A/N: Halloween isn't for another few weeks but I couldn't resist writing this, the thought of Sami Zayn scaring the hell out of someone as a prank is funny.
The second Finn Balor heard his girlfriend's terrified screaming and the front door of his Orlando apartment being slammed and locked, he bolted out of his room and downstairs to find Amanda hiding behind the couch, the hood of her crimson red jacket covering her head as she rubbed her hands on her jean covered legs, trying to calm down.
"Mandy, you okay?! What's wrong?!" Finn asks after running to her and crouching down, resting his hands on her shoulders, Amanda out of breath from the screaming and trembling violently. Amanda pointed to the door, still frightened.
"Dressed in all black… he had a Scream mask on." Amanda says hoarsely, Finn realising what happened. Amanda tugged on Finn's hand as he tried to walk to the door but Finn lightly rubbed her shoulders and kissed her.
"It's okay lass, just stay here." Finn says softly in his Irish accent before standing up, walking over to the door and unlocking it, opening it and finding his and Amanda's friend, Sami Zayn, laughing hysterically and holding the mask in his right hand.
"Amanda, it's alright, kiddo! You can come out of hiding, you're not in danger!" Sami says, Amanda standing up from behind the couch as Sami walked in, closing the door before he and Finn walked over to Amanda, who wasn't shaking as violently and had pulled the hood of her jacket off of her head.
"Alright?! I mistook you for a terrifying psychopath who was trying to kill me!" Amanda says, still freaked out but also mad as Finn tried to calm her down.
"Sami, were you watching horror movies again?" Finn asks, remembering that Halloween was a few days away.
"Yeah… aw, come on. It's October, best time to watch horror movies. You know I would never harm either of you." Sami says as Finn pulled Amanda into his arms, rubbing his hand up and down her back as they hugged, Amanda resting her head on Finn's right shoulder.
"Sami, I get that you like Halloween but you should ease off of the pranks for now." Finn says.
"Mandy didn't scream when the three of us went to go see Blair Witch last month and there were plenty of scary moments in that movie." Sami says.
Amanda had managed to calm down, her and Finn kissing before they let go, Amanda walking over to Sami.
"I'll sic Bayley on you if you do that again. Hugs come in many forms, Sami." Amanda says quietly, Finn pulling her back.
"Okay now, no need to call Bayley just yet, lass." Finn says, wrapping his arms around Amanda's shoulders and kissing her forehead as she closed her eyes and rested her hands on his arms.
The two eventually let go and sit down on the couch, Finn once again wrapping his arms around Amanda as Sami sat down on the other couch, trying to find something on Tv as he scrolled down the guide, finding the El Rey network.
"Ooh, Miami Vice is coming on soon, the episode is Shadow In The Dark." Sami says.
"That one aired on Halloween, 1986. Only Vice episode to premiere on Halloween night." Amanda says, having calmed down now and was resting her head on Finn's left shoulder as he kissed her forehead again.
Amanda and Finn knew Sami liked messing with them sometimes… but jump scares could be a bit too much, especially with Sami Zayn involved.