Idea By: Sunsetlover23 & CMS4ever

"I still think we should all consider Finn and I to sing at nationals again, right guys?" Rachel said, batting her eyes.

"Save it Berry, we obviously kicked butt without you and Finn singing together before so why start now" Santana said, braiding Brittany's hair.

"Relax guys we got a long way before nationals. We should just focus on more important things, like who wants to give Puck the answers to the next math test" Puck smirked, leaning back in his chair.

"Oh be quiet Noah, nationals is more important than some stupid math test, right Finn?" Rachel said.

Finn, who was too busy banging his heart out on the drums, finally looked up "What? Oh sure Rach, whatever you say" Instantly back on drums.

"You know what I think Puck's right, we should all take a break together from all this musical stress and do something fun" Artie said.

"I dare Rachel, to break into the school and stay for the whole weekend." Sugar cried out from her magazine.

" W-What b-but that's….." Rachel began

"I second that" Santana said shooting Rachel a smug look.

"Third" Kurt said

"KURT, you're supposed to be on my side" Rachel snapped.

"C'mon Rach, you're the one that needs a stress releaser" Kurt said glancing at his nails.

"Don't even bother Kurt, Goody two shoes over there can't even steal from the 99 cent store" Puck said. Santana and Mercedes snickered.

"B-b-b ut…" the bell rang before Rachel could even finish. Everybody grabbed their stuff as they began to leave.

"Don't worry Rachel no one will make fun of you for chickening out" Mercedes said passing her.

"Want me to come with you?" Finn whispered in her ear as they walked hand in hand down the hallway.

"There really is no way out of this is there?" Rachel sighed.

"Hey think about it this way, me, and you, alone in a dark, big school. Any ideas on what to do over the weekend?" Finn smirked down on her.

"I could think of a few" Rachel said. Finn's grin became even wider

"We should totally do some vocal exercises and listen to Barbara Streisand, oh think of the possibilities." Rachel cried out. Finn groaned. They really need to work on the whole communication crap Tina and Mike were always talking about.

"No Rachel I mean..." Finn went down to whisper to Rachel.

"FINN HUDSON!"

The day passed on and soon night began.

"This is it Rach, me and you take on school after hours" Finn said

"Hey fail dancer and wannabe Barbara over here" a voice cried out.

"Santana is that you?" Rachel said coming closer to the voice.

"And the rest of us" another voice cried out. Standing before Rachel and Finn, were Mercedes who was sending Sam regretful looks, Tina wrapped up in Mike's arms, Brittany holding her precious cat Lord Tubbington, Rory and Artie glaring daggers at on another, Santana blowing a big piece of gum, Sugar who was still glancing at the magazine from earlier today, Puck texting rapidly while, Blaine and Kurt were conversing.

"What are you all doing here" Rachel asked in awe.

"We couldn't let you have all the fun now could we" Sugar said putting an arm around Rachel's shoulder.

"Yeah and besides who wants to spend the night at home watching parents either making out or fighting with each other" Puck said finally putting away his phone.

"C'mon it's freezing outside and I promised to show Lord Tubbington around" Brittany said. They all went in easily, courtesy of Puck.

"I think we should all stick together who knows…" Artie began.

"Please, Artie will just go in pairs, plus we all have cell phones don't we?" Tina said dragging Mike down the corridor. Soon everybody was gone from the main hall except Sugar, Rory and Artie.

"Hey don't you guys ever wonder what it would be like to perform in a dark empty auditorium" Sugar said stuffing her magazine back into her bag.

"Well it wouldn't really be the first…." Rory began

"C'mon lets go" Sugar said pushing Artie's wheelchair.

"Stay here Artie, so I can get scaredy-cat Rory" Sugar said turning around. A few seconds later she came back with Rory.

"Let's go on stage Rory, need help getting there Artie?" Sugar asked, dragging Rory to the stage.

"No but, let me hold your flashlights that way the lights can hit the both of you" Artie said. Both Rory and Sugar handed their flashlights to Artie, and finally they were on stage.

"What do you want to sing Sugar? I was thinking…" the flashlights began to flicker before shutting off completely.

"Sugar, Artie are you ok" Rory asked worriedly.

"Yeah I'm fine, Artie?" Sugar cried out while leaving the stage to get Artie.

"I'm fine too" Artie said. Then suddenly the flashlights flickered back on, only to hear Sugar's scream.

"RORY" Sugar cried out. Artie looked up to see Rory who was up many feet from the ground. Rory was still as the tight rope was coiled around his neck.

"No, no this cannot be happening" Artie said shocked. Sure he disliked Rory, but he didn't want him to die.

"Sugar we need to call for the police right now" said Artie. Taking out his phone he began to dial.

"NO. Do you want us to get in trouble?" Sugar said taking the phone from him.

"Sugar stop being ridiculous" Artie said reaching for his phone. At that moment the flashlights were off yet again.

"Artie don't move we need to be close" Sugar said, standing still. But then Sugar was pushed to the ground.

"Artie what's going on" Sugar cried out. Silence. Then Sugar began to feel something hard pressed down on her throat.

"ARTIE!"

Rory Flanagan. Age 15-16 at time of death. Cause of death: Hanged to death. Location: William McKinley High school auditorium.

Sugar Motta. Age unknown. Cause of death: Suffocation. Location William McKinley High school auditorium

Please review!