My verison of Double Mama Drama. One piece of backround info you need is that Quinn is living with her sister Brooke and bother in law Andrew instead of with Finn. Let's get on with the show!
"No this can't be happening," Rachel Berry said as she stared down at the small stick in her hands. "I only did it once. I was on the pill and we used a condom." How can I tell Finn? she thought. She sat down on her bed and cried herself to sleep.
The whole Grease incident in Rachel's room led to a make-out session. "This feels so good Rach," he said between kisses.
"It does,"
"I want it to be more than this. Will you have sex with me?"
"Do you have a condom?"
"Right here," he said pulling it out of his left pocket.
"Let's go, my dads are out of town with Ben so there's no chance of us getting caught."
He striped off his shirt and pants as she did the same. Finn awkwardly put the condom on as Rachel laid down. "Just relax and let me move in." In three minutes they were having full-on sex. The condom broke right before Finn "erupted", and they didn't realize it.
It was 3 months since that night. Rachel's dads and brothers knew she was pregnant, but they were the only people to know other than Quinn. One afternoon Finn approached her because she was avoiding telling him about their baby.
"Rachel what have I done? You've been avoiding me everyday for the past 2 weeks."
"Finn, there's something I need to tell you."
"What?"
"I'm pregnant."
"How? We used a condom!"
"I asked my doctor and they said it most likely broke."
"Is it mine?"
"Yes, this little girl is yours."
"It's a girl?"
"Uh huh. Papa took me to the hospital when I kept throwing up and then they did an ultrasound."
"Rachel, I can't raise two babies!"
"Just think of it like having twins only 3 months apart."
"What about Quinn? I have to help raise my other daughter too."
"Finn, she already knows. When I found out I was pregnant I asked for her help."
"Does she know it's mine?"
"Yes, she was shocked for a little while but devoted that energy to help baby Scarlett."
"You already named it?"
"it's just what I want to call her while she's inside me."
"It's a pretty name for my pretty friend's baby, but I can't raise her. I'm sorry Rachel, but I need to take care of Quinn and Sophia."
"I knew you already named her!"
"Does it matter that I gave my first daughter a name!? I'm out of here!" Then he ran off.
"I'm sorry Scar, but it doesn't look like Daddy wants you," she mumbled under her breath and sat down with her back pressed against her locker and cried.
A short 17 seconds later a certain Noah Puckerman found her crying. "Rachel, why are you crying?" (A/N Puck lessened his badassness on Rachel after Sectionals and kind of likes her now)
"I'm pregnant with Finn's baby and he doesn't want her. He says it's too much for him."
"He probably should have thought of that before he had sex."
"I never thought I'd get pregnant. I used the pill and a condom! Turns out my stupid birth control pills were expired, and the damn condom broke! I don't have clue what to do," Rachel said and then put her head in her hands.
"Do your dads know about this?"
"Yeah. Papa thought something was really wrong with me when I threw up every hour and took me to the ER, but I knew about it before that."
"They all say I'm the couger, but I think that title goes to Finn now seeing as he has knocked up two girls in one year."
"What am I going to do Noah? Finn wants nothing to do with Scarlett. I can't raise this baby by myself."
"You're not going to do this by yourself. I'll help you raise Scarlett when she makes her grand apperence to the world. Come on let's get to glee."
"Alright let's go."
Quinn Fabray never thought she would be stuck in this position. She was pregnant with Puck's baby even though she was still dating Finn, but Finn had sex with Rachel, and now she is carrying his baby. That's why he came blubbering to her that afternoon.
"Quinn, I'm sorry I got her pregnant," he cried out. "We used protection and it all overwhelmed me and we did it. I don't have a clue on how I'm going to raise two babies!"
"You know Tina and Mercedes will help take some of this weight off her shoulders. You can't spend all you time worrying about Scarlett because you still have Sophia to worry about."
"How did you know she's calling the baby Scarlett?"
"Remember she asked me for advice."
"Oh."
"Finn, just go home and think straight. If you don't relax you'll die of a heart attack before either of your daughters come."
"Alright." With that Finn walked right out.
"Puck can you keep a secret?" he asked while they sat on the swings in the local park.
"Sure, what's up."
"I knocked Rachel up."
"Dude you got to stop doing that! Who's next Santana?"
"Dude I'm serious! I don't know what to do? This time I even took precautions! The fucking condom broke! I can't handle Rachel. I need to focus on Sophia and Quinn."
"But Rachel's baby is yours too! You can't just leave her!"
"I can and I will!" he shouted then ran all the way home.
"Would things really be this bad if we told him?" Puck thought aloud before walking back home.
