I DONT OWN GLEE OR ANY CHARACTER (I WISH)

Rachel's POV: So, I am in the boys bathroom, sitting on Noah Puckerman's lap. I knew this was going to happen. Honesty I started to like spending time with him. I actually kind of started to get real feelings for him. Well, it was great while it lasted. He looks at me and sighs.

"Im really sorry I ever did this to you."

"Its okay" I say to him, actually meaning it

"No. No, its not. You dont deserve this feeling. Rachel.. im sorry, but when the clock strikes 3:30 today.." He stopped, not wanting to continue

"You're choosing Football over Glee, which means we probably cant be together anymore." I finish for him quietly, trying to hide my sadness.

"Yes." He sighs loudly. "God I feel like such a bad Jew." He frowns

I smile slightly at him, kiss his forehead and get up. "Bye Noah" I whisper before walking out.

Pucks POV:

I watch her walk out the door and I pull out my Yarmulke and slap it onto my head. To be honest, I really started to like Rachel. Sure, she might be kind of crazy and over driven, but i dont actually mind it that much. Being with her was kind of refreshing. With her, it was real, unlike all those other girls i just slept with. I cant be with her when were both in completely different circles. Besides, she'll be fine without me. What the hell am i even thinking right now, why do I care about Rachel Berry? I didn't before. That was before. Fuck. I have actual, genuine feelings for Rachel freaking Berry. God, help me.

Later, almost 3:30.

I stand at the point between the locker room and the choir room, not knowing which way to turn. I looked at the clock, 3:27. Come on Puckerman, make a decision! Hurry up. ! 3:29! I see Mike and Matt walk toward the choir room. 3:30.. I heard the happy exclamations of Santana and Brittany and I knew which way to go.
I walk in, head down. I hear gasps and excited whispers. I look up and see Rachel's smiling face, her eyes light up, and she walks up to me.

"Are you sure about this, Noah? If you choose glee over football, you get a slushie facial every day." She tells me quietly

"Bring it" I say and smirk at her

She smiles widely and i pull her towards me and wrap my arms tightly around her. Now I know I made the right decision. She pulls away and takes my hand and drags me over to the rest of them.

Santana: Good to see you, Puckerman.

Puck: Yeah, you too Satan.

She winks at me and I shake my head at her, smiling. The others are all watching to door, clearly expecting Finn to walk in. They of course are going to be disappointed. I saw Finn walk to the locker rooms. Ill let them figure it out n their own though. They all thought Finn was some loyal leader. Guess they were wrong. I look down at Rachel to see her not looking at the door, but at me. I Smile at her and turn back to the door.

"Okay. Lets get started you guys." Mr. Schue says, not wanting to mention their missing male lead.

"Oh, well. We dont need him." Rachel shrugs, walking to stand in her place

I look at her, shocked. Does she actually not care that Finn isn't here? Does this mean she's over him?

"How about we try with Puck and Rachel lead on Dont Stop Believing?" Mr. Schue says

I look at him, eyes widened. I glance and Rachel and she grins and nods at me. I walk over and take Finn's normal place. The music starts and I start to sing. When we finish, me and Rachel are standing in front of each other, incredibly close.

"That was really great you guys! Puck, wow! That was awesome guys! Lets run it again. " Mr. Schue beams

I grin. This day just keeps getting better.

End of the week (Friday)

So, Mr. Schue somehow managed to convince Finn to come back. Of course, he walks in as if he never left, with a cart of slushies. Just as expected, everyone crowds around him like he's some sort of saint. Everyone except me, and Rachel, who is leaning against me, my arm around her shoulders. Yeah, things have been going pretty good with me and her. I think she's someone I could be with for a while. Then i look back at Quinn and I remember. I need to tell Rachel about the baby. I just hope she wont hate me. I glance back at her, sipping on her slushy. Before I know it, shes counting dwn from three and were all throwing our slushies' on . We all break out laughing and I see Finn glancing at me and Rachel, so I pull her closer to me, giving him a small glare in the process. I know he's supposed to be my best friend, but i cant help but get annoyed on how much they all idolize him.

"Alright guys! From the top!" exclaims

Finn goes and stands in his original spot. I start to walk back to my old spot when I hear a voice speak out.

" , dont you think its a little unfair to just give Finn back his lead spot just like that? He wasnt here for days.. Noah has been working so hard. Finn just came back." Rachel states

I look over at her, she has her arms folded across her chest, and her hip cocked out. I look around at the others, Santana has a smirk on her face as well as Mike and Matt, Quinn looks pissed, and Finn is just staring at her in shock, and most of the others just look confused. Thats my girl.

"Yeah, and Puck was doing a great job. But this song originally had Finn on lead. Im sorry Puck, but next time you'll most definitely have an opportunity for a lead if you want it." says to us

"Well since were switctching things around again...Quinn. I think you should take the female lead. You and Finn would have so much more emotion than me and Finn afterall." Rachel says and moves to take Quinn's spot giving Quinn a slight push forwards. I go to stand next to her, grabbing her hand.

"Thanks for trying." I whisper to her

"You deserve the lead. If you aren't singing opposite me, I dont want to be the lead either." She replies

Wow, I think im actually changing this girl. She would have never done that before. We go over the number with Quinn and Finn on lead. Quinn's not even close to as good as Rachel. We practice a couple more times then practice is over.

Rachel's POV

dismisses us for the day, and I go to grab my bag. I do and turn around and Noah's waiting for me. I smile and walk to him.

"You ready?" asks me

"Yeah." I smile at him

He takes my bag from me and we walk to his truck together. Being with Noah has really changed me even if weve only been together for like 3 days so far. Im completely over Finn now, and feel nothing more than friendships towards him. Maybe now Quinn can stop trying to take me down if I make it clear I am not going after Finn. I snapped out of my thoughts and saw Noah staring at me with a hint of concern in his eyes.

Pucks POV

We walk to my car and when I go to open the door for Rachel I see her staring into space, her eyes glassy looking. I let out a low whistle, trying to get her attention. Nope. I start to say her name and then say it louder and she finally looks at me.

"Rach. You okay?"I ask, frowning in concern

"Sorry. I was just thinking." she says

"What about?" I wonder

"I was thinking that maybe Quinn can stop trying to ruin me since im over Finn." she says thoughtfully

"She still giving you a hard time? What a bitch."

"Its okay. Maybe i desevered it. Though I never tried to actually tried to break them up or anything like that. It honestly feels kind of good that she considered me a threat. She's always telling me how much better she is, yet she put so much energy into keeping me away from Finn. Clearly she's just insecure about her relationship." she shrug

"Fuck that shit. You don't deserved to be targeted by Quinn just cause she is insecure about her relationship with Saint Finn. " I say, fists curled.

"Yeah I guess youre right."

"Babe, of course im right. You're an awesome, hot Jew. You dont need to take her bull." I smirk

She smiles at me and i pull into her driveway, get out of the car and rush to her side and open her door for her. I walk with her to her front door and wait as she unlocks it. She steps in and turns around to face me.

"Thanks,Noah." She says

"No need to thank me, its my job as your boyfriend to at least to drive you home from school." I shrug

"I didnt just mean for the ride." She smiles at me

"Well I meant it. Anyways, what are your plans for tonight?"

"Ill probably just curl up on the couch and watch a movie or something, why?" she wonders

"I want to take you out tonight. On a real date. We havent really gone out as a couple. School doesnt really count. So, how bout a real first date, Berry?"

" I'd love that, Noah. My dads are out of town for while anyways. Its about 4:30 now. How about 7?" she asks checking the time on her cell phone.

"Cool. Ill pick you up at 7 then?"

"Yeah. See you then."

I walk away with a smirk on my face. This is gonna be the most badass date ever.

Hope you liked it. Give me some reviews! Good, bad, whatever. Ill take any criticism so I can make improvements and change things to make my story better as I go on! Thanks for reading!