Upon reaching their teen years, Baby Quackers, Baby Sweet Stuff, and Baby Fifi became deeply troubled. Baby Fifi had always believed it shameful that she was named after a dog and this belief turned her into a jealous yet outwardly happy pony with a near infinite number of play inflicted wounds. As for Baby Sweet Stuff, the miraculous ability to move her neck, a talent only granted to a select few ponies, had caused her to be shunned by the local pony community and placed in all sorts of special classes at the Lullabye Nursery. Baby Quackers merely sported a rebellious nature and enjoyed disobeying the truant officer at Lullabye Nursery. Alone, they were just a few lost ponies but together, they were lost ponies with high quality AAA maps made of their own far-fetched dreams of revenge.

The vast majority of ponies in Dream Valley were atheists, having no god and not desiring one except for maybe the Rainbow of Light or Megan, a human girl. Talking amongst themselves made the three juvenile delinquents realize their need for a religion and when they heard the words of Muad'Dib on government-funded television, they knew they had found a religion and, better yet, a form of revenge.

"What do you despise? By this are you truly known." –from "Manual of Muad'Dib" by the Princess Irulan

This particular Muad'Dib cult despised the other ponies. By this they came to be known as anti-social. Looked upon as the lowlifes of society, they knew that they were not the ponies to exact revenge. They needed someone with powers, someone of royal blood, someone like Paul Muad'Dib. These thoughts of having their own Muad'Dib were what inspired them to name their cult "Pony Gesserit" and start a breeding program. But they had no idea that the story of their Kwisatz Haderach would be eerily similar to, if not exactly the same as, the story of Muad'Dib.