you."
"If you love me, then-!"
The monster shook his head regretfully. "I'll show you how much."
Barry choked as Zoom tightened his grip of Barry's throat and with his other hand ripped the front of the boy's suit. Caitlyn stared, uncomprehending. What was he doing? Barry's fingers scraped desperately at Zoom's wrists but he could not get free. Zoom continued to press until Barry's eyes rolled back and he fainted.
Then Zoom stepped back, allowing Barry to collapse in a heap. "How do I do this?" he asked, contemplating Barry's broken and exposed body. Shaking, Caitlyn realized that there was an obvious bulge in the front of Zoom's pants.
Shocked beyond belief, Caitlyn couldn't utter a word, even to hurl recriminations. Zoom casually ran a hand over Barry's naked chest until he's resting a hand on the boy's still covered crotch. He curled his fingers and after he's finished tearing at Barry, the suit was in crimson shreds around them. Barry groaned, eyes fluttering beneath his lids.
"I could always just shove into him," Zoom warned. "That might hurt more than it has to, though."
Caitlyn jerks back in terror. "Uh—uh—lube. You need lube. And to prepare—prepare him." In a second he's back with a jar of lubricant, and in a shaking voice she walks him through the process.
Zoom was just starting to lift Barry's bare left ankle to his shoulders when the boy regained consciousness. "What-?" he asks blearily. "Jay, what's going on?" Then recognition shoots through him, and he shoved at Zoom's shoulders in a panic.
Despite Barry's writhing, Zoom uses his much greater strength to pin Barry to the ground by his narrow hips. "I'm fucking you," Zoom informs him, and steadily pushed into him, inch by agonizing inch.
Barry gritted his teeth in a clear attempt not to give Zoom the satisfaction of screaming. Zoom paused thrusting to reach for his gloves and puts them on. Then he raked the clawed tips of his fingers down Barry's sides, forcing the younger man to throw his head back and cry out. Ribbons of blood immediately welled up and spread over his ribs, dripping onto the concrete.
After several interminable minutes of thrusting, Zoom tensed for a long beat, and ejaculated with an expression of intense pleasure. Barry moaned, the sound like that of a dying animal.
Caitlyn beat against the glass, her voice hoarse with screaming. "Barry!"
"This isn't a bad solution," Zoom mused, pulling out and wiping himself with a piece of Barry's suit.
Zoom leaned down and brushes a kiss on Barry's bruised mouth before tilting his head to look Caitlyn. "Love you, Caitlyn," he murmured. Then he's gone, leaving her and Barry alone in the cave except for the Masked Man curled away in the corner of his own prison.
Still lying crumpled and naked on the ground, with extreme effort Barry turned his head to see her. Caitlyn's heart broke at his empty expression. "Tell me something good, please," he whispered.
She tried. She managed to stammer of happy times with Ronnie, how he had opened her mind to new possibilities, to love and hope. Caitlyn tells him to hold on, that help is coming, they'll be rescued soon. But eventually she just rests her forehead against the glass, hands curling into impotent fists, and wept.
To be continued in Part 2 … it … kinda gets worse because Caitlyn gets involved.. WHAT AM I DOING.