So I'm starting another new story. And it's basically about Lucas and Nathan who both have to make a choice between two girls that are important to them. Lucas has to choose between Lindsey and Brooke. and Nathan has to choose between Haley and Charle (who is a character I made up because I didn't think any of the characters would fit the place). You can probably guess who their going to pick but I think it's going to be a good story. So it's going to have Naley, Brucas, LucasxLindsey, and NathanxCharlie. I would have made it Brooke against Peyton but I really don't like Peyton and Lucas together so yeah. Please enjoy :)


I love you so much. The thought of not seeing you every day, hurts me so much. I want you to be mine forever. So, you have two choices, you can leave me standing where I am, and never see me again or you can marry me.

You don't know happy I am to find you. I want you more than I've wanted anyone else on this planet. You are the girl for me. I hope you know this because I've never been more sure of anything in my life. I think I've always known that, I was just afraid to admit it. I love you.

Lucas Scott rushed through the campus trying to get through crowds of people; his mom had been dead set on finding him a respectable girl to marry, and he was about to be late for his blind date. He normally wouldn't care if he was late, but this girl had been suckered into it as well by her mom so he figured he'd give it a shot. From his mom's description, Lindsey was smart and beautiful and was going to Duke just like him, working towards being a publisher for Fuller Bros. This company published more books in a year than any other company in the country. Ironically enough they were meeting in a book store so they could go to the café next door.

"Finally" Lucas thought as he reached the doors to Barnes and Noble. He looked towards his watch and noticed he made it here with 5 minutes to spare, so he started to look around for any good books. While looking through a book, he looked up to see a beautiful girl, reading a book while walking, and he couldn't help but be intrigued. So he did the subtle thing and "accidentally" bumped into her.

"Oh god, I'm so sorry I wasn't looking where I was going." Lucas apologized while helping the girl up.

"It's totally fine." The girl said while taking Lucas's hand, "It figures the one time I open a book, and I bump into someone. I think that's God's way of telling me to not read."

Lucas chuckled. "So what's a pretty girl like you doing in a book store, if you don't read?" he smirked, his signature Scott smirk he inherited from his father.

"My friend told me that I might really like this book if I gave it a chance. Of course I laughed in her face once she said it, but I figured I could try to read one book even if it kills me."

"So what book are you attempting to read?"

"Something Borrowed?" she laughed. "It's probably not something you'd want to read but my friend recommended it. Plus there's a movie coming out for it so I could just see that… or sparknote it."

"You should give reading a try, it's not that bad once you get used to it."

She smiled, "Maybe I will. It was nice meeting you… I totally don't know your name sorry."

"Lucas Scott." He answered while sticking out his hand. "And you are?"

"Brooke Davis." She smiled and started to walk away, but Lucas grabbed her arm before she could go.

"Do you think I could have your number?" Lucas asked with a hopeful smile.

"Sure." She took his phone and put her number in it.

"Thanks." He said and started to walk away.

"But you should know, the last two digits to that number aren't right." She smirked. "If you really want to call me, you'll have to find me again."

"Why would you do that?"

"So I can make sure you're not some creepy serial killer, who "accidently" bumps into hot girls only to kill them later on." Brooke smiled and skipped away.

Lucas was shocked, she had never met anyone like this girl, and he sure as hell was going to find her again to get those last two digits. She was drop dead gorgeous and outgoing and the type of girl that would balance him out.


Nathan Scott pulled up to the long familiar drive way of where his girlfriend, Charlotte Swift lived. Today was the day Nathan was going to introduce her to his parents. This is a monumental step for Nathan because he never brought a girl home; his life had always consisted of one night stands or two week relationships. But this girl was different, they had been going out for two months and it was still strong. This was all so new for Nathan and he didn't want to screw it up.

Nathan got out of the car and walked up to the house and knocked, waiting patiently for the door to open. When it did open, it was Charlotte's roommate Mia. "Hey Nate, you can come in, Charlie's just getting ready." The brunette said while moving out of the door way to let him in. "You know, Charlie's really nervous to meet your parents. She's afraid they won't like her." she hinted.

"My parents love everyone, they can't help it. Plus they know how important, Charlotte is to me, so they'll be on their best behavior." Nathan assured her. Hoping that Charlie would be down soon, and it seemed that she heard his thoughts because she was down a few moments later.

"Hey cutie, how's it going?" Charlotte smiled.

Nathan laughed, "It's going good. How about you sexy?" He heard a moan coming from the brunette next to him, "God you guys are sickly annoying. I'm gonna go before this get's anymore cliché."

They both laughed, and Nathan walked over to Charlotte and planted a sweet kiss on her lips, "I missed you." Charlotte smiled, "I missed you to boyfriend."

"We should go." Nathan said while pulling away.

"Do we have too?" She asked sneakily.

"I know you're nervous, but it's really nothing to be nervous about. My parents know how I feel about you so they're not going to be mean." He tried to reassure the beautiful caramel haired girl in front of him. "They're gonna love you. I promise." But aren't promises meant to be broken.

"Mom we're here!" Nathan shouted as they walked into the house. He heard laughter coming from the kitchen and he smiled. Haley. He brought Charlie through the hallway towards the kitchen and was delighted to see his mother and Haley laughing up a storm. "Hey mom, hey Hales." The two women looked over at him and smiled.

"Hello Nathan." His mother said as she walked over and hugged him. "And you are?" She asked with a fake smile, that only his son noticed.

"Mom this is Charlie, Charlie this is my mom Karen." Nathan introduced them.

"Hi, Mrs. Scott it's nice to meet you." Charlie smiled and shook her hand.

"Well I think I'm going to go." Haley said awkwardly standing up and gathering her stuff.

"Haley James you don't need to go." Karen said. "You just got here and I missed my daughter."

Haley smiled. "I really have to go, I have to meet Quinn and Clay or dinner."

"Well let me walk you out." Before Haley could protest, Karen was already walking towards the door. "I'll be right back Nate."

Nathan knew his mom, and this really wasn't a good sign. He hugged Charlie simply trying to reassure her that everything was fine.


"So what's your favorite book?" Lucas asked Lindsey. After his brief encounter with Brooke, he was surprised to see a beautiful young girl that happened to be his date. He mentally thanked his mom, as he found out they have so much in common.

"I actually don't have a favorite." Lindsey smiled, "I've read so many and I love all types I can't narrow all my options down to one." Lucas smiled, Lindsey was really something. "God, you probably think I'm some loser book worm, but I'm not, it's really nothing like that."

"No it's totally fine. I actually understand, books are what take me away from the drama in life. I've actually been writing a lot lately."

"Well I'd like to read what you have some time." Lindsey smiled again.

Gosh her smiles beautiful Lucas thought. "You have a really beautiful smile Lindsey." Hearing that made Lindsey's cheeks go red and she replied with a shy, thanks.

"So do you have any siblings?" Lucas asked curious.

"I'm an only child. Now you probably think I'm spoiled, and I guess I kind of am, but I'm grounded you know? Like my parents offer me things but I don't like taking stuff from them, I like being able to provide for myself." Lindsey explained. "Do you have any siblings?"

"I have a younger brother and a younger sister. Plus I have a good family friend that I consider my little sister. Nathan is 22 along with Haley who's not really my sister but I treat her like one. Then there's Lilly, she's only 5 but she's the smartest 5 year old I've ever met."

"I'm sort of jealous of you."

"Why are you jealous of me?" He asked incredulously. She was so perfect, if anything he should be jealous of her.

"Because you have siblings and I've always wanted one. I know that sounds silly but I just wish I had grown up with someone who I could be close too."

"Has anyone ever told you, that you're amazing?"

Lindsey blushed again, "Gosh if you make me blush anymore I'll be as red as a tomato."

Lucas smirked, "I like making you blush." They both laughed. "So why haven't our moms set us up on a date before?"

"Well I've actually lived her for a few months, I'm here for an internship at a publishing company, and depending on how well the internship goes, I might be down here for a while. But my mom moved down here a couple of years ago, she loves it here. I'm really glad that she's happy though. Ever since my dad died she hasn't really been the same." Lucas looked at her surprised.

"I didn't know your dad died. I'm so sorry." he fumbled.

"Thanks that's really sweet. But its okay it was two years ago, he had been really sick, and god finally took him away."

"It must have been really hard; I can't imagine life without my parents."

"It was and it still is some times. But on a happier note, I had a great time tonight, you're a really nice guy and I hope we can get together again." She smiled.

"Yeah, defiantly. I had a great time too." He smiled when he saw her smile. It was like a contagious disease. "It was good meeting you Lindsey."


Haley James sat on her front porch reading one of her favorite books. "Hey nerd, whatcha reading?" When she heard the familiar voice she smiled.

"A book, you should try it sometime, loser." She shot back.

"Okay, okay you win." Nathan put his arms ups in defeat, and walked up the steps of her porch. "So, I saw you today, but you couldn't get away fast enough, I thought I might have done something wrong."

"You didn't do anything wrong, I just had to meet up with Quinn, I'm going to be her maid-or-honor in her wedding."

"Quinn's getting married?" Nathan asked with a shocked face forming.

"Yup." she said making her 'p' pop, "Clay finally got the balls and proposed."

"Well that's great." A comfortable silence surrounded them. "So, I've missed you Hales. How was your trip?"

"It was amazing; I will defiantly be going back to Italy at some point in my life; which reminds me I got you something." Haley ran into her house to grab something. Nathan smiled, Haley would go away, and get ME something. She always takes care of others first.

Haley came outside holding something behind her back. "I know you told me not to get you anything, but I saw this and thought of you." Haley handed him the box and watched him open it would delight in her eyes. "Do you like it?"

Inside the box was a chain with a small basketball charm with the Italian colors on it. "Before I left, you mentioned your chain breaking and I know that you're still a hotshot basketball player, so I got it. It's okay if you don't like it, I understand if you don't. But in case you didn't I got you this too." She spoke at a thousand words a minute. "It's nothing fancy, just a picture frame but I went to the Leaning Tower of Pisa and did that picture of when you lean up against it when you push it." She laughed. "I thought you might enjoy it."

Nathan pulled her into a hug, "Haley James you are truly one of a kind. And I love both of my presents, even though I told you not to get me anything. So I think I should pay you back for not listening."

Haley looked at him, "You wouldn't dare." She got up and started to run away, seconds later she felt strong arms wrapped around her waist. "Nathan Royal Scott put me down."

"Not till you say I'm the best friend anyone could ever have, and the hottest, and you love me more than anyone else in this world." He commanded while running around the lawn with her in his arms.

"Never." Haley protested, refusing to give in.

"Fine but you asked for it." Nathan set her down and started tickling her sides.

"Nath- Nathan s-stop." She said through her giggles.

"Say it Haley." He wasn't going to give in.

"Fine, You a-re th-e bes-test friend anyo-ne could ev-er hav-e, and th-e ho-test, and I loooove yo-u more th-an an-yon-e else in the wo-rld." She conceded still laughing up a storm.

"Now was that so hard?" He asked rolling on to his back watching the sun set.

"It's always hard to lose. Especially if I'm losing to you." She laughed as she moved her long blonde hair out of her face.

"Well you should be used to losing to me."

"You're hilarious." she added sarcastically.

"And you love me more than anyone else in the world." Reminding her of a few moments earlier, earning a punch from the blonde.

"It's a good thing that's true." She moved to get comfortable and lay down next to him. "The sunset is beautiful."

"Not as beautiful as you." Nathan said with all seriousness. Making Haley blush, "Stop it Nathan."

"What it's true, you're gorgeous Hales. You're gonna make a guy really happy someday."

"Yeah, well, thanks. So tell me about Charlie, she seems really nice." In actuality the thought of Charlie was eating, Haley away inside. But she kicked that feeling aside because she would never be a cliché; she would never fall in love with her best friend. Or at least she wouldn't admit it. So instead she listened intently as Nathan described her.


"Mom I'm home." Lucas called out walking into the house.

"How did your date go Luke?" Karen asked intently.

"It was good mom, Lindsey's a great girl, and I think I might call her again."

"I'm so happy Luke, who knows maybe one day you'll get married and have kids and just love each other forever." she sighed dreamily.

"Let's not jump the gun mom; I don't see wedding bells anytime soon." Lucas chuckled. "Where's Nate, I want to see if he wants to play a game of hoops."

"He beat you to it."

Lucas walked outside to see his brother dribbling the ball up the court. "Hey bro, want to play a little one-on-one?"

"Why so you're sorry ass can lose again?" Nathan asked challenging him.

Lucas laughed, "Yeah right, what was the score the last time we played?" He said as he grabbed the ball from Nathan and made a shot.

"I was sick that day. So, how was the blind date mom set you up on?"

"It was good, Lindsey's a really nice girl and she seems really genuine, plus we like a lot of the same things. But there's a girl I met before the date that I can't seem to get out of my mind. She was just so unlike any girl here and she seemed really amazing."

"Lucas Scott, are you taking my spot as the family player?" Nathan laughed.

"No, I was just saying that both girls were amazing, and I hope I'll be able to be friends with the both of them."

"So now you're getting soft on me?"

"Oh, like you're really one to talk. How's that girlfriend of yours going? Two month is a pretty long time for THE Nathan Scott to keep a girl. What are you doing bribing her to stay with you?" Lucas joked.

"Ha ha. You are so funny. But no I really like Charlie, although she met mom and dad today, and mom was less than happy to meet her. I think she just needs time to warm up to me having a long time girlfriend."

"Or she needs time to get used to the idea of you having a long time girl friend other than Haley. You do know that mom and Mrs. James have been planning your wedding since you two for 6, right?"

"Mom knows that me and Haley are just friends and that's all we're ever going to be." Nathan said. Although he really didn't know what was going to happen in the future.

"Sure, if that's what you want to believe. But let's get this game started, after I beat you I need to take a shower."

"Good you're gonna need one to get the loser off of you after I win." And the two boys started their game. This is how the let go of everything; playing basketball.


So that's the end of the first chapter and I hope you liked it. I really think the story has potential so please read and review.

And in the story Lucas and Nathan are actual brothers not half, and Lucas is 24 and Nathan is 22.