"What's wrong flamebrain? I never see you think like this.", Gray asked the pink haired dragon slayer who looked up "I'm damn horny. I need to find a way to get Happy out of the house so I can touch myself.", Natsu thought out loud and it was only when Gray started laughing that Natsu realized he had said that out loud.

Gray put his hand on Natsu's shoulder and told him. "Why touch yourself when you can have a girl touch you. Come with me tonight. We're getting laid.".

That evening Natsu met up with Gray and they went to a club together. "It's pretty simple. Buy a girl some drinks, get comfortable with her and ask her if she's up to something more intimate.", Gray explained the dumbfounded dragon slayer. He had never had a girlfriend before, let alone showed any interest in girls. Gray thought for a long time that he was asexual, maybe gay,maybe gay for him. Gay for Gray, it still sounded funny.

They went inside the club and Gray started scanning the room for a potential sex partner for the night. His eyes met with a blondine with a big bust. She looked slightly older and winked to Gray "I've found someone. Good luck for you too.", Gray told him and walked over to the Girl.

Natsu looked around but didn't immediately find someone. It didn't help that all of the people in the club were bigger than him and he couldn't look over their heads. He walked to the bar and ordered something when suddenly a voice next to him asked "Hi. Are you okay? You look stressed out.". Natsu looked to his right and saw a girl sitting next to him. "Yeah. I'm fine...", Natsu sighed.

"You sure. You can tell me if you want, that helps most of the time.",she said in her cheery voice "I'm Elie.", the girl said, her two brown pigtails going up and down. "I'm Natsu... It's my best friend Gray. I accidentally told him that I was horny this afternoon and now he took me here to find a girl and have a good romp. But he doesn't know I'm gay. For him. I don't want to lose my virginity to some stranger. I want to lose it to him.

"Is he that raven haired guy that's talking to my sister?", Elie asked. Natsu looked over and nodded. "What if I'm the Girl you're taking back and I arrange something with my sister. Maybe he loves you too. You never know.", Elie encouraged Natsu. "I don't know. If he was gay he wouldn't be picking up girls so often, would he?", Natsu asked. "I don't know. You're gay too. And yet here you are, searching a girl that is willing to give you some sexual relief.", Elie said. Natsu wanted to protest. It hadn't been his idea to pick up a girl. He didn't even like girls. "I'm a lesbian too. Yet here I am, willing to be that girl that you need for your sexual frustrations.", she added with a smile.

"You sure you are willing to do this?", Natsu asked. He wanted to be sure. None of them should be doing this without wanting it. Sure, his first time might not be with Gray. But he would never be Gray's first either. And he would be doing it together with Gray. And Elie seemed like a nice girl. "Sure. You seem like a nice guy. And you're quite handsome too. Well, for a guy that is.", she answered. Natsu took her with him to where Gray and Elie's sister were and touched Gray's shoulder to get his attention from a full make out session with the blonde.

"What a coincidence your friend has just managed to pick out my little sister. Of all the beautiful, and not lesbian, women at this club.", the blonde, who's name was mumy, well her nickname at least, said.
"Well, how about we go back to my house?", Gray proposed. Mumy nodded, already eager to strip the clothes off this boy. What he hadn't stripped off himself at least.

They arrived at Gray's home and Gray showed the two girls the bedroom. Then he took Natsu with him to the bathroom. "Strip off your clothes.", Gray ordered him and Natsu looked confused for a moment before he slowly started to strip off his clothes. When he was standing there in only his boxers, Gray shook his head and pulled his boxers down also. Natsu immediately reached down to cover up his crotch but Gray held his hands up. "Holy cow Natsu. If that girl wasn't a lesbian she would be very happy.", Gray complimented his endowment but all Natsu could think was 'Don't get hard. Don't get hard. Don't get hard."

"How did you even get a lesbian to have sex with you?", Gray asked. He had once tried without knowing the Girl was a lesbian and he got hit. "How did you get the gay guy to come with you to a bar and pick up some chicks?", Natsu asked in return.

"You're gay!? I should've expected it, but still!", Gray yelled maybe a little bit too loud. "Just shut up about it. If I could change it, I would. I just want to be normal.", Natsu told his raven haired friend. "Natsu, you're anything but normal. I think that you being gay is about the most normal thing about you.", Gray answered. Natsu looked down and pouted a little when he realized Gray could be right. "Anyway, here.", Gray said and face Natsu a little square package. He inspected it closely and sniffed it a little. "It's a condom. We don't want them to get pregnant, do we?", Gray asked Natsu. Natsu shook his head.

Gray stripped too and Natsu muttered "I'd still rather have my boxers on. I feel embarrassed like this.". He knew it wouldn't change Gray's mind anyway. Gray was a nudist. Well he stripped all the time. "You're gonna have sex with her and you don't want her to see your cock. Good luck I'd say", Gray laughed and pulled Natsu with him.

Gray pushed open the door of the bedroom and when Natsu was pulled in he saw the two girls sitting on the bed. Mumy was naked already but Elie was just sitting on the bed in her underwear. She looked at Natsu and her eyes drifted down to his crotch. Her eyes grew big for a moment and she blushed. Natsu felt something too. He wasn't sure if it was because of Elie or because of the fact that Gray was so close behind him.

Gray pushed Natsu forwards to Elie and Natsu sat down on the bed next to her. Gray walked over to the other side of the bed where Mumy was sitting and almost immediately started making out with her.

Natsu and Elie end both sitting on the bed in an uneasy silence when suddenly Elie asked "Hey. Can I touch that?", and pointed to Natsu's cock. Natsu blushed fiercely at her question and stammered "Y-yeah. Sure. I-I guess that's how sex works, right?". "I wouldn't know.", Elie cheerily said again. "You're still a virgin, right?", she asked Natsu. He had told her that he didn't want to lose his virginity to a stranger but to Gray. And even though he had said he didn't want to lose it to a stranger, Elie didn't feel like a stranger anymore. 'Well, you don't let a girl touch your cock every day.', Natsu thought.

Elie reached out for his cock and wrapped her hand around it "That's good. I'm- Woah! This feels weird. It's soft but hard at the same time!", Elie said way to enthousiast. She squeezed it tighter and Natsu tried his best not to get erect. "Elie. If you keep that up, I'll.", Natsu said but couldn't finish his sentence as his cock started raising. Elie watched in amazement as the once limp organ now got erect.

Elie suddenly wanted to try something and dove down on the cock of the pink haired teen. Natsu was shocked by her action and wanted to pull her head off his cock. But when he pulled her head backwards; she sucked hard, her cheeks hollowing, and Natsu's eyes rolled back in his head and his breath came put as a weird ragged moan-like something. This made Gray look over and he saw Natsu getting his, obviously, first blow job ever and apparently he was enjoying it.

Natsu brought her head back onto his length and pulled it back again when she was as far as she could get. "Elie.", Natsu whispered breathlessly. He loosened his grip on the girls head so she could pull back if she wanted too. She did so and Natsu felt a bit disappointed actually. But she went back down on his cock and this time even further than the last time. When the tip of his cock hit the narrow space of her throat Natsu couldn't hold back a moan.

Natsu was having a hard time not coming into her mouth when she suddenly cupped his balls. Natsu lost control for just a moment but quickly regained it again. But just then Gray looked over to him and the look of those piercing, deep blue eyes made him lose him and he came in Elie's mouth in hot spurts.
The brunette didn't expect this and gagged in the thick fluid. Spit out a big part but managed to swallow some too.

"Hey Natsu. Are you ready playing around now? Let's do this together.", Gray said. Natsu knew what Gray meant and that he wanted to do this together with Natsu for his first time made him feel so happy and special. He took the package of the condom and ripped it open. But he didn't really know what to do now. He looked questioning at Elie but she just shrugged, shaking her head "Like the lesbian would know."

Gray looked over to check Natsu and saw he didn't knew what to do. Gray sighed and snatched to condom out of his hands. "First, you need to get hard.", Gray told Natsu. "I can't just get hard like that out of nowhere.", Natsu explained Gray who sighed even louder and told Natsu. "If you tell anyone about this I'll tell the guild all of your little secrets.". Natsu nodded nervously and Gray gave Natsu's cock a few strokes. Having Gray stroke him caused him to immediately go hard and Natsu blushed.

Gray pinched the tip of the condom and slid it down Natsu's length. When it was all covered, Gray gave it one more stroke to make sure it was good "Does it feel good? Is it a good fit?", he asked. Natsu nodded "It's good. Maybe a bit tight, but good anyway.".
"Yeah, I never expected you to be bigger than me so I just bought two of my size.", Gray explained. As he was now lining up in front of Mumy's entrance, waiting for Natsu to get ready too.

Natsu inhaled nervously and hardened his eyes. He, too, lined up in front of Elie.

Gray grabbed his cock and guided it in Mumy. When he was fully seated he groaned and looked over to Natsu, who was struggling getting his cock in. He took his cock firmly in his hand and pressed it against Elie's entrance. He pushed a bit harder and finally the tip disappeared into the opening. When he pushed more inside, Elie suddenly grabbed his arms and clawed at them. "A-are you okay?", Natsu asked the brunette. She nodded painly "Just put it in already."

"Was your sister a virgin?", Gray asked Mumy, who nodded. "Your friend too?", she asked him "Yeah..."

Natsu was finally fully seated and he was panting "God, this is much better than touching myself.", Natsu stated and Gray chuckled at Natsu's words. Of course this was better than jerking off. Gray slowly started moving his hips and Natsu slowly let his instincts tell him what to do. He pulled his hips back; and when only the tip was in, he slammed back inside making Elie gasp. Natsu quickly got an idea of what he had to do and started slamming his hips into the Girl. "Natsu~!", she moaned and blinked away some tears. Natsu didn't knew if it were tears of pain or pains of pleasure but Natsu didn't care at the moment. He was too far into his cloud of bliss to stop his body from acting purely on instinct.

Natsu took Elie's mouth, never stopping the movement of his hips for even a second. When he released her mouth from his, she told him "Natsu. I'm not gonna last much longer. Please, hurry up already!". Natsu, who was too far to get our words, just nodded and grabbed her hips. He slammed her hips down in time with his thrusts and this seemed to be even more intense as Elie screamed his name the first few times he did this.

Natsu felt his orgasm creeping down his back all the way throughout his body to his cock. He felt it heat up and his thrust quickly became sloppy and fast with the need for release. When Elie came and her muscles clamped down around Natsu's cock, he felt himself on the verge of breaking "Just... A little more...", he said through clenched teeth and ended his sentence with a groan. After only a few more thrusts he came too, filling the condom with white fluid.

He pulled out of Elie and collapsed next to her on the bed, feeling the condom starting to slide off his now shrinking cock. "I should probably get rid of this.", Natsu guessed and sat upright. He slid the condom off his cock and made a knot in it to keep the fluids inside before he threw it in the trash can.

Gray was just finishing too and Natsu watched with longing eyes as Gray got his orgasm. He settled back down on the bed and felt said. Gray would never be his first, he would never be Gray's first, he would never even be Gray's.

Mamie asked Gray if she could take a shower and Gray told her where the bathroom was. She pulled her sister with her and Natsu just sat down on the bed. Naked and sad.

Suddenly a body slumped over him and Gray's voice whispered in his ear "You're gay, right?". Natsu swallowed hard at the question. He had told Gray earlier that he was gay and now he asked it himself. Like he was emphasizing the fact. "Yeah. Why?", Natsu managed to ask without stuttering. "I wanna try something.", Gray told the pink haired boy who was stunned. Gray Fullbuster, his crush since two years, wanted to try stuff with him that needed to ask Natsu for if he was really gay.

Natsu tried looking at Gray to see if he was joking but met Gray's lips instead. A bit unsure of what he should do, he eventually still kissed back Gray. When they broke up Natsu was curious "What do you want to try?", he asked. "I want you to top me. I wanna feel what it is like to be topped.", Gray explained. Natsu's eyes grew big and he almost fainted upon hearing this. Gray wanted to be topped . By him! His dream would be coming true if he accepted this. Natsu hesitantly nodded his head. Still afraid this would be just a joke and said "Sure."

"Relax flamebrain. I'm sure this is secretly one of your fantasies so just do it.", Natsu blushed and tried to protest but ended up stuttering. "I've never seen you as pathetic as you are now matchstick."
"Just shut up. I've never done this before.", Natsu told Gray. Gray shrugged but suddenly remembered something. They would need lube. Lots of lube. He tossed the bottle that was on his nightstand to Natsu.

Natsu smiled nervously. He breathed in and steeled himself before drizzling some lube on his fingers and on Gray's tight hole. When he inserted his first finger, Gray inhaled sharply and shut his eyes tight "You need to relax.", Natsu told him "Otherwise it'll only hurt. And I don't want to hurt you while doing intimate things.".

Gray looked back to see if Natsu was joking but found Natsu looking at him with a soft expression. He flashed a smile at Gray and this caused Gray to relax a bit. Natsu moved his finger in more but Gray's muscles clenched again "Relax.", Natsu told him a second time. "I'm trying. But it's not easy for me to relax when you are fingering my ass.", Gray said and emphasized the you. "Then think of me as a beautiful girl. I don't know. You're the one that asked for this.", Natsu bit back, a little hurt by what Gray had said.

Gray's breathing pattern changed and soon his muscles loosened up. Natsu started circling his finger around and when he added a second finger Gray's muscles tightened for a moment but quickly loosened up again. When Natsu was curling and scissoring his fingers inside of Gray, he suddenly hit a bundle of nerves that made Gray moan and whisper a name under his breath. It was just a mere whisper, to faint for any normal person to hear; any person but Natsu who was enraged.

"From all people to fantasise about, you choose Lucy!?", Natsu yelled angrily. "What!? You're gay so it's not like you would take her now.", Gray said. "She's still my best friend. I won't let you fantasise about her. Just think about me if you're going to think of anyone.", Natsu growled and thrust a third finger inside. When Gray was stretched out enough for Natsu's liking Natsu told him. "I'm going in. Are you still sure about this?". Gray hummed and nodded. This was happening.

Gray didn't even know why he had asked that. He wasn't gay. And this was Natsu. But when he finished inside of Mumy, he had looked over to Natsu and saw the look in his eyes. He looked sad. Jealous maybe. And he didn't know why, but he never wanted to see that look in those green eyes again. Maybe that was why he had agreed to this...

He felt Natsu push the tip of his cock against his entrance and automatically tensed up. Natsu wanted to push his cock inside but Gray was tense so his cock slipped up "Gray~", he whined "Don't fucking tense up if I want to enter you!"

Gray laughed at Natsu and loosened his muscles again. Natsu tried pushing in once more and succeeded this time. He pushed in all the way and when he was seated once more tonight he could feel it.

Different body
Different gender
Different sensation

And he certainly liked this. He was inside of Gray and those muscles were clenching down on him hard. He had to restrain himself to not lose it that same moment. "Natsu! Move. Please.", Gray begged. Natsu did as told him and got a hold on Gray's hips. He slowly moved his cock back and when only the top was inside of Gray, he slammed back inside, hitting Gray's prostate in the process. "Guh!", Gray moaned loudly. He had almost yelled Natsu's name but he didn't want to go that far. He was sure Natsu would like it; and maybe it was the fact that Natsu would like it that made Gray not want to do it.

Natsu kept going at a fast pace, his hips practically snapping inside of Gray and it was surprisingly good to Gray who had thought this was only going to hurt for him. Natsu had turned him and Gray was staring at all the faces Natsu made while thrusting inside of him now.

Natsu's eyes were closed shut, only opening a few times to check on Gray, his mouth was open and he was panting and his hair; those pink locks sticker to his forehead with sweat and the pink spikes that always were in his hair seemed to have disappeared. "Beautiful...", Gray said without even realizing it and a the blush on his face darkened even more. Pink really looked good on Natsu.

Suddenly Natsu's hand reached over to Gray's cock and started stroking it. "Gray. I... I won't last much longer.", Natsu managed to get out. "Me neither Natsu. You're amazing.", Gray complimented the younger male as his thrusts got sloppier and more needy.

Natsu eyes rolled back in his head and his whole body made spastic movements when he came. Gray felt the jets of seed shoot out inside of him and Natsu's little thrust against his prostate combined with the feeling of Natsu's seed shooting put got too much and he too came hard and fast, so he couldn't even warn Natsu.

Natsu rolled off Gray and curled up next to him, inhaling that delicious scent "I love you.", he whispered, slowly falling asleep. "Stupid flamebrain.", Gray muttered as he spooned Natsu and drifted off too.

Mumy and Elie had seen the whole thing and decided to just leave the two of them here. Elie smiled. Natsu seemed pretty happy with Gray. He got his wish to come true. Even though she just knew him not even a day, she felt bonded with him. Like they knew each other for years already. He was a nice guy.

When the girls had left, Gray was woken up by the door closing and took a better look at the pink haired boy all curled up in his chest. It made his heart skip a beat. "Stupid flamebrain, making me fall for you..."